id
stringlengths 3
7
| context
stringlengths 8
967
| statement
stringlengths 10
276
| entailment
listlengths 0
4
| neutral
listlengths 0
4
| contradiction
listlengths 0
4
| idk
sequencelengths 0
3
| label_count_round_1
dict | label_count_round_2
dict | label_set_round_1
sequencelengths 1
3
| label_set_round_2
sequencelengths 0
3
| error_labels
sequencelengths 0
2
| has_ambiguity
bool 2
classes | chaosnli_labels
dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
102857n | Expenses included in calculating net cost for education and training programs that are intended to increase or maintain national economic productive capacity shall be reported as investments in human capital as required supplementary stewardship information accompanying the financial statements of the Federal Government and its component units. | Net cost for college programs can be calculated as a way to increase productivity. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "923-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Colledge programs mentioned in the statement are included in education and training programs mentioned in the context, which are intended to increase or maintain productivity.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "923-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"shall be reported as investiments in human capital\" means that they can be included in the calculation as investiments in productivity.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "923-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Yes, college programs is kind of education that can increase productivity.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "923-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is those education and training programs that are intended to increase the producitvity. Not the NEt cost",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 60,
"n": 35,
"c": 5
} |
133243e | He watched the river flow. | The river roared by. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "461-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The condition of the river is not described in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "461-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear how the river flows",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "461-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that the river move steadily, while roaring means the opposite.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "461-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The river flowed, it didn't roar.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 22,
"n": 66,
"c": 12
} |
144408n | Today it is possible to buy cheap papyrus printed with gaudy Egyptian scenes in almost every souvenir shop in the country, but some of the most authentic are sold at The Pharaonic Village in Cairo where the papyrus is grown, processed, and hand-painted on site. | The Pharaonic Village in Cairo is the only place where one can buy authentic papyrus. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "618-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "People can buy authentic papyrus in the Pharaonic Village in Cairo, but there can be other places also sell it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "618-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Pharaonic Village in Cairo is the place to buy some of the most authentic papyrus, not the only place to buy authentic papyrus.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "618-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"some of the most authentic\" implies that there are other places that also sell authentic papyrus.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "618-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "You can buy it everywhere in the country",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 20,
"n": 39,
"c": 41
} |
104412e | After being diagnosed with cancer, Carrey's Kaufman decides to do a show at Carnegie Hall. | Carrey's Kaufman was diagnosed with cancer before deciding to do a show at Carnegie Hall. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "420-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement describe the same thing about Carrey's Kaufman.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "420-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Carrey's Kaufman was diagnosed with cancer first, and then decided to do a show.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "420-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Kaufmann decided to do a show at Carnegie Hall after he is diagnosed with cancer",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "420-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "They decided to do the show after the diagnosis, not before.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 88,
"n": null,
"c": 12
} |
129601e | Took forever. | Lasted too long | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1467-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Forvever\" is indeed too long.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1467-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1467-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "took forever\" is an expression to say that it is taking too long",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 90,
"n": 10,
"c": null
} |
62238e | Clearly, GAO needs assistance to meet its looming human capital challenges. | GAO will soon be suffering from a shortage of qualified personnel. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "375-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"human capital challenges\" most likely refers to a lack of qualified personnel.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "375-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Shortage of qualified personnel may or may not included in the GAO's human capital challenges.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "375-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Human capital challenges can be a shortage of qualifies personnel, but also can be others, like too expensive labor price.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "375-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if it is a shortage. They might have hired too many personnel",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 61,
"n": 38,
"c": 1
} |
51353e | It is not a surprise, either, that Al Pacino chews the scenery in Devil's Advocate . And the idea that if the devil showed up on Earth he'd be running a New York corporate-law firm is also, to say the least, pre-chewed. | The fact that the devil would work in law is extremely cliche. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1155-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The word \"pre-chewed\" in the context indicates that it is cliche.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1155-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"chewing the scenery\" means artificial acting, so \"pre-chewed\" likely means cliche",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1155-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The devil would work in law, which is an idea, not the fact, and the fact of devil's job is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 79,
"n": 16,
"c": 5
} |
108027n | The door opened and Severn stepped out. | They were waiting for someone to open the door for them. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "280-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what \"they\" were doing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "280-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether they waited or whether they opened the door themselves.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "280-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Servern stepped out when the door opened, maybe he waited, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "280-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if someone opened the door for Severn or he opened it himself",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 73,
"c": 23
} |
95883e | Charles Geveden has introduced legislation that will increase the Access to Justice supplement on court filing fees. | Charles Geveden initiated a law that will essentially lower court filing fees. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "370-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Increasing supplement is not a essential way to lower the fees.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "370-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Charles Geveden intiated a law wikk increase the court filling fees.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "370-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The law he initiated increased the access to justice supplement on court filling fees, meaning the court would need to pay more.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 47,
"n": 22,
"c": 31
} |
26495e | Standard screens may not perform as well in these patient subgroups that may represent a considerable part of the ED population. | The subgroups may not perform well in standard screens. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "880-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement talk about the possible poor performance of the subgroups in standard screens.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "880-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"standard screens may not perform well in subgroups \" and \" subgroups may not perform well in standard screens\" has the same meaning",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "880-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The screens do not perform well, not the subgroups.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "880-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, it is standard screens may not perform well in the subgroups.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 71,
"n": 15,
"c": 14
} |
67836n | Who are these sons of eggs? | I wish they were daughters of eggs. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "202-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what the speaker wishes.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "202-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context is asking about the sons of eggs. Statement is a wish about the daughters of eggs",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 65,
"c": 34
} |
21340n | uh somewhat they're not my favorite team i am uh somewhat familiar with them | They are the best team in the league, by they are not my favorite. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1499-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The best team in the league is not mentioned by the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1499-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether they are the best team in the league.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1499-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe they are the best, maybe they are not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1499-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "I am only somewhat familiar with the team. So I may not know if they are the best team in the league",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 5,
