id
stringlengths 3
7
| context
stringlengths 8
967
| statement
stringlengths 10
276
| entailment
listlengths 0
4
| neutral
listlengths 0
4
| contradiction
listlengths 0
4
| idk
sequencelengths 0
3
| label_count_round_1
dict | label_count_round_2
dict | label_set_round_1
sequencelengths 1
3
| label_set_round_2
sequencelengths 0
3
| error_labels
sequencelengths 0
2
| has_ambiguity
bool 2
classes | chaosnli_labels
dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
135021n | you know we keep a couple hundred dollars um if that much charged on those which isn't too bad it's just your normal | We have money on there, which isn't great | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "799-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "Spending money on that is not great, because it is normal.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "799-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The \"not too bad\" comment in the context is about charging much, while the statement is about having money on there.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1,
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 28,
"n": 50,
"c": 22
} |
88605e | The remaining parts of the north, although enticing, are difficult to explore. | The rest of the north presents a steep challenge. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "789-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement are saying that the rest of the north is hard to explore.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "789-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the remaining parts of the north are difficult to explore, then they also present a steep challenge.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "789-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Difficult to explore\" means \"a steep challenge\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "789-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"difficult to explore\" entails a chanllenge",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 82,
"n": 17,
"c": 1
} |
98710n | well Jerry do you have a favorite team | Jerry, do you follow any sports? | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "886-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement are questions about sports. If someone has a favorite team, then he/she must follow this sport.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "886-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If Jerry has a favorite team, he/she should follow this sport.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "886-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Jerry can follow sports without having a favorite team.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "886-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Jerry can be a fake fan, for example he/she support a local team, but even don't know the rule of the sport.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "886-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 46,
"n": 51,
"c": 3
} |
30894c | Earlier this week, the Pakistani paper Dawn ran an editorial about reports that Pakistani poppy growers are planning to recultivate opium on a bigger scale because they haven't received promised compensation for switching to other crops. | It is illegal to grow opium in Pakistan. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "388-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether growing opium in Pakistan is illegal or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "388-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't say anything about the legality of the cultivation of opium.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "388-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It didn't mention whether it is legal to plant opium in Pakistan.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "388-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The legal status of growing opium is not mentioned in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 67,
"c": 29
} |
81356e | In keeping with other early Buddhist tenets, there is no figurative representation of Buddha here, However, there is a large gilded statue from a later period inside, and behind the temple are the spreading branches and trunks of the sacred Bodhi Tree, which is said to have grown from a sapling of the first one that stood here 2,500 years ago. | There is no statue of Buddha located there. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1013-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No figurative representation of Buddha indicates that there is no satues of Buddha.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1013-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If there is no figurative representation of Buddha then there can be no statue of Buddha.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1013-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether the \"large gilded statue\" is a statue of Buddha or something else.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1013-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"However\" means although the early Buddhist tenet forbade the figurative representation of Buddha, later it was somehow disobeyed or changed, and there is a large gilded statue here.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1013-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is a large gilded statue from a later period",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 66,
"n": 9,
"c": 25
} |
132516n | right right they left a woman and a child or the cat the sheep yeah | They were merciful in this regard, only taking the men as slaves. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "883-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement could be true because only the men are not mentioned in the context. They may have been merciful if they only took the men but left the women and children.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "883-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention men.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "883-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They left a woman or a child. They could still have taken other women or children.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "883-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "What did they take is not sure, maybe they didn't take anybody, just took some fortune away.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "883-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about taking the men as slaves",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 7,
"n": 80,
"c": 13
} |
34176n | The rustic Bras-David picnic area, for example, is set alongside a burbling stream. | The stream is always burbling. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1185-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement mention the burbling stream.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1185-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Burbling\" is how the stream is described in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1185-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The stream could also be burbling only sometimes or most of the time.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1185-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It can't be promised that it is \"always\" burbling, maybe sometimes the rainfall will influence the volume of the stream.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1185-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The area is set alongside a burbling stream. No info about if all stream is burbling",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 44,
"n": 54,
"c": 2
} |
77116e | The third row of Exhibit 17 shows the Krewski, et al. | Exhibit 17 has many rows. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1144-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that Exhibit 17 has at least three rows. So there are indeed many rows.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1144-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "As there is \"the third row\", we can suppose that there are more than one row.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1144-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is the third row of Exhibit 17, meaning it has at least first and second row",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1144-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We only know that it has at least three rows, which is not many.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1144-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Many\" can be quite a large number, but it is not refered in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 43,
"n": 57,
"c": null
} |
76947n | i think we have too thank you very much you too bye-bye | I don't think we can thank you enough for your help. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "860-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both sentences express strong gratitude.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "860-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention why they are thanking you, it may or may not because of the help.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "860-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe \"I\" think oral thanks is enough.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "860-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "exaggeration",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 34,
"n": 52,
"c": 14
} |
139635n | have that well and it doesn't seem like very many people uh are really i mean there's a lot of people that are on death row but there's not very many people that actually um do get killed | Most people on death row end up living out their lives awaiting execution. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "433-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not very many people on death row get killed indicates that there are many people waiting on the death row, but they will not be executed.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "433-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "there are many people on death row, but few of them actually get killed",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "433-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The people in death row that are not killed could also be pardoned. So they would not await execution.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "433-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some people's execution can be cancelled and they will suffer from life imprisonment and die in prison.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 77,
"n": 19,
"c": 4
} |
101245n | we were lucky in that in one respect in that after she had her stroke she wasn't really you know really much aware of what was going on | She had a very serious stroke. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1090-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The stroke left her unaware of her surroundings, so it has to have been serious.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1090-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the seriousness of the stroke.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1090-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It can be a very serious stroke, but also can be a mild stroke.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1090-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the seriousness of her stroke; She could a serious or not so serious stroke",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 24,
"c": 1
} |
