text
stringlengths 19
982
| label
stringclasses 12
values | Claim
stringclasses 69
values | Source
stringclasses 10
values |
|---|---|---|---|
Let’s find out by comparing the actual temperatures since 1979 with what the 32 families of climate models used in the latest U.N. report on climate science predicted they would be. | cherry picking | 5.1.4 | Alhindi_train |
The 3 scientists argue that even if the planet warms by 5 degrees, humans can adjust. | false equivalence | 3.2.1 | jintrain |
There hasn't been any sea level rise in the San Francisco Bay for at least 70 years. | cherry picking | 1.6 | CARDS |
Then early next week I will post part 3, detailing a train of specific unscientific and anti-scientific steps in the IPCC analysis that render it not just scientifically invalid but properly classify it as a hoax and a fraud. | conspiracy theory | 5.3.2 | CARDS |
The ongoing rise in sea level that began with the end of the ice age continues with no great increase in magnitude | slothful induction | 1.6 | jintest |
Coldest start to May for more than 70 years. In fact, temperatures could hit the lowest ever recorded for May. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
I'm a staunch conservative. I disagree with the reasons for climate change. You can't pave over billions of acres of greenery and trees without moderation and not affect climate. Where do you think the water goes that was once used by plants and trees? The radiational heat? | single cause | 2.2 | hamburg_test3 |
I suspect that what the Maya calendar cycle was saying was not that this is the end, but rather that this is as good as it gets and the next many thousands start a long slow slide into cold. | slothful induction | 1.2 | CARDS |
The left is lying and using this to sell the climate change lie. | slothful induction | 5.2 | hamburg_test3 |
The Paris Agreement would also handicap America in the global race for new sources of energy . | slothful induction | 4.1.1 | jindev |
“Scientists are also expecting a ‘huge reduction’ in solar activity for 33 years between 2020 and 2053 that will cause thermometers to crash.” | misrepresentation | 1.2 | Alhindi_test |
Yet Climate Change Warriors keep flying around the world in private jets 1 at a time to conferences to eat endangered fish and ride around in limos and yachts. Pardon me if I suspect their honesty. | ad hominem | 5.2 | hamburg_test2 |
A waste of money global warming/ climate change isn't man made. IT occurs naturally and has since the planet was formed. | single cause | 2.1.4 | hamburg_test2 |
What are the models missing? Obsessed with radiation from greenhouse forcings and questionable temperature feedbacks, they ignore or poorly parameterize many important climate processes and undervalue the net cooling effect of the following events: | impossible expectations | 5.1.4 | CARDS |
The green freaks and climate change nuts hate Plymouth Rock. Still at Sea level December 26th 1620. Guess what. Still there at sea Level. Dang rising oceans because we use gasoline | anecdote | 1.6 | hamburg_test3 |
That's why the left went from GLOBAL WARMING to climate change. | misrepresentation | 1.8 | hamburg_test2 |
Brooks added that Antarctic ice is growing. | cherry picking | 1.1.1 | Alhindi_train |
The cost of living crisis is a result of the boom and bust system of control being bust! The virus, the war & climate change all cover for NWO to create a new social credit prison system, an electric one (on/off) with no escape! Stop the NWO or allow it. YOUR CHOICE! | conspiracy theory | 5.3.1 | hamburg_test3 |
Clearly, absorption and re-radiation of the sunshine in the upper atmosphere at this wavelength cools the Earth and is going to cause additional cooling as the concentration of CO2 increases. | misrepresentation | 2.3 | CARDS |
Despite the expenditure of over $50 billion to find evidence that man-induced greenhouse gasses are the primary cause of the current warming, not one piece of empirical evidence in support of this theory has been found. | slothful induction | 2.3 | CARDS |
There is no climate emergency, crisis, breakdown, bombshell or any other superlative you attach to it.The Great Barrier reef isn't dying, the poles are having their coldest periods in fifty years | cherry picking | 1 | hamburg_test3 |
"Despite the fact that the carbon trading market, along with "smart meter" programs, have been exposed as slush fund scams owned by the very globalists fearmongering about man-made climate change - namely Al Gore and Maurice Strong - designed to line the pockets of habitual con men who have been caught over and over again lying about the evidence behind global warming, states are now adopting their own version of the scheme so that the trick can be played on an unsuspecting public who still think that cap and trade hasn?t been implemented." | conspiracy theory | 5.3 | CARDS |
