id
stringlengths
33
34
title
stringlengths
6
218
authors
stringlengths
5
6.98k
categories
stringlengths
5
188
summary
stringlengths
34
3.26k
link_pdf
stringlengths
33
34
updated
timestamp[us]
published
timestamp[us]
embeddings
dict
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09216v1
Assessing Translation capabilities of Large Language Models involving English and Indian Languages
Vandan Mujadia, Ashok Urlana, Yash Bhaskar, Penumalla Aditya Pavani, Kukkapalli Shravya, Parameswari Krishnamurthy, Dipti Misra Sharma
cs.CL, cs.AI
Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in various NLP tasks. In this work, our aim is to explore the multilingual capabilities of large language models by using machine translation as a task involving English and 22 Indian languages. We first investigate the translation capabilities of raw large language models, followed by exploring the in-context learning capabilities of the same raw models. We fine-tune these large language models using parameter efficient fine-tuning methods such as LoRA and additionally with full fine-tuning. Through our study, we have identified the best performing large language model for the translation task involving LLMs, which is based on LLaMA. Our results demonstrate significant progress, with average BLEU scores of 13.42, 15.93, 12.13, 12.30, and 12.07, as well as CHRF scores of 43.98, 46.99, 42.55, 42.42, and 45.39, respectively, using 2-stage fine-tuned LLaMA-13b for English to Indian languages on IN22 (conversational), IN22 (general), flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets. Similarly, for Indian languages to English, we achieved average BLEU scores of 14.03, 16.65, 16.17, 15.35 and 12.55 along with chrF scores of 36.71, 40.44, 40.26, 39.51, and 36.20, respectively, using fine-tuned LLaMA-13b on IN22 (conversational), IN22 (general), flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets. Overall, our findings highlight the potential and strength of large language models for machine translation capabilities, including for languages that are currently underrepresented in LLMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09216v1
2023-11-15T18:58:19
2023-11-15T18:58:19
{ "title": [ -0.064453125, -0.0057144165, -0.039916992, -0.021408081, -0.019454956, -0.0038814545, -0.053710938, -0.0027427673, -0.023651123, 0.031311035, -0.0021953583, 0.0040512085, 0.0005722046, -0.032836914, -0.035858154, 0.0054397583, -0.004917145, 0.010673523, -0.019241333, -0.039154053, 0.019973755, -0.045013428, 0.028579712, -0.0013790131, 0.059448242, -0.049804688, -0.108947754, 0.023513794, -0.029388428, -0.018737793, -0.009735107, 0.029327393, 0.046203613, -0.00894928, 0.001914978, -0.0072669983, -0.03451538, 0.005203247, -0.026260376, 0.0073432922, 0.028045654, -0.018432617, 0.01889038, -0.007949829, -0.015274048, 0.034332275, -0.048614502, -0.031402588, -0.009780884, 0.024093628, 0.017150879, 0.00944519, 0.01411438, 0.018341064, 0.008666992, -0.01763916, -0.042510986, 0.023208618, 0.032287598, 0.04727173, 0.019378662, -0.014717102, 0.0023326874, -0.023117065, -0.026794434, -0.0020771027, -0.02394104, 0.0050849915, 0.08288574, 0.005332947, -0.0418396, 0.03074646, 0.016448975, -0.024597168, -0.025741577, 0.041412354, -0.00806427, 0.023406982, 0.051940918, -0.043640137, 0.0067253113, -0.007713318, 0.019042969, -0.0024719238, 0.008216858, -0.009674072, -0.011497498, -0.019378662, -0.043151855, -0.06225586, -0.013870239, -0.020645142, -0.046875, 0.008308411, -0.006958008, -0.04852295, -0.0124053955, 0.0440979, -0.00078105927, -0.030563354, -0.024353027, 0.030044556, -0.064575195, -0.020599365, 0.01651001, 0.007534027, -0.021087646, -0.0019569397, 0.02734375, 0.043548584, -0.02330017, 0.047180176, 0.013969421, 0.021652222, -0.008865356, -0.027191162, -0.021392822, 0.02670288, 0.0021953583, 0.041534424, -0.0021438599, -0.010467529, 0.0015029907, -0.0095825195, 0.0287323, -0.0010347366, -0.041992188, 0.017074585, 0.016708374, 0.027664185, 0.009803772, 0.028915405, -0.11810303, -0.089904785, -0.0597229, 0.030593872, -0.03164673, 0.008712769, -0.010353088, -0.0071105957, 0.015701294, -0.014656067, 0.030532837, 0.013473511, -0.000223279, -0.016204834, 0.059265137, 