8545c | He hadn't seen even pictures of such things since the few silent movies run in some of the little art theaters. | He had recently seen pictures depicting those things. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "7-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He could have visited the little art theaters recently or not. It is not clear.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "7-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is clear from the context that he hadn't seen pictures of such things, while the statement suggests that he had recently seen them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "7-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, \"he hadn't seen pictures of such things\" since the silent movies run in some art theaters.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "7-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He hadn't seen pictures of those things",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 16,
"c": 73
} |
8219n | it depends a lot of uh a lot of things were thought that uh as you know the farmers thought okay we got chemicals we're putting chemicals on the field well the ground will naturally filter out the | The farming chemicals are filtered by the ground. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "296-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The farmers think the groud will naturally filter out the chemicals",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "296-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the thought of the farmers. It is not clear whether this thought is the truth.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "296-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker talks about the farmers thinking that the ground will filter out the chemicals. But they don't say that they themselves believe it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 49,
"n": 48,
"c": 3
} |
115247c | oh really yeah so he he's uh he's probably going to be going to jail and and the problem with him is he's on a guaranteed salary like for three years so whether he plays or not they've got to pay him ten million dollars so if they | He is so hardworking and has helped the team achieve so much, I don't see anything wrong with paying him a million dollar salary. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "633-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can't infer from the context whether he is hardworking or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "633-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His personality and characters are not mentioned in the context, maybe he is not hardworking.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "633-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about where he is hardworking or not or about my subject feelings on him got paid a million dollar salary",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "633-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker clearly says that they believe it's a problem that the person has a guaranteed million dollar salary.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "633-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He will probably go to jail, and \"I\" worry about the ten million dollars, but although he can not work in jail, the money still need to be paid.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 4,
"n": 42,
"c": 54
} |
99708e | It was made up to look as much like an old-fashioned steam train as possible. | It was built in the modern era to look like something built in the past. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "963-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions the building of an old-fashioned train, the word old-fashioned would only be used in the modern era. So the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "963-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was made to look like a steam train which is something from the past.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "963-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was made up to look as an \"old-fashioned\" steam train, if it is made in the past, it should be described as \"fashion\" instead of \"old-fashioned\". So it was built in the modern era but to look like something old.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "963-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about when it was build. It could be built in 20th century to look like something built in 19th century",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 85,
"n": 14,
"c": 1
} |
82415n | Then he sobered. | He was drunk. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "946-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If he was not sober due to alcohol, then the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "946-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "For a person to sober, they have to be drunk before.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "946-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He could also be not sober because of the drugs.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "946-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He can be faint because of hunger or desease.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "946-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "sobered means becoming not drunk",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 40,
"n": 22,
"c": 38
} |
82700c | During his disastrous campaign in Russia, he found time in Moscow to draw up a new statute for the Com??die-Francaise (the national theater), which had been dissolved during the Revolution. | Russia has been successfully invaded hundreds of times. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1249-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention how many times Russia has been invaded.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1249-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no information about how many times Russia was invaded.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1249-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Nothing shows how many times has Russia been invaded.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1249-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about how many times Russia has been invaded",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 76,
"c": 23
} |
1073c | News ' cover says the proliferation of small computer devices and the ascendance of Web-based applications are eroding Microsoft's dominance. | Microsoft is a more profitable company than Apple. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "747-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the profits of Microsoft and Apple.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "747-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about Apple.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "747-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Apple is not mentioned in the context, so we can not compare which company is more profitable.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "747-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the profit-comparision between Microsoft and Apple",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 83,
"c": 13
} |
120149c | There's a lot of villas all the way along, but by degrees they seemed to get more and more thinned out, and in the end we got to one that seemed the last of the bunch. | There were only a few villas the whole way along, until we reached a small village that seemed to be the end. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1139-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly suggests that there are many villas all the way along.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1139-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the end they reached a single villa, not a small village.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1139-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There are a lot of villas the whole way along.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1139-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is a lot of villas all the way along.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 22,
"n": 9,
"c": 69
} |
124037n | The park was established in 1935 and was given Corbett's name after India became independent. | The park changed names due to the independence. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1415-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The park probably received a name in 1935, so the new name would be a change.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1415-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The park was renamed after the independence, but the reason for the name change is unclear.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1415-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The park changed names after the independence, but independence can not be the reason of changing, it can be a coincidence.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1415-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whether the park had a name already before the independence.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 69,
"n": 27,
"c": 4
} |
92062c | Krugman's column will henceforth be known as The Dismal Science, a phrase too famous to be ownable by anyone, except possibly British essayist Thomas Carlyle (1795-1881), who coined it. | Krugman writes novels. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "478-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's clear that Krugman writes a column, but not clear whether they write novels.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "478-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Krugman has a column known as \"The Dismal Science\", it can be a novel column, but also can be others like essay column.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "478-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Krugman is a columnist, he doesn't write novels.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "478-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, in the context is his column, which appears often in newspaper",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 6,
"n": 64,
"c": 30
} |
131235c | Even if the entire unified surplus were saved, GDP per capita would fall somewhat short of the U.S. historical average of doubling every 35 years. | Even if the entire unified surplus were lost, GDP per capita would fall somewhat short of the U.S. historical average of doubling every 35 years. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "700-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear what would happen to the GDP if the surplus would be lost instead of saved.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "700-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context state if the surplus were saved",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 32,
"n": 17,
"c": 51
} |
46820e | and my and my part-time work you know it's not our the restaurant our favorite restaurant in the town of Salisbury where actually we live you know where my where i'll return to my job or whatever we can normally eat out for um under fourteen dollars | My first part time job was in a restaurant in Salisbury where you could eat out for under $14. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "708-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not mentioned in the context whether the speaker's first part time job was in a restaurant in Salisbury.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "708-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "1. The part-time work in Salisbury can not be the first job; 2. The part-time job can not in a restaurant.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "708-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about if it was my first part time job",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "708-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "My part time job is not in a restaurant",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 34,