And as people are freezing to death in their homes, will we still be paying the green levies to stop global warming? | anecdote | 1.3 | hamburg_test3 |
Also, as Peltier (2009) points out, the GRACE gravitational-anomaly record indicates that sea level has actually fallen in recent years. | cherry picking | 1.6 | CARDS |
Climate Models Performing Poorly Compared to Actual Temperatures | impossible expectations | 5.1.4 | CARDS |
The media overplays every single extreme weather event and despite no scientific data or evidence, claims that the extreme weather is because of "climate change". | ad hominem | 5.2.2 | hamburg_test3 |
There has always been catastrophic weather. Of course we get to see it first hand. | single cause | 1.7 | hamburg_test2 |
Gas and oil are constantly being created and never run out. | slothful induction | 4.5.1 | hamburg_test3 |
Temperatures in Minden this week are forecast to be 30-40 degrees cooler than they were in 1936. President Barack Obama says that the US is heating out of control. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
The report , published in the journal Nature Geoscience on September 18, acknowledges that most of the models of warming trends failed to predict the "slowdown'' in warming post-2000, resulting in less pronounced warming than predicted and thus more room in the CO2 `"emissions budget'' for the coming decades. | cherry picking | 5.1.4 | jindev |
But carbon isn't the main driver of climate change. The sun is. | single cause | 2.1.1 | hamburg_test3 |
Tissue and Lewis continue saying that "glacial plants were severely carbon limited over a very long time period, until atmospheric CO2 began rising during the glacial-interglacial transition." In fact, they indicate that "controlled environment studies with modern plants grown in glacial CO2" have shown "significant carbon limitations on plant physiology even when other resources were generally not limiting ," citing Dippery et al. (1995) and Tissue et al. (1995). So in spite of anything one could have done to enhance their productivity (other than supply them with more CO2), glacial-age plants simply could not produce the bounty that today's plants do. In fact, they were fortunate to merely survive. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | CARDS |
For any objective reader and citizen of the world, this sort of bullying ought to inform everyone that science and its practice are now no longer free and willing. In fact, we are constantly being terrorized and threatened by the research funding gravy trains and large resources needed for science to progress and prosper. | conspiracy theory | 5.3.2 | CARDS |
Since Nov. 18, the normal high temperature has been hovering around 15 degrees colder than the historical normal temperature of 55 degrees. The normal low has been about 10 degrees lower than the normal temperature of 36 de grees. The national weather forecasters are predicting this same weather pattern going into the beginning of December. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
For if you own the dataset, you can reduce older temperatures and increase recent ones, just as NASA has been doing, and give the impression of greater warming. Naughty, naughty. more | conspiracy theory | 5.1.3 | CARDS |
Based on the last 25 years, 2013 was the fourth coldest. If we look at the average temperatures for the last 25 years, we see that they have pretty much remained constant. | cherry picking | 1.4 | CARDS |
global warming doesn't exist -- or at least hasn't for 19 years | cherry picking | 1.4 | jintrain |
Hubbard Glacier has been advancing into Disenchantment Bay for more than 100 years, according to NASA's Earth Observatory. In addition to its forward movement, the glacier has been thickening as well. | cherry picking | 1.1.4 | CARDS |
However the conspiracy main stream media News states a global warming, are they refering to HAARP? | conspiracy theory | 5.3 | hamburg_test3 |
DEMOCRATS CAN'T DEFINE ' climate change ' ! NOT A STINKING ONE OF THEM ! NONE NADA ZELCH !!! | ad hominem | 5.2 | hamburg_test3 |
It was minus 1.0 degrees in Gulmarg, two degrees below normal, while Pahalgam recorded minus 3.0 degrees today (Monday), three degree below normal. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
can today’s climate models be trusted when scientists have misrepresented the data in the past? | ad hominem | 5.1.4 | Alhindi_train |
However, I do not believe the earths climate is dominated by strong positive feedbacks and tipping points. It is this feedback hypothesis in climate models that multiplies warming to 3-4-5 degrees or more over the next century. In climate models, the catastrophe comes from feedback, not greenhouse effects, and I think this is a bad hypothesis. | slothful induction | 3.1 | CARDS |