0.028549194, -0.047180176, -0.042755127, 0.014060974, 0.0070343018, 0.029022217, -0.017730713, -0.031799316, -0.02949524, -0.107299805, -0.011238098, 0.017837524, -0.0011386871, 0.0059814453, -0.0021419525, -0.007331848, -0.016159058, 0.010803223, 0.0012731552, 0.018600464, 0.01096344, 0.0064468384, 0.061187744, -0.01689148, 0.026229858, 0.03112793, 0.0132369995, -0.014854431, -0.014389038, -0.0209198, 0.011703491, 0.02444458, -0.011474609, 0.01725769, -0.028640747, -0.0093688965, 0.06341553, -0.039855957, -0.062805176, 0.006412506, -0.012458801, 0.058013916, 0.02204895, -0.035705566, 0.014892578, -0.03262329, -0.012809753, -0.044830322, -0.026306152, 0.033355713, 0.029556274, -0.006126404, 0.0057678223, -0.025375366, -0.0035877228, -0.026885986, 0.0015306473, -0.0020809174, -0.03753662, -0.0038795471, 0.012435913, -0.0051994324, 0.06088257, 0.0473938, 0.025421143, -0.04953003, 0.030471802, -0.010765076, -0.05569458, 0.0022907257, -0.018844604, 0.0036029816, -0.029541016, 0.016326904, 0.005138397, 0.027008057, 0.049346924, -0.031982422, 0.012107849, -0.007858276, 0.009613037, 0.020004272, 0.024719238, 0.08605957, -0.046875, 0.03765869, 0.015655518, -0.019821167, -0.01966858, -0.012939453, -0.030334473, 0.00944519, 0.016204834, -0.0004529953, -0.035339355, -0.00573349, 0.03164673, -0.021499634, -0.020050049, 0.024414062, 0.011161804, 0.03289795, 0.036315918, 0.049072266, -0.015052795, 0.038116455, -0.011138916, 0.005672455, 0.031555176, -0.02909851, -0.020126343, 0.0110321045, -0.011138916, 0.023544312, 0.013404846, 0.0032596588, 0.008155823, -0.0703125, -0.0013084412, -0.046722412, -0.012878418, 0.0024318695, -0.013183594, 0.036865234, -0.0016384125, 0.0137786865, -0.0129852295, -0.014518738, -0.0066871643, -0.0036907196, 0.016799927, 0.0262146, -0.04736328, -0.014984131, 0.031829834, 0.031829834, -0.013206482, -0.005367279, 0.026748657, 0.009529114, -0.042236328, 0.007007599, -0.011123657, 0.053131104, 0.0044403076, 0.0045166016, 0.015777588, -0.004322052, -0.022979736, 0.12512207, 0.060943604, -0.0345459, 0.030044556, -0.034118652, 0.009887695, 0.011230469, -0.028762817, 0.007331848, 0.0155181885, 0.022247314, 0.0067863464, -0.028564453, 0.017364502, -0.043273926, 0.017532349, 0.00623703, -0.025039673, -0.037353516, -0.04196167, 0.0015411377, -0.044281006, -0.04144287, -0.0048980713, 0.039001465, 0.007896423, -0.017822266, 0.009353638, 0.026779175, -0.018920898, -0.009391785, -0.0259552, 0.020751953, 0.006259918, 0.032806396, -0.0053138733, -0.08441162, -0.064575195, 0.005039215, 0.01689148, -0.020355225, -0.001578331, -0.035247803, 0.0143966675, -0.027160645, 0.011276245, 0.01953125, -0.064697266, 0.035339355, -0.053955078, 0.01852417, 0.006580353, 0.005935669, 0.022583008, -0.02003479, 0.0028648376, -0.000477314, 0.026260376, 0.060638428, -0.05166626, -0.044799805, 0.023208618, -0.010856628, -0.022506714, 0.014381409, 0.017028809, 0.0049476624, -0.017333984, -0.018295288, -0.044433594, -0.013336182, 0.0038967133, -0.0015974045, 0.023269653, -0.022506714, -0.01687622, -0.032043457, -0.0059509277, 0.024368286, -0.011779785, 0.018493652, -0.0104904175, -0.025360107, -0.0023651123, 0.017425537, 0.025054932, -0.020401001, 0.017501831, 0.06781006, 0.011184692, 0.020095825, 0.003227234, 0.05218506, -0.009689331, 0.016937256, 0.0007748604, 0.0048065186, -0.011131287, 0.010498047, 0.010864258, -0.024307251, -0.008842468, -0.060791016, 0.0027561188, 0.103393555, -0.035308838, -0.03564453, 0.034820557, -0.057403564, 0.031341553, 0.023132324, 0.015007019, 0.025497437, 0.030822754, -0.0014381409, -0.007896423, 0.00207901, -0.045135498, 0.009643555, -0.026992798, -0.11077881, 0.034698486, -0.031402588, -0.018814087, 0.005584717, -0.014053345, -0.030532837, 0.012458801, -0.0015459061, 0.085876465, 0.019058228, 0.0009236336, 0.050476074, -0.027374268, 0.012825012, -0.0064926147, -0.0141067505, -0.008506775, -0.012611389, 0.03253174, -0.017700195, 0.06304932, 0.00945282, -0.016433716, -0.031204224, -0.018707275, -0.039276123, 0.010688782, 0.003129959, -0.0446167, -0.019302368, -0.019622803, 0.009536743, 0.029785156, -0.012184143, 0.0087890625, -0.043426514, -0.002084732, -0.03704834, 0.0032653809, -0.0027618408, 0.022491455, -0.0028972626, -0.033996582, 0.021652222, -0.028503418, -0.04763794, 