"n": 84,
"c": 11
} |
114971e | They won't be killing off George Clooney's character at ER like they did to Jimmy Smits at NYPD . Instead, Dr. Doug Ross is being forced out over the next two episodes because the maverick heartthrob gives an unauthorized painkiller to a terminally ill boy (Thursday, 10 p.m.). | George Clooney will not be getting fired from his TV show. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1101-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "George Clooney's character will not be killed, which suggests that George Clooney will keep his job.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1101-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "George Clooney's character at ER will be kept. So he will not be fired",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1101-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is about George Clooney's character in the context, not the actor himself.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1101-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Forced out\" means that he likely still will be fired.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 36,
"n": 28,
"c": 36
} |
103354n | The Varanasi Hindu University has an Art Museum with a superb collection of 16th-century Mughal miniatures, considered superior to the national collection in Delhi. | The Varanasi Hindu University has an art museum on its campus which may be superior objectively to the national collection in Delhi. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "961-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because the university's museum has a superb collection of 16th-century Mughai miniatures, superior to the national one. Therefore, it could be considered superior in this collection compared to the national collection",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "961-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The location of the Varanasi Hindu University's museum is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "961-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what \"objectively superior\" means in this context and whether this really is the acse.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "961-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The location of the art museum of the Varanasi Hindu University is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "961-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Varanasi Hindu University's meseum is considered superior to the national collection in Delhi, which may not be objective.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 78,
"n": 22,
"c": null
} |
11971n | In a six-year study, scientists fed dogs and other animals irradiated chicken and found no evidence of increased cancer or other toxic effects. | Scientists gave animals irradiated chicken and they all lived as long as the rest of them. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1326-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If there were no toxic effects, they should have lived as long as the others.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1326-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "no evidence of increased cancer or other toxic effects are found. So they should live no different as other chicken",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1326-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They might lived longer than the rest of them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1326-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No evidence of increased cancer or other toxic effects can make the test animals live as long as others, but the test animals may have other accidents which shorten their lifespan.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 52,
"n": 44,
"c": 4
} |
83722e | Whether a government postal service can engage in these kinds of negotiations deserves serious study. | There is serious study needed to check. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "506-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that it needs serious study.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "506-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is loosely a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "506-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, there is serious study needed to check whether a government postal service can engage in these kinds of negotiations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "506-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context states that the postal service deserves serious study. So there is serious study needed to be looked at",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 76,
"n": 19,
"c": 5
} |
38527n | will never be doused (Brit Hume, Fox News Sunday ; Tony Blankley, Late Edition ; Robert Novak, Capital Gang ; Tucker Carlson, The McLaughlin Group ). The middle way is best expressed by Howard Kurtz (NBC's Meet the Press )--he scolds Brill for undisclosed campaign contributions and for overstretching his legal case against Kenneth Starr but applauds him for casting light on the media. | They wanted the public to know where the funds came from. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "325-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Praising him for casting light on the media shows that they want the public to know the truth.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "325-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They scolded for undisclosed campaign contributions, so they want the public to know where the money came from.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "325-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because they scolds Brill for undisclosed campain contributions. So they would want Brill to let public know where the fund comes from",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "325-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The funds are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 39,
"n": 47,
"c": 14
} |
59934n | Likewise, at their production decision reviews, these programs did not capture manufacturing and product reliability knowledge consistent with best practices. | Their production decision reviews located an anomaly in the data. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "853-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because they find these programs did not capturing manufacturing and product reliability knowledge consistent with best practice.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "853-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not mention the anomalies in the data.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "853-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "An anomaly in the data is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "853-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is the inconsistence in the manufacutring and product reliability knowledge. Not an anomaly",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 30,
"n": 54,
"c": 16
} |
10916n | He'd gone a long way on what he'd found in one elementary book. | He learned a lot from that elementary book. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "509-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both sentences suggest that he learned a lot from the book.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "509-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "509-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He spent a lot of time on what he found in the elementary book, so it must be very useful.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "509-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"had gone a long way\" means he had made a lot progress with what he found in one elemantary book",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 88,
"n": 12,
"c": null
} |
34043c | The Gaiety Theatre in South King Street is worth visiting for its ornate d??cor. | The Trump Tower is a terrible place to visit for ornate decor. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1134-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Trump Tower is not mentioned by the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1134-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Trump Tower is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1134-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "two different buildings",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1134-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "If it is worth visiting, it is not a terrible place to visit.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 62,
"c": 38
} |
117089n | appropriate agency representatives, help resolve | the right agency workers, help fix my security system | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1124-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what should be resolved.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1124-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "the right agency workers may help fix the security system, may help resolve other problems",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1124-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what the agency workers help resolve",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 32,
"n": 67,
"c": 1
} |
121910c | If ancient writings give only a romanticized view, they do offer a more precise picture of Indo-Aryan society. | Ancient writings show an accurate picture of Indo-Anryan society. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1317-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "More precise picture doesn't necessarily mean accurate picture.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1317-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear that the picture is truly accurate, it is only more precise than some other writings.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1317-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, ancient writings give only a romanticized view.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1317-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not an accurate picture offered, but only a \"more precise\" picture. It could still be not clear",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 60,
"n": 23,
"c": 17
} |