"n": 55,
"c": 11
} |
77590c | do you think most states have that or | I think most states have that. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1507-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is an answer to the question in the context. It may be true or false.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1507-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker poses a question and doesn't assert that most states have that.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1507-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about what I think in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 19,
"n": 70,
"c": 11
} |
128542e | There should be someone here who knew more of what was going on in this world than he did now. | He knew things, but hoped someone else knew more. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "964-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "someone is hoped to be here to know more of what was going on than he did",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "964-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only suggests that someone else knew more than he did, it is not clear whether he hoped so.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "964-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether he hoped or only epected that there was someone who knew more.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "964-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He supposed that someone else knew more, but it can not reflect whether he hoped so or not, maybe he hoped that he knew the most in the world.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 82,
"n": 18,
"c": null
} |
74768e | She admits to Dorcas, 'I don't know what to do; scandal between husband and wife is a dreadful thing.' At 4 o'clock she has been angry, but completely mistress of herself. | She had remained in control despite her anger. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1135-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is clear from the context that she got control of herself.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1135-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Mistress of herself\" means that the she was in control of herself.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1135-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"She has been angry, but completely mistress of herself. \"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 57,
"n": 32,
"c": 11
} |
122928e | A small page-boy was waiting outside her own door when she returned to it. | When she came back to her door she found something waiting. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1470-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The someone waiting was the small page-boy.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1470-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that someone was waiting, we don't know if something was waiting as well.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1470-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe beside the page-boy, there are something else waiting.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1470-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not correct to say \"a small page-boy\" as \"something\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1470-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "it was rather someone waiting",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | true | {
"e": 77,
"n": 10,
"c": 13
} |
139409e | Then, all the time, it was in the spill vase in Mrs. Inglethorp's bedroom, under our very noses? I cried. | You mean we were so near it constantly? | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "467-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Under our very noses\" means that it was very near to us.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "467-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"under our very noses\" means in our very nearby surrendings",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 78,
"n": 21,
"c": 1
} |
59208n | He's chosen Meg Ryan. | A possible selection would be Meg Ryan or Jon Doe. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1175-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The selection is Meg Ryan. So Meg Ryan or Jon Doe is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1175-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is possible, because Meg Ryan is one of the two candidates.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1175-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear from which pool he chose Meg Ryan.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1175-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the other choice of person",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 13,
"n": 48,
"c": 39
} |
133597n | In manual systems, attestations, verifications, and approvals are usually shown by a signature or initial of an individual on a hard copy document. | The only things that signatures in manual systems show are attestations, verifications, or approvals. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "666-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Signatures could also show other things in addition to the mentioned ones.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "666-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sinatures in manual systems can be used for more purposes except from attestations, verifications, and approvals.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "666-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info that signatures only shows attestations, verifications and approvals. Signatures could show more than that",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "666-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Attestations, verifications and approvals, all three of these things, not just one of these things, are showed by a signature.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 32,
"n": 52,
"c": 16
} |
80517e | This doesn't look good. | This looks really bad. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "606-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"not look good\" implies \"bad\"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "606-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that it doesn't look good, which may be normal or bad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "606-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not good is not equivalent to really bad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "606-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "This doesn't look good, but it can look just a little bit bad, or really bad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "606-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "possible exaggeration: \"not looking good\" might be not as serious as \"really bad\"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 65,
"n": 32,
"c": 3
} |
93236c | The word itself, tapa, is translated as lid and derives from the old custom of offering a bite of food along with a drink, the food being served on a saucer sitting on top of the glass like a lid. | Tapas are large portions and are a very filling meal. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1589-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the protion size of tapas.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1589-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The meaning of the word tapa could have radically changed and now signify large portions.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1589-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Tapas only offer \"a bite of food\", so it is not \"very filling\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1589-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Tapas are small portions",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 2,
"n": 30,
"c": 68
} |
142643c | The standard technology assumptions of scenario A were used by EIA in the development of the AEO2001 reference case projections. | EIA used the standard technology assumptions to eliminate the AEO2001 reference case projections. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "145-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about developing AEO2001 reference case projections by using the assumptions, while the statement talks about elimination.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "145-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The assumptions were used to develop the projections, not eliminate them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "145-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "EIA used the standard technology assumptions to develop the AEO2001 reference case projections, not to \"eliminate\" them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "145-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was used during the development of the AEO2021",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 20,
"n": 19,
"c": 61
} |
31113e | One wag, J., wrote in to ask, Is there a difference between pests and airlines? | J. thinks there is no difference between pests and airlines. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1532-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question from J. could be a rhetorical question to which the speaker already has a standard answer, which is that there is no difference.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1532-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Literally taken the question is so absurd that it is most likely a rhetorical question implying that there really is no difference.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1532-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question from J. could be a simple question which needs to be answered.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1532-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context J only asked a questions. It is unknown about his opinion",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 28,
"n": 55,
"c": 17
} |
34776c | We did not study the reasons for these deviations specifically, but they likely result from the context in which federal CIOs operate. | The Context in which federal CIOs operate is no different from other CIOs. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1220-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context refers only to a hypothetical, we don't know whether it is the truth that the context in which federal CIOs operate is different.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1220-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Other CIOs are not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1220-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Federal CIOs can be semilar with other CIOs, also can be different from others.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1220-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The contexts of different CIOs potentially lead to these deviations",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 10,
"n": 60,
"c": 30
} |
121422c | it it like strange that it you're right in the middle of the mountains and it's so brown and dry but boy you just didn't feel | you are in the right part of the mountains. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1019-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether someone is in the right part or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1019-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether right in the middle of the mountains is also the right part of the mountains.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1019-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not clear context",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1019-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"right\" in context means exactly, not the side of the mounstains, and your location is in the middle of the mountains.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 12,