I have emphasized that the CO2-temperature relationship is mostly caused by the influence of temperature on the gas concentrations (as seen through the 800-year lag in the Vostok data). | false choice | 2.3.3 | CARDS |
Again , why would anyone with critical thinking ability , trust ANYTHING , the government tells you? | ad hominem | 5.2.3 | hamburg_test2 |
He calculates the cooling effect of CO2 and other "greenhouse" gases to be 100 times greater than the heating effect. | misrepresentation | 2.3 | CARDS |
The Little Ice Age (LIA) showed that the present warming trend began prior to the major impact of the Industrial Revolution. Significant production of CO2 by humans began only after World War II. | single cause | 2.1.4 | CARDS |
Using data from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), a Science and Public Policy Institute paper published last month found that if the United States eliminated all carbon dioxide emissions, the overall impact on global temperature rise would be only 0.08 degrees Celsius by 2050. | impossible expectations | 4.2.3 | CARDS |
Since the late 1980s The New York Times has engaged in the most horrid effort to convince its readers and the world that the IPCC should be taken seriously even though its successive reports have proven to be an offense to real science and the truth. No opportunity was ignored to advance the hoax even in the face of incontrovertible facts of every description. | ad hominem | 5.2.2 | CARDS |
Since the ice extent dropped to a record level in 2007, heavy snowfall, much more abundant than normal were observed in vast areas of North America, continental Europe and China, according to the article, published on February 27. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) has estimated the potential savings from a nationwide 25% renewable electricity standard, a goal included in the Waxman-Markey energy bill that narrowly passed the House last year. Best-case scenario: about 306 million tons less CO2 by 2030. Given that the agency expects annual U.S. carbon emissions to be about 6.2 billion tons in 2030, that expected reduction will only equal about 4.9% of emissions nationwide. That's not much when you consider that the Obama administration wants to cut CO2 emissions 80% by 2050. | impossible expectations | 4.2.6 | CARDS |
The far-left ThinkProgress reports that scientists have finally proven that the theory of man-made Global Warming is a total hoax. | conspiracy theory | 5.3 | jintrain |
What this means, the report concludes, is that claims by NASA, NOAA, and the UK Met Office that the world is experiencing unprecedented and dramatic warming should be taken with a huge pinch of salt: they all use the same corrupted global average temperature (GAST) data. The conclusive findings of this research are that the three GAST data sets are not a valid representation of reality. | ad hominem | 5.1.3 | jindev |
No one has ever proven Climate Change. Scientific Consensus is a political term, not a scientific term. | slothful induction | 5.1.1 | hamburg_test3 |
The widespread snow cover is due to cold, not the imaginary warmth inside your computer model. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
The forecast is for global warming to be 1.7C from 1850-2100. We have already had 1.1C and the population has grown by 500%. Why would anyone think the next 0.6C is so special it will kill all human life? Pass this on, we need a grown up discussion on this. | slothful induction | 3.4 | hamburg_test3 |
Some experts have defended rising CO2 levels as a good thing for humanity. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | jintrain |
Observe the last interglacial 130,000 to 110,000 years ago. Temperature plummeted even as CO2 stayed at about 260 ppm. | single cause | 2.3.3 | CARDS |
Thus, 4.7 ln(390/388) = 0.043 Fahrenheit degrees less than a twentieth of a Fahrenheit degree of global warming every year. That is all. Putting it another way, it would take almost a quarter of a century with no carbon-emitting activity at all not a single train, plane, automobile, or fossil-fueled power station to forestall just 1 Fahrenheit degree of global warming. | impossible expectations | 4.2.3 | CARDS |
The intellectually corrupt and mendacious alarmist science establishment | ad hominem | 5.2 | jintrain |
They had to change it to the ambiguous "climate change" because temperatures weren't actually getting warmer. | misrepresentation | 1.8 | hamburg_test3 |
The result: our economic output would lag while other countries continued to expand their GDPs. | false choice | 4.2.6 | jindev |
As for those record temperatures brought in 2016 by an exceptionally strong El Nino | single cause | 2.1.3 | jindev |