113668n | If necessary to meeting the restrictions imposed in the preceding sentence, the Administrator shall reduce, pro rata, the basic Phase II allowance allocations for each unit subject to the requirements of section 414. | Section 414 helps balance allowance allocations for units. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1228-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If \"subject to the requirements of section 414\" refers to \"reduce\", then Section 414 is involved in helping to balance the allowance.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1228-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If \"subject to the requirements of section 414\" refers to \"unit\", then it is not clear whether Section 414 is involved in helping to balance the allowance.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1228-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Section 414 require to reduce the allowance pro rata, so it can be balanced, or not balanced.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1228-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The requirements of section 414relate to the reduction of the basic Phase II allowance allocations, not the balance of allowance allocations.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 66,
"n": 34,
"c": null
} |
128176e | The chart to which Reich refers was actually presented during Saxton's opening statement, hours before Reich testified, and did not look as Reich claims it did. | Reich refers to a chart that he misunderstood. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1333-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The fact that Reich was wrong about what he said about the charts he referred to shows that he misunderstood.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1333-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether he misrepresented the chart because he misunderstood it. Maybe he did that on purpose.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1333-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Reich refers to a chart wrongly, but maybe it is because he misunderstood it, maybe because he remembered incorrectly.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1333-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It might be misunderstanding or Reich could also just remember it wrong",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 55,
"n": 39,
"c": 6
} |
122322e | well uh normally i like to to go out fishing in a boat and uh rather than like bank fishing and just like you try and catch anything that's swimming because i've had such problems of trying to catch any type of fish that uh i just really enjoy doing the boat type fishing | I fish in the boat and try catching any fish because I have trouble catching certain types. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "71-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "71-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I have problems of cathing any type of fish, not just certain types",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 79,
"n": 15,
"c": 6
} |
53619c | True devotees talk shop at even more specialized groups, such as one on Northeastern weather (ne.weather), whose recent conversation topics included the great blizzard of 1978 and the freak snowstorm of May 1977. | Ne.weather is a general discussion group, not only about weather. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "245-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "ne.weather is a specialized discussion group focussing on weather",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "245-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "According to the context, ne.weather is a specialized group, not a general discussion group.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "245-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, ne.weather is a specialized group.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "245-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is specialized in weather topics",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 7,
"n": 29,
"c": 64
} |
27287c | we were talking . Try to behave | We are having an argument, come at me if you dare! | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "654-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "These are different statements.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "654-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Talking can be peaceful or a arguement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "654-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context means rather that the other person should behave and be quiet. It is not aggressive like in the statement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 41,
"c": 58
} |
125700e | Don't forget to take a change of clothing and a towel. | Remember to replace your towel and clothing. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "579-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Taking a change of clothing and a towel means taking an extra set of them, which implies the need to replace them with the extra set of clothes and towel.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "579-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "579-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, a change of clothing and a towel is for replacement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "579-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 57,
"n": 36,
"c": 7
} |
96946n | Once or twice, but they seem more show than battle, said Adrin. | Adrin said they liked to perform more than they did fight. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "584-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is true because they seem more show than battle.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "584-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "584-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Their preference is not shown in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 74,
"n": 21,
"c": 5
} |
17660e | and not only that it it opens you to phone solicitations | It also opens the door to move marketing calls. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "795-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Phone solicitations and move marketing calls have similar meanings.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "795-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, phone solicitation is marketing call.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "795-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It opens you to phoen solitications. It's not clear whether it also opens you to move marketing calls (whatever that is)",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "795-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 62,
"n": 36,
"c": 2
} |
107252c | On the northwestern Alpine frontier, a new state had appeared on the scene, destined to lead the movement to a united Italy. | The alpine frontier was separated from Italy by glaciers. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1382-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that Italy is on the northweatern Alpine frontier, Glaciers are not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1382-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There are no glaciers mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1382-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Glaciers are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1382-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what separating them",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 80,
"c": 17
} |
113967e | 'I don't know what happened, exactly.' I said. | You aren't making sense. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "905-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what \"you\" said.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "905-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "These are different statements.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "905-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I don't know what happened could because your words are nonsense, but also could because of others, like that things are too complicated.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "905-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 73,
"c": 19
} |
129464c | It can entail prospective and retrospective designs and it permits synthesis of many individual case studies undertaken at different times and in different sites. | It can entail prospective and retrospective designs for system redesigns. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "567-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention system redesigns.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "567-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the designs are for system redesigns.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "567-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It permits synthesis of many individual case studies, maybe also contributes to system redesigns, but maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "567-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what the design is for",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 48,
"n": 48,
"c": 4
} |
82528c | you know maybe it just wasn't possible at all in the first place you know like the no new taxes thing you know that's uh with the economy going the way it is and everything that was nearly ridiculous thing to | it's possible to have no new taxes with the way the economy is right now. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1180-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The speaker says that the \"new taxes thing\" was not possible with \"the economy going the way it is\"",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1180-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is talking about the economy in the past, not right now.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 35,
"n": 23,
"c": 42
} |
134356n | You will remember my saying that it was wise to beware of people who were not telling you the truth." | There might be dishonest people around here. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "854-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions to beware of dishonest people, which implies that there might be dishonest people here.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "854-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker warns someone of dishonest people, so likely there are some around.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "854-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "one should be aware of people who aren't telling the truth. So there are dishonest people around",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "854-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Dishonest people maybe are around here, maybe are somewhere else.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 74,
"n": 24,
"c": 2
} |
102075c | um-hum with the ice yeah | With the sunshine and heat wave yes. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1555-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "These are different statements.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1555-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 30,
"c": 70
} |