"n": 72,
"c": 16
} |
104805e | California is high | California is hyped up! | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "641-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"high\" is one state of \"hyped up\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "641-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the \"high\" means in the context of spirit, that Californa is a hyped city",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "641-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "High is not the same as hyped up but also does not exclude the possibility.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "641-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the \"high\" in the context mean that Californa is geographically high. Then it does not entail the statement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 12,
"n": 72,
"c": 16
} |
115821n | The Chinese calendar was used to calculate the year of Japan's foundation by counting back the 1,260 years of the Chinese cosmological cycle. | The calculation of Japan's year of foundation was very exact. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "527-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "yes, because it was counted back 1,260 years of the Chinese cosmological cycle",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "527-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests how the Japan' year was calculated, but doesn't mention whether this calculation was exact or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "527-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether this calculation is exact.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "527-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context it just states how Japan's year of foundation is calculated, but it can not prove the method is exact or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 41,
"n": 56,
"c": 3
} |
80630e | The tree-lined avenue extends less than three blocks to the sea. | The sea isn't even three blocks away. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1277-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement talk about the distance to the sea is lee than three blocks.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1277-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the avenue reaches the sea after less then three blocks, it cannot be further away than three blocks.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1277-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The avenue is less than three blocks to the sea.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1277-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the statement means that the sea is less than three blocks away",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1277-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not given where is the location of the narrator.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1277-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "If the statement means that the sea is more than three blocks away",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 89,
"n": 8,
"c": 3
} |
138862c | Also, other sorbent-based approaches in development may prove in time to be preferable to ACI, making the use of ACI only a conservative assumption. | Hydrogen-based approaches in development may be preferable to ACl. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "450-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions sorbent-based approaches, not hydrogen-based ones. But this doesn't rule out hydrogen-based approaches.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "450-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context hydrogen-based approaches are not discussed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "450-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context mentions sorbent-based approaches, whereas in the statement it is hydrogen-based approaches, which is not mentioned in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 18,
"n": 66,
"c": 16
} |
105179c | I was to watch for an advertisement in the Times. | I looked for an ad in my mailbox. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "685-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker indeed looked for an ad, but the context doesn't mention where the speaker looked for.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "685-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about an obligation, but it is not clear whether the speaker then acts accordingly.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "685-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I searched \"the Times\" not \"my mailbox\" for an ad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "685-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Times is a newpaper",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 45,
"c": 48
} |
109876n | Text Box 2.1: Gross Domestic Product and Gross National Product 48Text Box 4.1: How do the NIPA and federal unified budget concepts of | This text displays how GDP and GNP is calculated. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "164-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what the text displays.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "164-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context it only offer a theme of GDP and GNP, but it can be about every aspect of the concepts, like the growth or the depression, and the calculation methods.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "164-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't show the calculation of GDP and DNP.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "164-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No it doesn't. It only shows the what GDP and GNP stand for",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 25,
"n": 45,
"c": 30
} |
65353n | Don't take it to heart, lad, he said kindly. | He was trying to console the lad. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1042-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is indeed about the consolation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1042-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Don't take it to heart\" is an attempt of consolation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1042-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The words and the attitude of him can express his attempt to console the lad.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1042-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"don't take it to heart\" means not to overthink something.. So the lad should not overthink something that might bother him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 97,
"n": 3,
"c": null
} |
16494c | It cannot be outlawed. | It has to be made illegal. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1072-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It cannot be outlawed means that it is legal.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1072-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"cannot be outlawed\" means \"cannot be made illegal\". So it has to stay legal",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 8,
"c": 84
} |
60732n | It started with The Wild Bunch : We sexualized violence, we made it beautiful. | Violence is now look at in the positive due to The Wild Bunch. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1268-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Making violence beautiful is is a positive way of looking at violence.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1268-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "People made violence beautiful is a way to look at it positively.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1268-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether people have a positive opinion about violence, only because The Wild Bunch made it look beautiful.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1268-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The current state of how violence is looked at is unknown; We only know it started to be looked at in a positive view",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 70,
"n": 28,
"c": 2
} |
88646c | You see, he said sadly, "you have no instincts." | He said that I had no willpower. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "501-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the comments on willpower.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "501-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Instincts do not totally relate with willpower.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "501-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He said \"no instincts\", not \"no willpower\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "501-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Instincts\" are not the same as \"willpower\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 13,
"c": 80
} |
53074n | ooh it's kind of tough to think of some of the others although i do watch some of some of those frivolous things uh like on Thursday nights at nine o'clock when i get home from aerobics i will watch uh Knots Landing | I only watch frivolous things on Thursday nights. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1036-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that the speaker watch frivolous things on Thursdays, but doesn't mention if he/she watch them on other days as well.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1036-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They could also watch frivolous things at other times.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1036-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I do watch frivolous things on Thursday nights, but maybe I also watch at other time.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1036-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Thursday is mentioned as example. There is no info about what he does on other weekday nights",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 23,
"n": 69,
"c": 8
} |
61818n | Kutchins and Kirk cite a particularly amusing example of such Robert Spitzer, the man in charge of DSM-III , was sitting down with a committee that included his wife, in the process of composing a criteria-set for Masochistic Personality Disorder--a disease that was suggested for, but never made it into, the DSM-III-R (a revised edition). | DSM-III-R is a book of personality disorders. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1125-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Masochistic Personality Disorder was suggested fot DSM-III-R, so the later should be about personality disorders.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1125-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that Masochistic Personality Disorder is not in the book, it doesn't mention the content of the book.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1125-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The book could contain also other things than only personality disorders.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1125-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We only know that DSM-III is a personality disorders. But DSM-III-R could just be a medical book for all kinds of disorders",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 63,
"n": 32,
"c": 5
} |