One major conclusion that should be reached from the unpredicted wide ranging severe cold and snow this winter, is that multi-decadal global climate models have demonstrated no skill in predicting such regional events which clearly have a major impact on society and the environment. | impossible expectations | 5.1.4 | CARDS |
Thus, nitrogen fertilisers and carbon dioxide fertilisation have together increased global food production by 111 per cent. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | jindev |
Global warming alarmists frequently make false and deplorable assertions (see, for example, my recent column debunking false claims that global warming is causing a decline in wheat production). | ad hominem | 5.2 | jindev |
Increased amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere cannot be the cause of global warming, if global warming even exists. | slothful induction | 2.3 | CARDS |
Mismanagement and over fishing are the primary factors long before the claims of climate change. | single cause | 3.2 | hamburg_test3 |
Mount Isa was very cold, dropping below freezing for only the second time this year and registering its coldest morning in 10 years. It was a staggering 11 degrees below average, reaching minus one. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
Actually, according to a peer-reviewed paper just published in Nature Climate Change, there has been no statistically-significant global warming for the past 20 years . | cherry picking | 1.4 | CARDS |
No doubt climate change is here. No different than any other time it's changed during the history of this planet. From hot & arid to hot & humid with no polar ice caps to ice sheets covering most of the planet. All about cycle. Good luck stopping nature. | single cause | 2.1.4 | hamburg_test2 |
There is no reversing climate change. Climate change has always happened and will always happen regardless of human activity. | single cause | 2.1.4 | hamburg_test3 |
Mini ice age hits UK in January 2010.Must be global warming causing all this extreme cold weather.July 2022 UK heating up,in fact burning up must be global warming. | anecdote | 1.3 | hamburg_test3 |
It’s sad that the climate crisis crowd has been able to brain wash a big share of the planet with the term “Settled Science.” A fourth grader should no better than that! Ask Galileo about it! | slothful induction | 5.1.1 | hamburg_test1 |
Independent climate researcher Nick Lewis put out a study last year with Georgia Techs Dr. Judith Curry that found that the climates response to a doubling of atmospheric CO2 levels a measurement called climate sensitivity was 1.64 degrees Celsius. | cherry picking | 3.1 | CARDS |
There is no convincing evidence that carbon dioxide and other so-called greenhouse gases are causing a catastrophic heating of the Earths atmosphere and disruption of the Earths climate. | slothful induction | 2.3 | CARDS |
“But observations, such as those on our CO2 Coalition website, show that increased CO2 levels over the next century will cause modest and beneficial warming—perhaps as much as one degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit)” | cherry picking | 3 | Alhindi_train |
There's another reason why there will be more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. It involves two of the most swiftly developing nations in the world, China and India, both of whom are building coal-fired plants to generate electricity as fast as they can. This is happening while the Environmental Protection Agency has been engaged in an all-out war on coal that has closed several hundred U.S. plants. | impossible expectations | 4.2.6 | CARDS |
White House Supply Chain Advisor Is a World Economic Forum Climate Change Activist Who Worked at Hunter Biden's Think Tank. | ad hominem | 5.2 | hamburg_test3 |
10,000 years ago there was no manmade global warming. The years of fast sea level rise are shown on the charts.The sea level rise of the last few thousand years is well known, too.Our beliefs about sea level rise until now are the same. Your religion teaches acceleration, though. | false equivalence | 1.6 | hamburg_test3 |
In fact, the 50-ppm increase in atmospheric CO2 between 1981 and 2010 fertilized an 11% boost in plant cover worldwide. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | CARDS |
First up, a common misconception in the climate debate is that radiation from a cold body (e.g. the -18C atmosphere) can warm a hot body (e.g. the +15C Earth surface) just because the cold body does indeed send very-low-energy photons to the hot body. Heat transfer (not radiation) from cold to hot is forbidden by the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics on a macro basis, and by the Pauli Exclusion Principle of fundamental quantum theory on an atomic and molecular basis. | misrepresentation | 2.3 | CARDS |