96956c | You wonder whether he could win a general election coming out of the right lane of the Democratic Party. | He will not run in a general election while he is a conservative Democrat. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1216-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Someone only asks themselves if he could win the general election. That does not say anything about its truth.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1216-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He is runing in a general election since \"you\" already wonder whether he could win it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1216-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, he run in a general election while he is under the right lane of the Democratic Party.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1216-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is wondered if he could win a general election. So it is possible that he will run in a general election",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 70,
"c": 23
} |
24163e | We have done that spectacularly. | Spectacular results was the only way to describe the impact of our past work. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "521-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Our work has been spectacular. So the result of the work must be spectacular",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "521-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention otherr describtion than spectacular, so we don't if it is the only way.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "521-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear what they have done spectacularly.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "521-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Spectacular results was the one way to describe the impact of our past work, but there could be other ways, like historical.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 67,
"n": 31,
"c": 2
} |
31775c | well what station plays uh that type of music | What TV station has documentaries about space travel? | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "990-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "These are different questions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "990-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 26,
"c": 74
} |
8487n | We always knew it was an outside chance. | We were never assured of it happening in time and we knew this full well. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "419-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "419-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, outside chance means a small probability, so we never assured of it happening.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "419-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We have always need it is a very small possibility. So we always knew it will most likely not happen",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "419-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context what was an outside chance.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 64,
"n": 28,
"c": 8
} |
46576e | Perhaps a further password would be required, or, at any rate, some proof of identity. | Identity should be a minimum requirement. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1538-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Identity is at any rate required, so it is a minimum requirement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1538-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1538-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, at any rate the proof of identity is needed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1538-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Whatever is needed, some proof of identity is needed. So it makes the identity a minimum requirement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 68,
"n": 25,
"c": 7
} |
83247e | It's come back? cried Julius excitedly. | They were excited to hear it will come back. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "910-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Julius cried excitedly when heard it back.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "910-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Julius cried excitedly. So he is excited about it coming back",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "910-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions Julius, it is not clear who \"they\" are.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "910-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether \"they\" or only Julius was excited.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 59,
"n": 37,
"c": 4
} |
80109n | if it had rained any more in the last two weeks instead of planting Saint Augustine grass in the front yard i think i would have plowed everything under and had a rice field | It has rained enough to flood everything here and make rice pattys. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "360-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what \"make rice patty\"s means, but it shouldn't be entailed by having a rice field.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "360-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "it hasn't rained enough. If it had rained enough, I would have had a rice field",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "360-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context indicates that it hasn't reained enough.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "360-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, it has not rained enough in the last two weeks.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 51,
"n": 25,
"c": 24
} |
52854n | This was used for ceremonial purposes, allowing statues of the gods to be carried to the river for journeys to the west bank, or to the Luxor sanctuary. | Statues were moved to Luxor for funerals and other ceremonies. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "901-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "ceremonial purposes were mentioned. Funeral is also a kind of ceremonial purpose. So the statues could also be used for that",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "901-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Statues were moved to Luxor or to the west bank.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "901-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the statues were moved for funerals or only for other ceremonies.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "901-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe statues were moved to Luxor, or to the west bank.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 53,
"n": 47,
"c": null
} |
133274n | (Imagine the difference between smoking a cigarette and injecting pure nicotine directly into a vein.) | Smoking a cigarette is a lot like injecting pure nicotine. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1097-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't suggest the difference between smoking a cigarette and injecting pure nicotine.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1097-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the difference is large or small according to the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1097-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe there are lots of similarities between smoking a cigarette and injecting pure nocotine, but maybe they are very different.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1097-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, the context emphasizes the difference between smoking a cigarette and injecting pure nocotine.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1097-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There should be a difference",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 17,
"n": 36,
"c": 47
} |
120070n | well do you know you have a ten limit a ten minute time limit well that's okay and then they come on and tell you and they tell you got five seconds to say good-bye | You get a ten minute time limit, but sometimes you'll be told to end early. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1540-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1540-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if then come early or on time to tell one to end",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1540-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests clearly that \"you\" have a ten minute time limit. The requirement for an early end is not valid unless explicitly stated in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1540-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, you will not be told to end early, but will be asked to end it quickly.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 62,
"n": 33,
"c": 5
} |
129185n | Lincoln glared. | The man was angry. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1200-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If he glared, then he probably was angry.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1200-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Glaring is a state out of anger",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1200-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Lincoln glared might out of anger or surprise.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1200-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The man glared maybe because of anger, maybe because of others like terror.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 56,
"n": 42,
"c": 2
} |
49172n | These alone could have valuable uses. | They may be valuable. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "233-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "According to the context, they could be valuable.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "233-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "233-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, \"could have valuable uses\" implies the probability of being valuable.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "233-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Valuable uses infer being valuable",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 86,
"n": 13,
"c": 1
} |
140782c | Generally, FGD systems tend to be constructed closer to the ground compared to SCR technology retrofits. | FGD systems tend to replicate SCR systems. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1086-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly suggest the difference between FG and SCR systems, which shows that FGD is not a replication of SCR systems.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1086-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They probably do not replicate SCR systems, because they are closer to the ground.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1086-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, FGD systems are closer to the ground.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1086-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "FGD systems tend to be closer to the ground; whereas SCR system not",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 9,