46003n | trying to keep grass alive during a summer on a piece of ground that big was expensive | The watering and fertilizer, can cost a lot to keep grass alive in the summer months. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "386-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Keeping grass alive on a big ground can be expensive. For that you need watering and fertilizer, which can be expensive",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "386-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention the reason for the high cost.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "386-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear what exactly is expensive about keeping the grass alive.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "386-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It costs a lot to keep grass alive in the summer, but the reason can be watering and fertilizer, or something else like labor and pesticide.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 69,
"n": 30,
"c": 1
} |
6386n | isn't it i can remember i've only been here eight years but i can remember coming to work from i used to live in Wylie and i could see downtown Dallas | Downtown Dallas was a short drive from where I lived in Wylie. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1252-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker can see downtown Dallas from where he/she lived, so it is true to say that it was a short drive.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1252-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the person could see Downtown Dallas from their place in Wylie, it probably was only a short drive.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1252-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"I\" saw Dallas on my way to work from Wylie. Considering daily commute, Dallas should not be very far away from Wylie",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1252-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I could see downtown Dallas maybe because it was not far away from where I lived in Wylie, maybe because I lived in a high-rise apartment. Besides, as there could be a river between me and the downtown, if there is no bridges, the drive still will be long.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 58,
"n": 41,
"c": 1
} |
98739n | The living is not equal to the Ritz, he observed with a sigh. | The living is nothing compared to the glamour of the Ritz, he said sadly. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "335-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can infer from the sigh that the speaker did think that living here is not as good as in Ritz.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "335-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The sign and the words proved that he didn't think the living is good as the Ritz.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "335-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "335-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether he sighed from disappointment or relief.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 71,
"n": 22,
"c": 7
} |
108624c | Exhibit 3 presents total national emissions of NOx and SO2 from all sectors, including power. | In Exhibit 3 there are the total regional emissions od NOx and SO2 from all sectors. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1407-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Exhibit 3 shows the total national emmissions, not regional emissions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1407-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The emissions are national not regional.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1407-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Exhibit 3 is about \"national\" not \"regional\" emissions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1407-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be national emissions",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 47,
"n": 11,
"c": 42
} |
106013c | Ca'daan heard the Kal grunt and felt the horse lift. | The Kal heard Ca'daan grunt. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "699-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "true, statement is a part of the context",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "699-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The grunt was from Kal, not Ca'daan.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "699-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Ca'daan grunted not the Kal.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "699-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is Ca'daan that heard the Kal, not reverse.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 9,
"n": 16,
"c": 75
} |
37407n | 5 are highly correlated during summer months in some areas. | Six are correlated to winter in certain areas. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1284-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only suggests the correlation during summer months, not winter.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1284-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be that six are correlated to winter, the context only speaks about summer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1284-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Winter months are not discussed in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1284-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about 6",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 63,
"c": 37
} |
70590c | China's civil war sent distressing echoes to Hong Kong. | Japan fought a civil war. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "355-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no mention of the Japan civil war in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "355-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be that Japan also fought a civil war, but it is not clear from the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "355-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Japanese civil war is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "355-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "no info about japan; irrelavant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "355-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "China fought a civil war",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 1,
"n": 49,
"c": 50
} |
23901e | Then Shuman claims that Linux provides no graphical user interface. | They made accusations about the platform. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "225-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can infer from the claim in the context that the made accusations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "225-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "That an operating system doesn't contain a graphical user interface can be called an accusation.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "225-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Linux provides no graphical user interface\" can be a common description or an accusation, the attitude needs more background to prove.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "225-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the claim being an accusation",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 70,
"n": 22,
"c": 8
} |
23280n | Sphinxes were guardian deitiesinEgyptianmythologyandthis was monumentalprotection,standing73 m (240 ft)longand20 m (66 feet) high. | Sphinxes were put in the tombs to protect the dead. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1427-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no information in the context about where Sphinxes were placed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1427-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context what exactly the sphinxes protected.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1427-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sphinxes' location is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1427-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whether if Sphinxes were put into the tombs",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 24,
"n": 70,
"c": 6
} |
135247c | The original wax models of the river gods are on display in the Civic Museum. | They have models made out of clay. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1292-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention about the clay models.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1292-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They could also have models made out of clay next to those made out of wax.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1292-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context it just refered to a wax model, but provided no information about clay model.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1292-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is out of wax",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 5,
"n": 38,
"c": 57
} |
58357c | What changed? | Nothing changed. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "95-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker doesn't assert anything about whether something changed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "95-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context is a questions. The statement is answer, but can not be entailed.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 76,
"c": 20
} |
19803e | But there's SOMETHING. | Surely there's something. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "581-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that there is something.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "581-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "581-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The uppercase of \"something\" can express \"surely\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "581-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is something despite of the tone",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "581-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Surely\" can not find a correspondant word in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 90,
"n": 8,
"c": 2
} |
144753n | When he's ready for a major strike, how many innocents do you suppose are going to suffer? To quote one of your contemporaries; 'The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.' ' | He won't care how many innocent people will suffer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "691-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question in the context could be a rhetorical question to which the speaker already has a standard answer, which is that he won't care.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "691-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He is preparing for a major striking, which will cause many innocents to suffer",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "691-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether he cares that innocents will suffer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "691-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "His attitude towards the suffer of innocents is not given in the context, he maybe cares, maybe not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 49,
"n": 45,
"c": 6
} |
15100e | but uh that has been the major change that we have noticed in gardening and that's about the extent of what we've done just a little bit on the patio and uh and waiting for the the rain to subside so we can mow we after about a month we finally got to mow this weekend | We have not done much gardening yet because of the rain. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "893-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that them have only done a little gardening and needed to wait for the rain to die down, which suggests that the reason was raining.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "893-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speakers says that they did only a little gardening because of the rain.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "893-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We plan to mow after the rain subside",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "893-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We have done just a little bit, but the reason can be the rain or something else like temperature.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 88,