0.022521973, 0.036895752, 0.045410156, -0.017089844, 0.015991211, -0.03503418, 0.008979797, 0.028747559, -0.03744507, -0.013420105, -0.018859863, 0.008399963, -0.023071289, -0.016464233, -0.0035266876, 0.01473999, 0.0064811707, -0.020507812, 0.023727417, -0.004798889, -0.07824707, -0.0116119385, 0.0046043396, -0.105529785, -0.039855957, 0.008972168, -0.0037708282, -0.028335571, -0.025604248, 0.015068054, -0.02142334, -0.022766113, 0.017196655, -0.017303467, -0.03010559, -0.03616333, -0.0914917, -0.023712158, 0.07330322, 0.0055656433, 0.045959473, 0.05618286, -0.0068092346, -0.020004272, -0.015296936, 0.044555664, 0.03414917, 0.03050232, 0.008453369, -0.048034668, 0.01965332, -0.036010742, 0.011894226, 0.025650024, -0.040100098, 0.004501343, 0.02305603, 0.015159607, 0.022109985, 0.0005059242, 0.052459717, -0.0067367554, -0.003774643, -0.06298828, -0.0014915466, -0.033996582, -0.007987976, 0.014450073, -0.011833191, 0.021224976, 0.0017938614, 0.018737793, 0.06402588, -0.02468872, 0.026397705, 0.05218506, -0.024261475, -0.033416748, -0.033721924, 0.0022716522, 0.025527954, -0.0070114136, 0.027023315, -0.044799805, 0.03479004, 0.004798889, -0.0051193237, -0.0034255981, 0.0046157837, -0.070129395, -0.015068054, -0.04321289, -0.030212402, -0.018005371, 0.025894165, -0.026611328, 0.009918213, 0.052978516, -0.011199951, -0.036193848, 0.012863159, 0.052703857, -0.015213013, 0.009269714, -0.07055664, 0.016281128, -0.02067566, -0.07366943, -0.045654297, -0.013847351, -0.00088071823, 0.024856567, 0.0059165955, -0.029403687, 0.01979065, 0.01260376, 0.01687622, 0.029708862, 0.0034389496, -0.01576233, 0.042419434, -0.019515991, -0.0149383545, 0.017974854, -0.00075769424, -0.010063171, -0.016983032, 0.02859497, -0.019241333, -0.014556885, -0.019515991, 0.037109375, -0.019317627, 0.03894043, -0.022583008, 0.025939941, 0.018310547, 0.015029907, 0.008430481, 0.0011196136, -0.043884277, 0.014373779, 0.0065307617, 0.045288086, -0.013145447, -0.0028133392, 0.057800293, 0.030822754, 0.019866943, -0.002954483, -0.02607727, 0.017822266, 0.023345947, 0.020843506, -0.0057678223, -0.03173828, -0.03149414, -0.0005340576, -0.004333496, 0.030456543, -0.03729248, 0.04055786, -0.049926758, 0.011474609, -0.029281616, -0.0289917, 0.032287598, -0.045562744, 0.04928589, -0.03302002, -0.0345459, 0.02911377, 0.010032654, -0.023254395, 0.017425537, -0.0040779114, -0.0020771027, 0.010246277, 0.045684814, 0.0018625259, -0.022964478, -0.009902954, -0.038085938, -0.03994751, -0.025009155, -0.03930664, 0.0036525726, 0.0104904175, 0.017028809, -0.028244019, 0.0112838745, -0.051940918, -0.007156372, -0.045898438, -0.045715332, 0.06561279, -0.048187256, 0.024917603, 0.12261963, -0.024505615, 0.07977295, -0.0030212402, -0.00069475174, 0.02998352, 0.07122803, -0.014793396, 0.024993896, 0.040802002, -0.042816162, -0.004863739, 0.0059127808, 0.02406311, -0.0070495605, 0.053009033, 0.0016183853, 0.030532837, -0.06097412, -0.00017118454, 0.01626587, 0.006679535, 0.060180664, -0.081970215, 0.018951416, 0.0029888153, -0.025787354, 0.014511108, -0.04321289, -0.044189453, -0.011749268, -0.013343811, -0.050628662, -0.0026760101, -0.0061187744, -0.04144287, -0.0022830963, 0.036010742, -0.02003479, -0.008422852, 0.025314331, -0.016021729, -0.02709961, 0.036224365, 0.03152466, -0.038024902, 0.00289917, 0.0047836304, 0.003162384, 0.03753662, 0.037506104, -0.06768799, -0.01486969, -0.0029449463, -0.041870117, -0.028259277, 0.006866455, 0.010093689, -0.007282257, -0.023147583, -0.045959473, -0.020950317, 0.009605408, 0.026824951, -0.017120361, -0.032592773, 0.008857727, -0.01737976, -0.018569946, 0.006778717, 0.029373169, -0.009353638, 0.007873535, 0.009346008, -0.04486084, 0.04083252, -0.017456055, 0.0074005127, 0.0037212372, -0.043426514, 0.014762878, 0.013412476, -0.020706177, -0.007232666, 0.058532715, 0.030303955, 0.01789856, 0.003358841, 0.023208618, 0.04055786, -0.030822754, -0.021560669, -0.022109985, -0.00052547455, -0.013397217, 0.07055664, 0.00022232533, -0.0069770813, -0.038146973, -0.037200928, -0.03439331, 0.016067505, 0.03768921, 0.010375977, 0.051849365, 0.0070152283, 0.033233643, -0.044433594, -0.003156662, -0.044708252, 0.035217285, -0.018203735, -0.031234741, 0.01525116, -0.0060195923, -0.042236328, 