"n": 33,
"c": 58
} |
45443c | This confluence of a bad tax, a $1 billion reserve, a botched opposition campaign, and voters willing to call a bluff resulted in the I-695 victory. | The I-695 failed in its campaign to help the people. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "447-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the I-695 helped people.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "447-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A series of negative factors contributed to I-695 success, but it can not be concluded that I-695 failed to help the people",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "447-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The campaign is not aimed to help the people, as described in the context. And the I-695 didn't fail.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "447-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, the I-695 succeeded.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 12,
"n": 31,
"c": 57
} |
22938e | Despite a recent renovation, the Meadows Mall is the least appealing of the three suburban malls. | The Meadows Mall is not appealing. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "729-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, the Meadows Mall is the least appealing of the three suburban malls.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "729-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Meadows Mall is the least appealing of the three malls, which doesn't mean it is not appealing at all, it is just not more appealing than other two.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "729-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is only less appealing than the other two malls. It's not clear whether they all are appealing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "729-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Meadows Mall is the least appealing of the three suburban malls, but maybe compared to other competitors, it is still appealing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "729-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "THe Meadows Mall is the least appealing out of three malls. But it could be appealing, just not as appealling as the other two",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 66,
"n": 31,
"c": 3
} |
67571c | Everybody has this quote from NBA commissioner David You cannot strike your boss and still hold your job--unless you play in the NBA. | NBA commissioner said he hates NBA players. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "674-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether NBA commissioner said he hates NBA players.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "674-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not seem to be about whether the commissioner likes NBA players.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "674-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "NBA commissioner David said NBA players could strike their boss and still hold their job, as \"the boss\", he maybe hates NBA players, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "674-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His quote ony shows that the boss does not have total power over his players in NBA. It does not convey his personal feelings over the players",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 1,
"n": 44,
"c": 55
} |
5087e | approaches to achieving missions vary considerably between agencies. | Approaches to achieving missions might change a lot. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "706-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement show that there are different approaches to achieving missions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "706-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If they vary between agencies, they might change a lot, e.g. if you move from one agencie to another.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "706-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, \"vary considerably\" implies \"change a lot.\"",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "706-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A considerable change could be big",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 75,
"n": 23,
"c": 2
} |
23769n | Kom Ombo is an unusual temple in that it is dedicated to two gods. | Rarely visited, Kom Ombo is a strange temple devoted to two gods. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1430-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if Kom Ombo is rarely visited.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1430-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether Kom Ombo is rarely visited.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1430-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know how often the Kom Ombo temple is visited.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1430-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about how many people visiting the Kom Ombo",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 36,
"n": 64,
"c": null
} |
13760n | If they have overestimated how far the CPI is off, Boskin and his commission may institutionalize an underestimated CPI--guaranteeing a yearly, stealth tax increase. | If they've overestimated how far the CPI is off, it will have horrific consequences. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1262-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The tax increase will come if CPI is underestimated and it's not clear whether this is horrific.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1262-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not sure if a yearly, stealth tax increase counts as a horrific consequence",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 35,
"n": 62,
"c": 3
} |
2133n | The tomb guardian will unlock the gate to the tunnel and give you a candle to explore the small circular catacomb, but for what little you can see, it is hardly worth the effort. | The tomb garden can give you a thorough tour of the catacombs. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "25-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context speaks about the \"guardian\" not the \"garden\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "25-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A thorough tour is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "25-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The tomb guardian will open the gate for you and give you a candle, which implies that he will not give you a tour of the catacombs.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "25-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, he only gives a candle to explore the catacomb. And you can only see a little, which is not worth the effort",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 10,
"n": 14,
"c": 76
} |
117093n | Hong Kong has long been China's handiest window on the West, and the city is unrivaled in its commercial know-how and managerial expertise. | Hong Kong is a great place to find commercial know-how if you are hiring someone new. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1056-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that Hong Kong is a great place in its commercial know-how.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1056-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1056-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "the city is experience in commercial know-how. So it is a good idea to find people in that area in Hong Kong",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1056-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Hiring someone new is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 54,
"n": 44,
"c": 2
} |
112402c | Although the accounting and reporting model needs to be updated, in my view, the current attest and assurance model is also out of date. | The accounting model needs to be updated in addition to the acquisition model. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1236-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the acquisition model.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1236-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the acquisition model has to be updated.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1236-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The acquisition model is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1236-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is the attest and assurance model needs to be updated",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 43,
"n": 44,
"c": 13
} |
32754n | After shuttering the DOE, Clinton could depict himself as a crusader against waste and bureaucracy who succeeded where even Reagan failed. | Reagan had tried to shutter the DOE but was unable to. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "136-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Clinton successfully shuttered the DOE while Reagan failed, as mentioned in the context. So the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "136-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Reagan failed at shuttering the DOE, so he tried to do it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "136-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, Reagan failed to shutter the DOE.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "136-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was Clinton who successfully shuttering DOE",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 64,
"n": 25,
"c": 11
} |
120896n | Tell me, how did those scribbled words on the envelope help you to discover that a will was made yesterday afternoon?" Poirot smiled. | How did you work out from that text that there was a new will? | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1441-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1441-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, you discoverd there was a new will form those scribbled words on the envelope.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1441-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context is a question about how \"you\" figure out there is a will made yesterday from only a text of scribbled words. So we can know the will is still new from yesterday",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1441-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions a will, it is not clear whether the will is a new one or the only one.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 88,
"n": 12,
"c": null
} |