The latest nail for the CO2-GHT coffin has been contributed by Dr. Charles R. Anderson with his article "The Most Essential Physics of the Earth's Temperature and Why Carbon Dioxide is No Threat to the Earth." This comes hard on the heels of a recent paper on "The phase relation between atmospheric carbon dioxide and global temperature" by Dr. Ole Humlum and coworkers. | false choice | 2.3.3 | CARDS |
You can't get accurate CO2 measurements from samples taken on the side of an active volcano that is outgassing CO2. | misrepresentation | 5.1 | CARDS |
You understand that Scientists know Climate change is a hoax. What do you think made Al Gore a multimillionaire? | conspiracy theory | 5.3 | hamburg_test3 |
Meanwhile, Chapman University has released a survey of the top ten issues Americans fear the most. Guess what ? Climate change didn't make the list. | cherry picking | 4.3.2 | jintrain |
There's still record levels of ice in the Antarctic. | cherry picking | 1.1.1 | hamburg_test3 |
Fact 2. Between 2001 and 2010 global average temperature decreased by 0.05 degrees, over the same time that atmospheric carbon dioxide levels increased by 5 per cent. Ergo, carbon dioxide emissions are not driving dangerous warming. | cherry picking | 2.3 | CARDS |
As suggested in the last comment this statistic is quite uncertain (1.5 – 3.3). Some climate models simulate less warming than some satellite datasets. The reason that the average of the CMIP5 models exhibits more warming than observations is in part due to natural variability and problems with the forcing (aerosols, solar changes, etc.) in the models. | cherry picking | 5.1.4 | Alhindi_test |
Then there's the issue of sea level change. Global warming and climate change are usually thought to mean that world sea levels will rise, perhaps disastrously. But according to US government scientific experts, in recent times (2010 and 2011, to be precise) phenomena driven by human carbon emissions have actually caused world sea levels to fall. According to a statement issued by the US National Science Foundation: For an 18-month period beginning in 2010, the oceans mysteriously dropped by about seven millimeters. | cherry picking | 1.6 | CARDS |
the glaciers of Geenland have shown substantial growth in the last 10 years | cherry picking | 1.1.2 | hamburg_test3 |
frost fairs were held on the Thames when the river froze | single cause | 2.1.4 | Alhindi_train |
On the same day the President was lying about warming, eight inches of snow fell in Rize, Turkey. It has fallen as well in South Africa, Norway, Sweden, Finland and Russia while closer to home snow fell on several cities in Idaho with cold freezes extending into Oregon. In June! | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
For the past century, greenhouse operators have been adding CO2 to the air inside greenhouses to enhance plant growth. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | CARDS |
Moreover, even if CO2 does drive climate change, slashing US greenhouse gas emissions would bring no benefits, since China, India and other developing nations will not be reducing their enormous emissions. | impossible expectations | 4.2.6 | CARDS |
More to the point, unilateral action will not mitigate climate change. The U.S. is only a small fraction of total emissions. Even if all of the Annex I countries of the Kyoto Protocol agreed to binding constraints, they would account for less than half of the world?s total emissions, and a far smaller fraction of the expected growth in emissions between now and 2100. To act unilaterally, or even in conjunction with the rest of the developed world, would mean paying the full measure of mitigating climate change while receiving only a fraction of its benefit. | impossible expectations | 4.2.6 | CARDS |
2010 is the hottest year ever, which explains why US winter temperatures have been dropping at a rate of more than 30 degrees per century since 1998. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |
I've got a plan to bring down Global Warming. We're already making progress, the Average daily temperature is 40 degrees lower since this summer. | anecdote | 1.3 | hamburg_test3 |
As the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere continues to rise, soybean plants will likely exhibit enhanced rates of photosynthesis, which will lead to greater synthesis of starch and other carbohydrates for supporting increased growth and development. In addition, if the atmospheric ozone level continues to rise, the rising CO2 content of the air will likely protect soybeans and other crops from the adverse effects of ozone that reduce productivity, growth, and yield. | oversimplification | 3.3.1 | CARDS |
I have had over 21 inches of snow at my house, here on the valley floor, at no elevation at all. For over a month now, every morning except one or two has been below freezing. And we all remember the arctic cold just before Christmas. | anecdote | 1.3 | CARDS |