0.015335083, 0.038238525, 0.06185913, -0.017578125, 0.05331421, -0.052856445, -0.028259277, -0.030380249, -0.049468994, 0.031799316, 0.013053894, -0.029327393, 0.033111572, -0.01991272, 0.0619812, 0.012329102, 0.0031013489, 0.026260376, 0.019348145, 0.0040664673, -0.00005310774, 0.028060913, -0.015594482, 0.0010948181, -0.041168213, -0.021530151, -0.06451416, -0.010726929, -0.06591797, 0.009063721, -0.0032444, 0.04244995, -0.0012264252, 0.015312195, -0.0038967133, -0.006462097, 0.026977539, 0.020233154, 0.06958008, -0.010292053, -0.0025959015, -0.008865356, -0.05419922, 0.036071777, 0.045837402, -0.014816284, 0.0051231384, -0.01965332, -0.026184082, 0.023239136, -0.019073486, 0.010673523, -0.026794434, -0.01600647, -0.03665161, 0.03314209, 0.005466461, 0.034698486, 0.045135498, 0.031555176, 0.015220642, -0.020706177, -0.0047073364, -0.01776123, -0.02331543, 0.022216797, 0.031799316, -0.07659912, 0.054016113, 0.008590698, -0.03378296, -0.042877197, 0.021697998, 0.009712219, -0.04547119, -0.030532837, 0.0132369995, 0.03527832, 0.028259277, 0.0027122498, -0.043762207, -0.03060913, 0.01486969, 0.03579712, -0.028244019, -0.0012359619, 0.0042915344, 0.030136108, 0.0011110306, -0.047851562, 0.033843994, -0.022567749, 0.026443481, 0.030563354, 0.010238647, -0.006313324, -0.009765625, -0.028305054, -0.02243042, 0.014190674, -0.031204224, -0.010826111, 0.0096588135, 0.025009155, -0.007827759, 0.047729492, 0.024780273, -0.020980835, -0.019317627, -0.025405884, 0.010879517, 0.034179688, -0.012680054, 0.034576416, -0.0597229, -0.05239868, 0.02848816, -0.059387207, 0.06213379, -0.05593872, 0.002029419, -0.050994873, 0.06890869, -0.011474609, -0.06439209, -0.04660034, -0.030136108, -0.05392456, 0.0005502701, -0.020614624, -0.0026626587, -0.006111145, -0.025131226, -0.00014674664, 0.010635376, 0.010917664, 0.014526367, -0.033172607, -0.07885742, 0.03161621, 0.0063552856, 0.055145264, -0.010910034, 0.009429932, 0.021331787, -0.017547607, -0.029815674, -0.031341553, -0.014251709, -0.032287598, -0.022140503, -0.031585693, 0.036956787, 0.028060913, -0.014434814, -0.060302734, -0.0054244995, -0.019226074, -0.039093018, -0.0018939972, 0.014152527, -0.04434204, -0.0077667236, 0.0060806274, -0.041503906, 0.027923584, 0.012130737, -0.02230835, 0.0418396, 0.016357422, -0.056488037, 0.0109939575, 0.015853882, 0.03878784, 0.001294136, -0.06137085, 0.016220093, -0.0024528503, 0.041229248, -0.039886475, -0.08343506, 0.01991272, 0.034332275, -0.019104004, 0.037384033, 0.017028809, 0.011703491, 0.024978638, 0.03527832, 0.0087509155, -0.044433594, 0.02217102, 0.020095825, 0.026931763, 0.061676025, 0.0041503906, 0.024307251, 0.017211914, -0.012420654, 0.015838623, 0.011672974, -0.014854431, 0.015296936, -0.0076560974, 0.024780273, -0.017227173, -0.014656067, -0.05053711, 0.01739502, -0.0023670197, 0.010612488, -0.023239136, 0.039794922, -0.02027893, 0.021087646, -0.059692383, -0.0541687, 0.07501221, 0.070129395, -0.005191803, 0.018920898, 0.010406494, 0.01737976, 0.014053345, 0.013000488, -0.006111145, 0.021133423, -0.0033283234, 0.0047035217, 0.0022411346, -0.0040779114, -0.028533936, -0.010002136, -0.025115967, 0.037506104, -0.025756836, 0.0016212463, -0.016403198, -0.025222778, 0.010551453, 0.022323608, 0.03062439, -0.01751709, -0.03878784, 0.012886047, 0.031921387, -0.021224976 ], "summary": [ -0.056732178, -0.03189087, -0.030654907, 0.0025863647, -0.0637207, -0.0024280548, -0.05718994, 0.025177002, 0.0023460388, 0.031982422, 0.018035889, 0.0082092285, -0.0006213188, -0.04321289, 0.000027298927, 0.0034370422, -0.023620605, 0.017608643, -0.027191162, -0.040527344, 0.019088745, -0.06329346, -0.041381836, -0.023468018, 0.030471802, -0.008491516, -0.0925293, 0.006965637, -0.011650085, 0.033599854, 0.018127441, 0.00680542, 0.04534912, -0.02519226, -0.0069732666, 0.01612854, -0.07147217, 0.010345459, -0.024108887, 0.010566711, 0.015380859, -0.0068092346, 0.0602417, 0.015975952, 0.013061523, -0.0010404587, -0.00598526, -0.07385254, 0.007083893, -0.0019483566, 0.012145996, 0.018661499, 0.007881165, 0.018920898, -0.016571045, -0.007888794, -0.026565552, 0.012458801, 0.01701355, 0.039611816, 0.00078964233, 0.011871338, -0.0026664734, -0.044067383, -0.014884949, 0.0069618225, -0.0075416565, 