"n": 12,
"c": null
} |
28507n | It is, as you see, highly magnified. | It is plain for you to see that it is amplified. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "438-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both the context and the statement suggest that it is magnified.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "438-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "438-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"highly magnified\" can be interpreted \"amplified\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "438-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It can be seen, and it is magnified",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 76,
"n": 14,
"c": 10
} |
123748n | There are many such at the present time. | There are over two currently. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "780-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If there are many then there are certainly over two.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "780-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Many\" ususally is over two.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "780-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Many means more than two",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "780-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The word \"many\" in the context indicates more than one, but we don't know if there are more than two.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 82,
"n": 15,
"c": 3
} |
111338c | He threw one of them and shot the other. | He kept his gun holstered. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1025-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether he had other shooting weapons than his gun.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1025-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement indicates that he didn't use the gun.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1025-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He \"shot\" one, so he need to pull his gun out of the holster.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1025-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He shot one of them",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 3,
"n": 7,
"c": 90
} |
52171c | For such a governmentwide review, an entrance conference is generally held with applicable central agencies, such as the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) or the Office of Personnel Management. | An entrance conference is held with specialized agencies. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "118-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Applicable central agencies mentioned in the context are indeed specialized agencies.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "118-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context with less detail.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "118-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) or the Office of Personnel Management are specialized agencies.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "118-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "the conference is held with applicable central agencies. They can then be considered as specialized",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "118-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "For a governmentwide review the statement is true, but for a normal entrance conference, it is could be held with specialized agencies or any temporary agencies.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 84,
"n": 8,
"c": 8
} |
90548e | Splendid! | The speaker is excited by the situation. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "169-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The comment \"splendid\" and the exclamation mark indicate that the speaker is excitied.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "169-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker calls out \"splendid!\" so they are probably excited about the situation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "169-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Splendid\" means very good, and the exclamation mark also conveys the speaker's excitement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "169-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Splendid entails excitement",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 72,
"n": 27,
"c": 1
} |
81842c | Answer? said Julius. | Julius already knew the answer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1149-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Julius is asking someone for answer, he might already know the right answer and wants to know if others do.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1149-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether Julius is really asking for the answer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1149-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was rather a question from Julius, we do not know if he knows the answer",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1149-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Julius is asking for answer, the question might indicate that he didn't know the answer.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 6,
"n": 71,
"c": 23
} |
91601n | Even today, Yanomamo men raid villages, kill men, and abduct women for procreative purposes. | Yanomamo eats food. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1380-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention if Yanomamo eats food.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1380-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Raiding villages, killing men and abducting women have nothing to do with food supply.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1380-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 71,
"c": 21
} |
118415n | John Panzar has characterized street delivery as a bottleneck function because a single firm can deliver to a recipient at a lower total cost than multiple firms delivering to the same customer. | John Panzar believes in nationalizing all postal delivery services and couriers into a single entity for cost-saving purposes. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "974-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "John Panzer supposes that delivering to one customer by only one firm costs fewer than multiple firms.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "974-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the John Panzar's thoughts about street delivery, not the proposal to nationalize delivery services.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "974-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear what John Panzar's stance on nationalizing postal services is.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "974-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "John Panzer didn't mention the way how could one customer only received delivery from one firm, it could be nationalization, but also could be others like monopoly.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "974-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "exaggeration: No info about John Panzar's believe and ambitions",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 53,
"n": 42,
"c": 5
} |
113644n | so do you have do you have the long i guess not not if there's see i was raised in New York but i guess up there you all don't have too long of a growing season do you | I am looking for a written guide to growing plants in different places in the country. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "716-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Althought the speaker asks about the growing season in the context, the reason is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "716-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the speaker is looking for a guide or simply asking a question.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "716-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "not clear context; potential irrelevance",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 70,
"c": 22
} |
47260n | The good news, however, can be found in reports like this one. | The good news is that the puppy's life was able to be saved. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1428-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what is the good news.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1428-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear what the good news is.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1428-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The topic of good news can be puppy's life or cat's life or parrot's life or anything.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1428-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about a puppy in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 86,
"c": 11
} |
129081e | right oh they've really done uh good job of keeping everybody informed of what's going on sometimes i've wondered if it wasn't almost more than we needed to know | After sharing all information with everyone, I think I may have shared too much. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1536-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker talks about \"they\" sharing the information not about themselves.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1536-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not given in the context whether I have shared all information, or do I think I have shared too much.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1536-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not the speaker who shares the information with everybody, it's them.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1536-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not I but they who shared all information.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1536-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"I\" did not share the information, \"they\" did",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 63,
"n": 20,
"c": 17
} |
18189e | The important thing is to realize that it's way past time to move it. | It has not been moved yet in the past. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1006-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that it's no longer the time to move, which indicates that it hasn't been moved yet.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1006-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because it is too late to move it now, so in the past it was not moved",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1006-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It might have been moved in the past and now is needed to be moved again.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1006-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states it is not time to move it now, but the history of movement is not refered to.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 38,
"n": 56,
"c": 6
} |