25437n | Well, we will come in and interview the brave Dorcas." Dorcas was standing in the boudoir, her hands folded in front of her, and her grey hair rose in stiff waves under her white cap. | Dorcas is well known for her bravery. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "48-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, \"brave Dorcas\" reveals her bravery.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "48-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear what is Dorcas well known for.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "48-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether Dorcas was known for her bravery or whether only the speaker thought she was brave.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "48-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whether Dorcas is well known for her bravery or not",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 60,
"n": 36,
"c": 4
} |
56895c | The entire economy received a massive jump-start with the outbreak of the Korean War, with Japan ironically becoming the chief local supplier for an army it had battled so furiously just a few years earlier. | Korea and Japan were not at war. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "401-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Japan was the chief local supplier for an army in the Korean war, but we don't know whether Japanese army also involved in the war.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "401-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Japan had battled with Korea furiously.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "401-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They were a war between the two countries. And Japan even was the chief local supplier for Korean after the war",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 52,
"n": 20,
"c": 28
} |
43094c | Time 's cover package considers what makes a good school. | Time's cover package is about how most college students have to deal with insane student loans. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1131-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Insane student loans are not discussed in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1131-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1131-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The topic of the Time's cover package mentioned in the statement is completely different from the one mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1131-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The cover package is about good schools, not about student loans.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 1,
"n": 50,
"c": 49
} |
21834e | But the world is not run for the edification of tourists. | The world does not try and morally subject to tourists. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "731-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Runing for the edification of tourists includes morally subjecting to tourists.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "731-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, the world exists not for the tourists.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "731-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 58,
"n": 38,
"c": 4
} |
139836n | The centralization dear to Richelieu and Louis XIV was becoming a reality. | Louis XIV cared a lot about centralization of his country and people. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "449-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement mention that Louis XIV valued the centralization.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "449-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "449-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, the centraliza dear to Louis XIV implies he cares a lot about centralization.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "449-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was not mentioned whether Louis XIV cared about his people or not",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 66,
"n": 34,
"c": null
} |
57454e | what does um is Robby Robin Williams does he have a funny part in the movie or is | Is Robin Williams in the movie? | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1204-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker seems to know that Robin Williams is in the movie, but not which part he has.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1204-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He is in the movie, the context asked about if he had a funny part in the movie",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 40,
"n": 45,
"c": 15
} |
34573n | But the door was locked?" These exclamations burst from us disjointedly. | We chaotically exclaimed as we all jumped up in a frenzy, "But the door wasn't unlocked?" | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "311-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Was not unlocked?\" entails \"Was locked?\"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "311-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn' mention that they jumped up.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "311-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The door was locked",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 43,
"n": 20,
"c": 37
} |
52278e | Tuppence rose. | Tuppence stood up. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1129-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that Tuppence stood up.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1129-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Rose\" entails \"stood up\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1129-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A human \"rose\" means \"stood up\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1129-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "the word\"rise\" means gets up/ stands up",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 88,
"n": 11,
"c": 1
} |
11618c | Enlarging the village was not desirable and most knew that Severn only desired wealth and a seat on the council of elders. | Severn was happy being poor. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "123-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Severn desired wealth, so he was not happy beding poor.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "123-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Severn desired wealth\" so they were not \"happy being poor\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "123-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Severn only desired wealth so he should be unhappy being poor.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "123-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Severn wants wealth",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 11,
"c": 89
} |
118460n | and the other thing is the cost it's almost prohibitive to bring it to a dealer | The cost of fixing it makes it hard to bring it to a dealer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "585-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and statement talk about the large cost of fixing it.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "585-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether \"fixing it\" increases the cost.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "585-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The cost makes it hard to bring it to a dealer, but it could be the cost of fixing, or the cost of something else, like transport.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "585-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is the cost of bringing it to the dealer that is very expensive",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 76,
"n": 22,
"c": 2
} |
54383c | He knew how the Simulacra was supposed to develop. | He didn't know about Sims. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "513-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sims are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "513-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sims is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "513-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He knew about Sims/Simulacra and how they were supposed to develop",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 3,
"n": 47,
"c": 50
} |
123751n | i think that the people that are um have um a lower income which you automatically equate with lower education | I think because you have lower income you are less educated. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "718-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, I think that lower income is equal to lower education.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "718-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether the speaker talks about other people associating lower income with lower education or whether they talk about themselves.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "718-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no clear causal relation between the poorness and the education level. Either one could lead to the other",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "718-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context and the statement discuss just the opposite of the causal relationship between income and educational level.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 78,
"n": 15,
"c": 7
} |
43891n | GAO recommends that the Secretary of Defense revise policy and guidance | GAO recommends that you eat 5 fruit/veg per day | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "761-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The recommendation of GAO in the statement is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "761-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Fruit/veg are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "761-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Diet is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "761-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 50,
"c": 50
} |
113039e | In this respect, bringing Steve Jobs back to save Apple is like bringing Gen. | Steve Jobs came back to Apple. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1142-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because it describe Steve Jobs' back as \"bringing Gen\", so he came back to Apple and saved it like a General.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1142-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Steve Jobs was brought back to save Apple. So he came back to Apple",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1142-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't suggest if Steve Jobs came back to Apple.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1142-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker talks only about what it would be like if Steve Jobs returned to Apple. He doesn't assert that he really came back.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 42,
"n": 40,
"c": 18
} |