0.00048446655, 0.05355835, -0.0048332214, -0.01612854, 0.019958496, 0.036834717, -0.075805664, 0.004634857, 0.04321289, -0.033203125, 0.018356323, 0.05432129, -0.050842285, 0.05532837, 0.023468018, 0.018692017, -0.02230835, 0.043945312, 0.0050621033, 0.0066833496, -0.037506104, -0.011428833, -0.036590576, -0.0060768127, -0.052490234, -0.051757812, 0.054901123, 0.035614014, -0.06347656, -0.00472641, -0.016189575, -0.010498047, -0.008575439, 0.007820129, -0.009361267, 0.0018749237, 0.0051498413, 0.01322937, 0.017333984, -0.0075187683, -0.022766113, 0.027191162, 0.0075187683, -0.02746582, 0.019470215, 0.032196045, -0.0074691772, -0.0073623657, -0.026992798, -0.010856628, 0.059448242, 0.013153076, 0.043884277, -0.0068511963, -0.001996994, 0.007446289, 0.05001831, 0.01637268, 0.035980225, -0.0044174194, -0.00005352497, -0.04586792, 0.02822876, 0.03845215, 0.039093018, -0.10913086, -0.05206299, -0.09277344, 0.008285522, -0.0036201477, 0.03353882, 0.001162529, -0.035095215, 0.010643005, 0.016860962, 0.041290283, -0.012451172, -0.0027828217, -0.0021018982, 0.027862549, 0.03225708, -0.025283813, -0.03250122, 0.05178833, -0.022628784, 0.034210205, -0.040374756, -0.01777649, -0.07513428, -0.07336426, -0.0070495605, 0.053619385, -0.012802124, 0.022140503, -0.0068130493, 0.02394104, -0.0004043579, -0.027557373, -0.0020427704, -0.022476196, -0.030670166, 0.026245117, -0.0056037903, 0.005168915, 0.017959595, 0.068847656, 0.00090169907, -0.0126953125, -0.004245758, -0.03302002, 0.038970947, 0.033416748, -0.010223389, 0.02645874, -0.03100586, 0.053588867, 0.03186035, -0.012413025, -0.05606079, -0.0063285828, 0.024276733, 0.06225586, 0.02760315, -0.040252686, -0.05316162, 0.02670288, -0.007461548, -0.016983032, -0.04812622, 0.008659363, 0.011680603, -0.014526367, -0.02684021, 0.047180176, -0.009338379, -0.006286621, -0.041809082, -0.07922363, -0.014801025, -0.020080566, 0.021362305, 0.020324707, 0.026535034, 0.008239746, 0.024459839, -0.023986816, 0.009483337, -0.02041626, 0.0062828064, 0.0060577393, 0.01777649, 0.03062439, -0.000023126602, 0.058898926, 0.0013494492, 0.037750244, 0.057403564, -0.047790527, 0.01184845, -0.005016327, 0.034240723, 0.0027942657, 0.027114868, 0.042388916, -0.049194336, 0.012664795, 0.008010864, -0.016235352, 0.0037250519, 0.002380371, -0.06347656, 0.0035266876, 0.022445679, -0.007896423, -0.005695343, -0.029281616, 0.041992188, 0.015655518, 0.03857422, 0.023254395, 0.01663208, -0.0021648407, 0.030822754, 0.0118255615, -0.00806427, -0.0006132126, -0.058013916, -0.0062408447, 0.023101807, -0.016860962, -0.033966064, -0.0012216568, -0.015342712, 0.03086853, -0.002122879, -0.03729248, 0.017852783, -0.061035156, -0.03753662, -0.03111267, -0.0211792, -0.0017852783, -0.052612305, 0.037841797, 0.013046265, 0.016357422, -0.029556274, -0.026809692, -0.031677246, -0.013435364, 0.013336182, 0.056915283, -0.034423828, -0.009208679, 0.04574585, -0.02154541, -0.020248413, 0.0074768066, -0.009841919, -0.02078247, -0.028579712, 0.016326904, 0.042266846, 0.037078857, 0.03225708, 0.014823914, 0.033172607, 0.006565094, -0.003200531, 0.064575195, -0.02456665, 0.02053833, -0.031402588, 0.013534546, 0.04663086, -0.022338867, 0.0011138916, 0.0206604, 0.018096924, 0.03918457, 0.0016403198, 0.006591797, 0.013641357, -0.051696777, 0.0030498505, 0.027770996, 0.03488159, -0.042877197, -0.04034424, -0.022354126, 0.0015277863, -0.042785645, 0.002588272, 0.070373535, 0.034851074, -0.008148193, 0.04675293, 0.021453857, -0.042633057, 0.050842285, -0.032409668, 0.052581787, -0.01739502, -0.006175995, -0.011177063, -0.049041748, -0.026123047, 0.007083893, -0.016952515, 0.0028858185, 0.011291504, -0.0062561035, 0.014465332, 0.018829346, 0.013267517, 0.019042969, -0.020385742, -0.006942749, -0.03164673, 0.030975342, -0.017608643, 0.027572632, 0.04525757, -0.010520935, 0.015594482, 0.0036907196, 0.054138184, 0.03643799, -0.06750488, -0.04611206, 0.03161621, -0.048919678, -0.03164673, -0.022247314, 0.02027893, -0.015975952, -0.029174805, -0.028701782, -0.007698059, -0.013587952, 0.0345459, 0.019317627, -0.001581192, 0.020874023, 0.02293396, -0.051513672, -0.032592773, -0.005317688, -0.027938843, 0.1048584, 0.020080566, -0.040283203, 0.039276123, 0.03439331, 