91797c | We know they will have to come from the south but that gives them a space as wide as the town in which to launch their attack. | The south is totally protected against an attack. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1221-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context, it is analysed that they will attack from the south, but the protection of the south is not measurable.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1221-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that the south is the right place to launch the attack, which indicates that the south cannot totally defend itself against an attack.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1221-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The space in the south makes it not totally protected.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1221-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is a space in the south as wide as the town to launch their attack",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 2,
"n": 37,
"c": 61
} |
917c | eligible individuals and the rules that apply if a state does not substantially enforce the statutory requirements. | It does not matter whether or not a state enforces the statutory requirements. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1193-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can only make sure, if a state does not enforces the statutory requirements, the rules apply; otherwise, we don't know whether the rules take effect or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1193-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It matters whether the state enforces the statuory requirements because then other rules apply.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1193-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There are rules that apply if the state does not enforces the statutory requirements, meaning it does matter that the state do enforces these requirements. Because if not, then there is no need for those rules to exist",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 11,
"n": 46,
"c": 43
} |
89995c | yeah then you don't have you don't have that mess to clean up when you use an oil oil base painting and boy i'll tell you oh | Typically oil based paints are easy to work with and clean up. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "493-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Because in the context, \"you\" didn't use oil based paints, so \"you\" have a mess to clean up",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "493-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether oil based paints are also easy to work with.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 65,
"n": 19,
"c": 16
} |
33822e | Why shouldn't he be? | There is no reason he shouldn't be. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "395-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "395-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question is open. It is not known if there is reason or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 68,
"n": 27,
"c": 5
} |
42983e | The town is also known for its sparkling wine and for the caves where about 70 per?cent of France's cultivated mushrooms are grown. | The town has a lot of sparkling wine. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1376-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The town is famous for its sparkling wine, so it should have lots of sparkling wine.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1376-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could also be a small amount of sparkling wine for which the place is famous.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1376-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is only known about the reputation of the town's wine, but not known about the quantity of the wine",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 28,
"c": null
} |
6105e | Asked about abortion the other day on CNN, Republican National Committee Chairman Jim Nicholson also invoked what is apparently the party-line inclusive party. | The Republican National Committee Chairman gave the party's standard answer on the subject of abortion when he was asked about it on CNN. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1060-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I think the party-line mentioned in the context refers to the party's standard answer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1060-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1060-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Party-line\" typically refers to a position or stance that aligns with the official position or policies of a political party, so it can be refered to the \"standard answer\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1060-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He toed the party line, meaning he said what is in line with the party's agenda",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1060-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Inclusive party\" suggests a political party that welcomes diverse views and members, so it should not be the party's typical answer.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 74,
"n": 22,
"c": 4
} |
26143n | However, the associated cost is primarily some of the costs of assessing and collecting duties on imported merchandise, such as the salaries of import specialists (who classify merchandise) and the costs of processing paperwork. | the associated cost is how much people spend relative to this amount | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "234-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The associated cost is not in the general sense of how much people spend, but is specifically defined in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "234-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context, \"the associated cost is primarily some of the costs of assessing and collecting duties on imported merchandise\", it is about the goods, so the description \"relative to this amount\" is different from the definition given before.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "234-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's the cost of assessing and collecting duties",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 24,
"n": 37,
"c": 39
} |
100768n | well in a way you can travel light | You won't need to pack much. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "328-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Traveling light means exactly no need to pack much.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "328-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If you can travel light, then you don't need to pack much.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "328-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Travel light\" means exactly not packing much.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "328-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Traveling light entails traveling with a small package",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "328-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"In a way\" suggests that it could be not the usual meaning of travelling light.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 85,
"n": 15,
"c": null
} |
82510e | although the uh it's uh it we almost one day we painted the house to uh we painted we painted the whole inside and it had all this dark trim we thought uh you know we did the one wall but the other trim i'm trying to think i think i think we left most of it because it gets to be uh they don't do that in the newer houses now we don't the uh mold everything is white in a new house everything is white | We painted the house over the duration of one day. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1190-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that the speaker spent almost a day to paint the house, so the time they spent is indeed over the duration if one day.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [
1,
2,
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 53,
"n": 39,
"c": 8
} |
102563n | The judge gave vent to a faint murmur of disapprobation, and the prisoner in the dock leant forward angrily. | The judge ordered the court to be silent. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "424-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about slience.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "424-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The judge \"gave vent to a faint murmur of disapprobation\" can not be taken as an order for quiet.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "424-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The judge only made a murmur and didn't give a direct order.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "424-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He let the crowd murmur",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 24,
"n": 45,
"c": 31
} |
48553c | Keep your eyes open for Renaissance details, grand doorways, and views into lovely courtyards. | All of the doorways and courtyards have been completely remodeled since the Renaissance. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "430-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention if the doorways and courtyards were remodeled since the Renaissance.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "430-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not garanteed that all of the objects mentioned in the context have been completely remodeled, maybe part of them kept the same as before the Renaissance.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "430-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about whether they have been remodeled or not. They could also be built in the Renaissance time",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "430-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the doorways and courtyards would have been remodeled since the Renaissance, then it wouldn't make sense to look for the Reneaissance details.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 3,
"n": 53,
"c": 44
} |
54458n | This one ended up being surprisingly easy! | This question was very easy to answer. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1029-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement suggest the easiness of what they talk about.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1029-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1029-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is true because the question \"ended up being surprisingly easy\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1029-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A question ended up easy, meaning it's easy to answer",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 81,
"n": 19,
"c": null
} |
17576n | The percent of total cost for each function included in the model and cost elasticity (with respect to volume) are shown in Table 1. | Table 1 also shows a picture diagram for each function. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "67-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "And this diagram shows the cost for each function",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "67-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention if Table 1 presents the picture diagram.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "67-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear in which way the values are presented in Table 1.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "67-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, Table 1 shows the \"the percent of total cost for each function\" and \"cost elasticity\", not picture diagram.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 27,
"n": 64,
"c": 9
} |