83900e | Ca'daan closed the door behind them and retied the not. | Ca'daan closed the door as they entered, and bound it shut with rope. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "684-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The \"[k]not\" was probably made with rope.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "684-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "684-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention if Ca'daan bound the door shut with rope",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "684-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Ca'daan closed the door after they entered, not as they entered.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 59,
"n": 33,
"c": 8
} |
10119e | Then he is very sure. | He is very sure of himself. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "42-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "42-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what he's very sure of.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "42-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's unclear whether he is sure of himself or of something else.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "42-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He could be very sure of himself, or be sure of any other things.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 60,
"n": 37,
"c": 3
} |
21810n | you can get a hard copy of it and that's about it | An email won't cut it. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "112-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Only one hard copy of it is allowed. So an E-mail does not meet the requirement and won't do the trick",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "112-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the hard copy.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "112-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "E-mail is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "112-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Email is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 46,
"n": 43,
"c": 11
} |
35700c | The Honorable Bill Archer, Chairman The Honorable Charles B. Rangel Ranking Minority Member Committee on Ways and Means House of Representatives | Bill Archer has never held government office in his entire life. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "368-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Bill Archer was chairman of the house of representatives.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "368-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Bill Archer at lease held government office as Chairman.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0,
3
] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 14,
"c": 85
} |
109278n | Lawyers in their first three years of practice or who are inactive pay $90, and retired lawyers pay nothing. | Lawyers pay $90 to be included in the directory. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "278-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear for what lawyers pay $90.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "278-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not all lawyers are required to pay $90.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "278-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, retired lawyers pay nothing to be included in the directory.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "278-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "retired laywers do not pay anything. And it is not clear what the money is for.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 13,
"n": 74,
"c": 13
} |
138530e | It vibrated under his hand. | It hummed quietly in his hand. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1030-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"It vibrated\" probably entails \"it hummed\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1030-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because if it \"vibrated\", it usually \"hummed quietly\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1030-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if the humming is quiet.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1030-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's vibrating not humming",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 43,
"n": 36,
"c": 21
} |
13387e | yeah i can believe that | I agree with what you said. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "896-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that the speaker believe what was said.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "896-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "To Believe what has happened does not mean to agree with what has happened",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "896-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Belief does not entail agreement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "896-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I believe something, maybe it is what you said, maybe it is anything else.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 70,
"n": 28,
"c": 2
} |
58557e | In the first instance, IRS would have no record of time before the person could get through to an agent and of discouraged callers. | There is no recording of the time for callers. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "815-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The \"would\" implies that this is about a hypothetical situation, not about a factual one.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "815-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no recording of the time for discouraged callers, but other callers could be recorded, or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "815-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is recording of the time after the person get through to an agent.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "815-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There will be a record after the person get through to an agent",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 77,
"n": 16,
"c": 7
} |
36811c | This having come to his stepmother's ears, she taxed him with it on the afternoon before her death, and a quarrel ensued, part of which was overheard. | A love affair sparked just moments before her death. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "724-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if the context talks about A love affair.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "724-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There's no mention of a love affair.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "724-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A love affair is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "724-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known that it's about a love affair",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 7,
"n": 40,
"c": 53
} |
73840n | Hersheimmer "WELL," said Tuppence, recovering herself, "it really seems as though it were meant to be." Carter nodded. | See, luck is real! | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1066-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker seems to believe in luck, as she said that it seems as it were meant to be.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1066-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Luck is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1066-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 20,
"n": 70,
"c": 10
} |
31249e | (And yes, he has said a few things that can, with some effort, be construed as support for supply-side economics.) | It would take some work to construe the things as support for supply-side economics. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "629-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"With some effort\" has the same meaning as \"take some work\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "629-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"with some effort\" implies \"it would take some work\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "629-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, to construe the things as support for supply-side economics need some effort.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "629-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "What he said would need some effort, meaning work, to be construed as support",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 86,
"n": 8,
"c": 6
} |
91913n | This is one of the reasons we're growing too weak to fight the Satheri. "What's wrong with a ceremony of worship, if you must worship your eggshell?" Dave asked. | Eggshell worship is the reason we're growing too weak to fight the Satheri, yet Dave asked about it. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1437-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify the reasons why they are growing too weak to fight the Satheri.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1437-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether \"Eggshell worship\" is really put as a reason.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1437-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reasons that we're growing too weak to fight the Satheri is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1437-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Dave meant if\"you\" can worship a eggshell then people can also have a ceremony of worship",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 60,
"n": 36,
"c": 4
} |
100895c | Is there adequate information for judging generalizability? | Every output has some kind of resource. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "181-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Output or resources are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "181-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 78,
"c": 20
} |
837n | The central features of the Results Act-strategic planning, performance measurement, and public reporting and accountability-can serve as powerful tools to help change the basic culture of government. | The Results Act has strategic planning as a central feature for public organizations. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1361-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"strategic planning\" is mentioned as one of the central features.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1361-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Strategic planning is one of its central features",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1361-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The central features of the Results Act are tools to help government, not public organizations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1361-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Results Act has strategic planning as a central feature, but the purpose is to help change the basic culture of government.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 61,
"n": 37,
"c": 2
} |