0.027832031, -0.0010929108, -0.004299164, 0.08312988, -0.00018489361, 0.022201538, 0.021942139, 0.04348755, -0.0048713684, 0.0030403137, -0.01991272, 0.013916016, -0.026855469, -0.017700195, 0.0262146, -0.03805542, -0.038482666, 0.009292603, -0.007522583, 0.08807373, -0.0011329651, 0.02571106, 0.010185242, -0.036376953, 0.07965088, 0.023010254, 0.034210205, 0.04244995, -0.0064964294, 0.019210815, -0.059448242, 0.008071899, -0.06915283, -0.02394104, 0.0017576218, -0.042053223, 0.0023441315, -0.024047852, 0.010154724, -0.001408577, 0.0128479, -0.010787964, 0.037841797, 0.011169434, 0.054718018, -0.030014038, -0.010017395, 0.017608643, -0.003545761, -0.027801514, 0.003353119, -0.019378662, 0.022277832, 0.007335663, 0.044708252, 0.0035533905, -0.0075149536, 0.033294678, -0.046722412, -0.018081665, -0.029174805, -0.07513428, -0.019119263, 0.0039043427, -0.045288086, -0.017532349, -0.036621094, 0.031036377, 0.034057617, -0.02999878, -0.00819397, -0.008117676, 0.013069153, -0.05105591, 0.019622803, -0.05596924, 0.021713257, 0.06945801, -0.020019531, -0.0021762848, -0.01638794, -0.015464783, 0.016860962, 0.04510498, 0.09283447, -0.066101074, 0.050964355, -0.021469116, -0.010902405, 0.09118652, -0.103271484, 0.0022907257, -0.030380249, -0.0059165955, -0.07385254, 0.05908203, -0.010391235, 0.051727295, -0.06616211, -0.061767578, 0.039978027, -0.07727051, -0.03692627, -0.012504578, 0.009124756, -0.028076172, -0.050476074, -0.009155273, 0.040985107, -0.011070251, 0.021270752, 0.022338867, 0.0143585205, -0.010475159, 0.028244019, -0.022979736, 0.032928467, -0.0262146, -0.05581665, -0.010757446, -0.026687622, 0.021560669, 0.03390503, 0.022521973, 0.019439697, 0.0040893555, 0.029754639, 0.0113220215, -0.014533997, 0.047546387, -0.0131073, -0.03656006, -0.007598877, -0.009231567, -0.015167236, 0.064086914, -0.022857666, 0.036621094, -0.00041151047, 0.018630981, 0.033111572, 0.035583496, -0.002128601, -0.016036987, 0.015357971, 0.005218506, 0.021224976, -0.018249512, -0.023544312, 0.023345947, 0.00699234, 0.014305115, 0.026687622, 0.018661499, 0.03677368, -0.033111572, 0.009056091, 0.04144287, -0.015350342, -0.005634308, 0.0053367615, -0.007129669, 0.030517578, -0.014640808, 0.015197754, -0.023956299, 0.029632568, -0.0059318542, 0.013626099, -0.028839111, -0.019226074, -0.041748047, -0.043640137, -0.02281189, -0.02822876, -0.026626587, 0.030258179, -0.0050735474, -0.014762878, 0.05456543, -0.03668213, -0.014122009, 0.0025177002, 0.019332886, 0.006565094, -0.024108887, -0.10394287, 0.024230957, -0.039215088, -0.032806396, -0.032104492, 0.025405884, -0.01626587, 0.014045715, -0.012496948, 0.01158905, 0.02458191, -0.0057792664, -0.014373779, 0.015449524, 0.005844116, -0.01701355, 0.02746582, -0.018676758, 0.010391235, -0.005970001, -0.008911133, -0.023498535, -0.000018239021, 0.013206482, 0.014656067, -0.00022053719, -0.04168701, 0.0028362274, 0.01701355, 0.007080078, -0.023361206, -0.0002720356, 0.011306763, -0.0006875992, 0.0046691895, -0.010192871, -0.012145996, 0.030410767, 0.01727295, 0.0045433044, 0.0067329407, 0.0019836426, 0.013328552, -0.006084442, -0.018112183, -0.011161804, 0.0050315857, -0.011779785, 0.023498535, 0.02835083, -0.0011749268, 0.028396606, -0.02394104, 0.023147583, 0.017822266, 0.0033798218, 0.024002075, -0.009460449, -0.010009766, 0.0018358231, -0.017120361, -0.032226562, -0.0016431808, -0.010818481, 0.002023697, -0.026275635, -0.033843994, 0.014122009, 0.014389038, 0.00630188, 0.013259888, 0.0073242188, -0.023803711, -0.004009247, -0.03161621, -0.04925537, -0.0013217926, 0.0054855347, -0.039855957, -0.030975342, 0.017807007, -0.0067367554, -0.028640747, -0.00031161308, 0.016189575, 0.02458191, -0.025421143, 0.01966858, -0.0042419434, -0.051574707, -0.037078857, 0.06304932, -0.037109375, -0.06689453, 0.039794922, -0.0128479, 0.027191162, 0.0027599335, -0.03643799, -0.0036201477, 0.0395813, -0.034820557, 0.01335907, 0.019805908, -0.04559326, -0.02268982, 0.0007147789, 0.024398804, 0.031982422, 0.016830444, 0.016830444, -0.0016078949, -0.013618469, -0.009086609, -0.027542114, -0.014656067, 0.018463135, -0.016021729, 0.039855957, 0.011749268, -0.026931763, -0.009689331, 0.011711121, -0.05117798, -0.018157959, -0.007019043, -0.025009155, -0.011451721, -0.016784668, -0.031311035, 