103431n | In addition, the senior executives at these organizations demonstrated their sustained commitment to financerelated improvement initiatives by using key business/line managers to drive improvement efforts, attending key meetings, ensuring that the necessary resources are made available, and creating a system of rewards and incentives to recognize those who support improvement initiatives. | This system of rewards and incentives will hopefully improve company performance. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "343-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The rewards and incentives will be given to those who support improvement initiatives, so the company is more likely to improve their proferance under these rewards incentives.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "343-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The measurement taken is thought for finance-related improvenemt.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "343-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The system of rewards and incentives",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "343-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the speaker hopes that the rewards and incentives improve company performance.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "343-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The measures mentioned in the context can not prove their effect \"will hopefully improve company performace\" or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 83,
"n": 16,
"c": 1
} |
64123c | Per week? | Every day. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1104-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is a question and the statement is an answer. But I don't know whether the statement is exactly the answer to the question in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1104-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "From a question can not be entailed to a answer",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1104-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "per week means once every seven days",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
1,
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 24,
"c": 74
} |
56163c | She would be almost certainly sent to you under an assumed one. | The man told the other man that Bill would be sent to him. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "114-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention who told whom.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "114-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Bill is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "114-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The gender of Bill and \"she\" and \"you\" is unknown",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 38,
"c": 60
} |
11297c | Transforming Control of Public Health Programs Raises Concerns ( | Everyone is content with the change of public health programs. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1321-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether people are satisfied with the programs.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1321-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "exaggeration: \"Raising concerns\" doesn't mean that everyone is concerned. Maybe someone is not concerned and the context will still hold",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1321-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The program raises concerns, so not everyone is content with it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1321-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, because the change of control of Public Health Programs \"raises concerns\", there must be someone not content with it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 24,
"c": 76
} |
32889n | Extremely limited exceptions to the authority are established in 31 U.S.C. | They were trying to eliminate all exceptions. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "807-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that there are extremely limited exceptions, but not whether someone wanted to eliminate the exceptions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "807-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether they tried to eliminate the exceptions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "807-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The limitation of exceptions will not definitey lead to eliminating all exceptions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "807-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The motive of them is unknown. Maybe they didn't try to eliminate all, but just eliminate the unnecessary ones.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 10,
"n": 62,
"c": 28
} |
19c | On the northern slopes of this rocky outcropping is the site of the ancient capital of the island, also called Thira, which dates from the third century b.c. (when the Aegean was under Ptolemaic rule). | Is the site of the ancient asteroid impact, also called Thira. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "392-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear if the site of the ancient capital mentioned in the context is also the site of the ancient asteroid impact.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "392-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether there was an asteroid impact on Thira.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "392-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"The ancient asteroid impact\" is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "392-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is the ancient capital of the island, not an asteroid impact",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 8,
"n": 59,
"c": 33
} |
32754e | After shuttering the DOE, Clinton could depict himself as a crusader against waste and bureaucracy who succeeded where even Reagan failed. | Clinton shuttered the DOE to move against waste. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1016-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If shuttering the DOE allowed Clinton to appear as a crusader against waste then it probably was done to do something against waste.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1016-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He shuttered the DOE, and were depicted as crusader against waste",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1016-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only suggests that Clinton can describe the reason as being against waste, but it is not clear if this reason is actually the truth.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1016-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Clinton could depict himself as a crusader against waste and bureaucracy\" doesn't mean it is his true intention is \"to move against waste.\" Perhaps he really is just trying to save energy, but maybe he has other intentions.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 80,
"n": 18,
"c": 2
} |
12815n | yeah well that's my uh i mean every time i've tried to go you know it's always there's there's always a league bowling | Every time I try to go bowling there are leagues only and I can't bowl. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1098-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement suggests that the speaker can't go bowling because of the leagues.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1098-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1098-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Usually if the place is occupied by a league, then other people can not play there.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1098-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe the place is big enough, so even the there is a league bowling, I can still bowl",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 56,
"n": 44,
"c": null
} |
135898c | The end is near! Then a shout went up, and Hanson jerked his eyes from the gears to focus on a group of rocs that were landing at the far end of the camp. | It's all over, Hanson whispered as he stared at the gears. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "456-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context if \"It's all over\" was Hanson's whisper.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "456-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear whether or what Hanson whispered",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "456-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The end is near, meaning it's soon to be over but not all over yet",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
2
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 12,
"n": 44,
"c": 44
} |
82830n | In the 19th century, when Kashmir was the most exotic hill-station of them all, the maharaja forbade the British to buy land there, so they then hit on the brilliant alternative of building luxuriously appointed houseboats moored on the lakes near Srinagar. | The maharaja allowed the British to build houseboats on the lakes. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "140-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The British did build houseboats on the lakes, so the maharaja must at least have tolerated it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "140-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The British was forbidden to buy land in Kashmir, so they buit houseboats on the lakes near Srinagar. Because they built it, so they must have been allowed",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "140-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions what the maharaja forbade, not what he allowed.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "140-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The British are allowed to moor houseboats on the lakes, but whether it is allowed for them to \"build\" houseboats is not mentioned.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 60,
"n": 20,
"c": 20
} |
74509n | Under the budget deal, by 2002, national defense will consume about $273 billion a year compared with $267 billion now. | The United States national defense budget will increase by 6 billion dollars. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "771-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The budget increases from 267 to 273 billion, an increase of $6 billion.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "771-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "$273 billion - $267 billion = $6 billion",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "771-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is true, because 273-267 = 6.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "771-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "right now the budget is 267 Million, in 2002 it will be 273 Million, making the incease by 6 million",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 87,
"n": 4,
"c": 9
} |
98944c | evaluation questions. | Only statements of the evaluation are available. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1577-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The state of statements of the evaluation is not given in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1577-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
0,
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 12,
"n": 55,
"c": 33
} |
19208c | Hearty Sabbath meals. | Hearty meals will only be offered to Buddhists | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "316-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Buddhists typically don't celebrate Sabbath, so the hearty meals will most likely be offered to Jews.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "316-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Sabbath is Judaism's day, it doesn't make sense that hearty meals will only be offered to Buddhists, not to jewish people.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "316-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is jewish traditional meals",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
0
] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 47,
"c": 52
} |