140005c | 3 It should be noted that the toxicity (LC50) of a sample observed in a range-finding test may be significantly different from the toxicity observed in the follow-up chronic definitive test (1) the definitive test is longer; and (2) the test may be performed with a sample collected at a different time, and possibly differing significantly in the level of toxicity. | The toxicity of a sample in the range-finding test will be exactly the same as the toxicity in the follow-up test. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "894-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The toxicity of a sample in a range-finding test may be different from the toxicity in the follow-up test, whereas the statement says the exact opposite.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "894-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says it \"may be significantly different\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "894-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, the toxicity of a sample in the range-finding test may be significantly different from the toxicity in the follow-up test.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "894-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They are not the same due to the test time and samples collected at a different time",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 5,
"n": 10,
"c": 85
} |
38475c | In 1984, Clinton picked up rock groupie Connie Hamzy when she was sunbathing in a bikini by a hotel pool. | Clinton kept her friends and relationships private in the 80s. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1018-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention if Clinton kept her friends and relationships private.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1018-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Clition is male not female.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1018-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He picked a one of his friends in a public hotel pool. So it was not private kept",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 2,
"n": 65,
"c": 33
} |
141293e | oh wow no i just started about well five years ago i think | It had started five years ago. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1251-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that the speaker started five years ago.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1251-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, I think I started five years ago.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1251-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I started something five years ago, so this thing or it was started five years ago",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1251-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"I started\" not \"it started\"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 64,
"n": 31,
"c": 5
} |
30139n | oh that's not really important the the other stuff is just you know window dressing because we we've never ordered anything fact the the van that we've got we bought uh from an estate it was an estate trade uh it was almost brand new the the gentlemen who owned it had died | We were very lucky to get the van given how new it was. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1396-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is true that it's a lucky thing to get a new van.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1396-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The van was almost brand new because the gentleman who owned it died. So it's almost not used",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1396-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Whether they were lucky would depend on the price which is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1396-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The van was almost brand new, but it could be lucky to have or not at all.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 62,
"n": 35,
"c": 3
} |
30380c | The NYT , in its front-page coverage, says the plane was flying far lower than the rules for training missions allow. | The NYT reported that training missions did allow for planes to fly that low. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "415-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The plane flew lower than the rules allowed, so the rules do not allow to fly that low",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "415-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was flying lower than the rules allow, which suggests that it was not allowed by rules for training missions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "415-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The \"plane was flying far lower than the rules [...] allow\" implies that it was allowed to fly this low.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "415-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, NYT reported that training missions did not allow for planes to fly that low.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 28,
"n": 6,
"c": 66
} |
22436n | 1 Now that each unit is fully staffed, the LSC Office of Program Performance and its state planning team contain over 260 years of experience in LSC-funded programs. | The LSC has over 260 years of experience with their lawyers. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "605-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The experience of LSC with their lawyers is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "605-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The experience is for the \"state planning team\" and not for \"lawyers\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "605-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The LSC has over over 260 years of experience in LSC-funded programs, but it could be with their lawyers, or with other staffs, like interns.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "605-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the info but about LSC-funded program, which we do not know info about",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 43,
"n": 45,
"c": 12
} |
76037n | You did, didn't you?" | You didn't mean to do that, did you? | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1513-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"mean to do that\" is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1513-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The deliberation is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1513-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context is about whether an action has been done by someone, but the statement is about the intention to do it",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 49,
"c": 40
} |
28456n | A clean, wholesome-looking woman opened it. | The woman was trying to be desecrate. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "354-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention anything about desecration.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "354-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what the woman was trying to be.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "354-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The attempt of the woman is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "354-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, the woman is clean and wholesome-looking, not desecrate.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "354-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context is a compliment, statement is a negative comment",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 1,
"n": 68,
"c": 31
} |
46198c | How effectively DOD manages these funds will determine whether it receives a good return on its investment. | The DOD is certain to have a bad return on these funds. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "926-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The return on its investment can be bad or good.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "926-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known yet about the result, it depends on DOD's management",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "926-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The return is not certainly bad. The return is determined by how DOD manages these funds.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "926-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"How effectively [...] will determine\" implies that there is at least a chance to have a good return.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 3,
"n": 45,
"c": 52
} |
100136e | Challenges to Restore Public Confidence in | Public confidence can be difficult to reestablish. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "755-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement suggest that it is possible that Public confidence is difficult to restore. This is true since the context only mentions that there are challenges, not how large the challenges are.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "755-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If there are \"challenges to restore public confidence\" then it can be \"difficult to reestablish\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "755-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Challenge means to be a difficulty",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 68,
"n": 31,
"c": 1
} |
24103n | if the United States had used full conventional power. | The United States is unable to maximize their potential. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1373-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maximizing potential is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1373-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It it unknown if US is able to maximize the potential or not. Maybe US is able to, just will not",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 18,
"n": 64,
"c": 18
} |
142729c | What Ellison is doing here, as Hemingway did, is equating the process of becoming an artist with that of becoming a man. | Ellison and Hemingway took different ways to compare becoming a man. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "307-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Ellison and Hemingway took the same way, not different ways.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "307-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They both compared the process to becoming an artist.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "307-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, both Ellison and Hemingway equated the process of becoming an artist with that of becoming a man.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "307-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They both equete becoming an artist with becoming an man. It means for them, when one becomes an artist, they also becomes a man. The way is the same",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 9,
"n": 12,
"c": 79
} |