0.040405273, 0.01828003, -0.026870728, 0.004901886, 0.041412354, -0.03665161, -0.0044174194, 0.023391724, -0.025924683, -0.01890564, -0.022979736, 0.0054130554, -0.0033397675, -0.042938232, 0.04864502, -0.064697266, -0.017410278, -0.014785767, -0.02468872, -0.013374329, 0.042633057, 0.035888672, -0.00006425381, 0.0006747246, -0.0015554428, -0.024124146, -0.010543823, 0.025756836, -0.047790527, -0.040527344, 0.01864624, -0.020370483, -0.024536133, -0.005744934, 0.009490967, -0.019927979, 0.0018196106, 0.0055732727, -0.0028820038, 0.048034668, -0.010902405, 0.015281677, -0.037139893, -0.01612854, 0.001789093, 0.03149414, -0.006362915, -0.01411438, 0.048706055, 0.01626587, -0.008163452, 0.017730713, 0.018478394, 0.023010254, -0.024047852, -0.016723633, -0.017837524, 0.026016235, -0.0121536255, 0.0021266937, -0.0042419434, -0.0028266907, -0.016235352, -0.046020508, 0.0031032562, 0.023406982, 0.045898438, 0.030258179, 0.06542969, 0.022277832, 0.045074463, 0.01676941, -0.035949707, -0.04345703, 0.044830322, -0.011047363, -0.07244873, 0.04434204, -0.025009155, -0.09020996, 0.061920166, 0.021224976, 0.058380127, -0.023025513, 0.09265137, 0.022125244, -0.03881836, -0.0041275024, -0.014717102, 0.007686615, 0.008575439, -0.027770996, 0.00016951561, 0.016555786, 0.044403076, -0.011062622, -0.02432251, -0.01423645, -0.015716553, -0.024291992, -0.0073394775, 0.010368347, -0.0140686035, 0.011329651, 0.000102996826, -0.062164307, -0.056610107, -0.055267334, -0.0060424805, 0.033172607, -0.038970947, 0.0138168335, -0.004840851, 0.017288208, -0.023468018, 0.014190674, -0.016357422, 0.033325195, 0.019897461, -0.00027918816, -0.011009216, 0.038726807, -0.05911255, -0.0051841736, 0.04159546, -0.014152527, 0.0075683594, -0.041015625, 0.011627197, 0.038391113, -0.025390625, -0.052215576, -0.038208008, 0.041107178, -0.056488037, 0.0031719208, 0.0041542053, 0.039978027, 0.033813477, -0.01033783, 0.06817627, -0.02734375, -0.0038700104, -0.018661499, -0.023269653, 0.023132324, 0.0004749298, -0.027877808, 0.0435791, 0.0022735596, -0.028015137, -0.01889038, -0.015716553, 0.032409668, -0.062316895, -0.031188965, 0.010520935, 0.018859863, -0.0022335052, -0.03930664, -0.038909912, -0.0066375732, -0.014877319, -0.006038666, 0.022445679, -0.0058021545, -0.05041504, 0.0062446594, 0.019958496, -0.013961792, 0.022964478, -0.0015993118, 0.033569336, 0.035980225, 0.011054993, 0.0046844482, 0.0062828064, -0.016204834, -0.016952515, 0.035369873, -0.042663574, 0.018112183, -0.016983032, 0.028625488, 0.045196533, 0.022827148, -0.047668457, 0.01424408, 0.06903076, -0.023788452, -0.008964539, 0.014160156, 0.020935059, -0.022750854, -0.048828125, -0.026672363, -0.026168823, -0.010658264, 0.051879883, -0.06756592, 0.009544373, -0.055633545, 0.07043457, -0.08111572, -0.015182495, -0.03741455, -0.018005371, -0.062042236, 0.017913818, 0.021392822, 0.008659363, 0.012619019, -0.02130127, -0.0132751465, 0.011695862, 0.0071144104, 0.048553467, -0.03149414, -0.016357422, -0.012077332, 0.036376953, 0.037597656, 0.012634277, -0.017166138, 0.06121826, -0.02330017, -0.013450623, -0.06915283, -0.008514404, -0.05038452, 0.0140686035, -0.019958496, 0.013298035, 0.027526855, -0.020935059, -0.10809326, -0.0038528442, -0.023422241, -0.048309326, -0.00047397614, 0.037261963, -0.012954712, -0.0039711, 0.0053138733, 0.000374794, 0.011146545, -0.031188965, 0.012870789, 0.030822754, 0.014541626, -0.017425537, 0.037261963, 0.05038452, 0.060913086, -0.002878189, -0.03048706, 0.022079468, -0.015731812, 0.030410767, -0.0115737915, -0.040649414, 0.006767273, 0.0032997131, -0.0040245056, -0.025787354, -0.02748108, -0.015731812, 0.05105591, 0.02911377, 0.017730713, -0.021148682, 0.054901123, 0.07476807, 0.05407715, 0.018295288, -0.029464722, 0.044555664, -0.01953125, -0.052703857, -0.013832092, 0.008888245, 0.008804321, -0.009063721, -0.009811401, -0.009963989, -0.04663086, -0.020629883, 0.013671875, 0.0058174133, -0.010009766, 0.011390686, -0.041778564, 0.012062073, -0.0069122314, -0.044555664, -0.035125732, -0.022781372, 0.046539307, 0.022644043, 0.018066406, -0.07159424, 0.057281494, 0.037139893, 0.01777649, 0.018066406, -0.008636475, 0.026138306, -0.014625549, 0.0042648315, -0.014533997, -0.016464233, 0.0022277832, -0.032318115, -0.035980225, 0.02961731, -0.011947632, -0.0077934265, -0.013893127, -0.009544373, 0.006198883, 0.037261963, 0.022140503, -0.016235352, 0.03793335, 0.03289795, 0.026306152, 0.01675415 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09214v1
Mind's Mirror: Distilling Self-Evaluation Capability and Comprehensive Thinking from Large Language Models
Weize Liu, Guocong Li, Kai Zhang, Bang Du, Qiyuan Chen, Xuming Hu, Hongxia Xu, Jintai Chen, Jian Wu
cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in the field of natural language processing. However, the sheer scale and computational demands of these models present formidable challenges when considering their practical deployment in resource-constrained contexts. While techniques such as chain-of-thought (CoT) distillation have displayed promise in distilling LLMs into small language models (SLMs), there is a risk that distilled SLMs may still carry over flawed reasoning or hallucinations inherited from their LLM counterparts. To address these issues, we propose a twofold methodology: First, we introduce a novel method for distilling the self-evaluation capability inherent in LLMs into SLMs, which aims to mitigate the adverse effects of erroneous reasoning and reduce hallucinations. Second, we advocate for a comprehensive distillation process that incorporates multiple distinct chain-of-thought and self-evaluation paradigms and ensures a more holistic and robust knowledge transfer into SLMs. Experiments on three NLP benchmarks demonstrate that our method significantly improves the performance of distilled SLMs and sheds light on the path towards developing smaller models closely aligned with human cognition.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09214v1
2023-11-15T18:56:23
2023-11-15T18:56:23
{ "title": [ -0.023345947, -0.021362305, -0.02482605, -0.03744507, -0.0045700073, -0.011581421, -0.01423645, -0.00409317, -0.0057792664, 0.026794434, 0.0065193176, -0.0062561035, -0.01876831, -0.030181885, -0.055877686, -0.002286911, -0.0066947937, 0.036132812, -0.019638062, -0.024154663, -0.021026611, -0.030975342, 0.027832031, 0.0096206665, 0.058502197, -0.07922363, -0.10949707, 0.033355713, -0.021148682, -0.00932312, -0.008773804, 0.017166138, 0.053253174, -0.0071907043, 0.01361084, -0.0054740906, -0.035064697, -0.0020389557, -0.016296387, 0.012931824, 0.01574707, -0.0030879974, -0.038116455, -0.003320694, -0.06958008, 0.022918701, -0.07525635, -0.014915466, 0.0012388229, 0.022964478, 0.017929077, 0.04449463, -0.009498596, 0.015838623, 0.012535095, -0.012626648, -0.031280518, 0.003692627, 0.028060913, 0.08581543, 0.027236938, -0.0335083, 0.0022716522, -0.047058105, -0.03781128, 0.001750946, -0.017852783, 0.023666382, 0.059295654, -0.012557983, -0.045562744, 0.010536194, 0.024749756, -0.0037117004, -0.050964355, 0.010559082, 0.04397583, 0.009170532, 0.046905518, -0.05911255, 0.004070282, 0.0034217834, -0.003074646, -0.0043792725, -0.008178711, -0.028259277, -0.02809143, -0.00932312, -0.019607544, -0.056274414, -0.007575989, -0.012573242, -0.011222839, 0.014823914, -0.01890564, -0.03656006, -0.0036468506, 0.021591187, -0.0070724487, -0.019943237, -0.014282227, 0.02017212, -0.04574585, -0.014503479, 0.003129959, 0.029190063, -0.05126953, -0.0044021606, 0.031921387, 0.051696777, -0.0041160583, -0.0034427643, 0.009521484, -0.016311646, 0.0032653809, 0.0076675415, -0.0056114197, 0.026428223, 0.019699097, 0.0385437, 0.0066490173, -0.02456665, 0.03817749, 0.042236328, 0.01939392, 0.032318115, -0.044433594, -0.020629883, 0.03390503, 0.012229919, -0.00365448, 0.0670166, -0.12963867, -0.12402344, -0.076660156, 0.045806885, -0.011016846, -0.014831543, -0.029266357, 0.014526367, 0.0090408325, 0.0012311935, 0.032684326, -0.027633667, -0.0025730133, 0.025604248, 0.053833008, -0.0149383545, -0.04510498, -0.046875, -0.02545166, 0.00032663345, 0.014656067, -0.010902405, -0.048339844, 0.0019340515, -0.15283203, 0.03060913, 0.017349243, 0.04827881, 0.006591797, 0.006790161, -0.0035858154, 0.00774765, 0.038635254, -0.004886627, -0.0070228577, 0.021530151, 0.01108551, 0.035461426, -0.022460938, 0.005783081, -0.0088272095, 0.008010864, -0.0032234192, 0.00868988, 0.025680542, 0.0041999817, 0.012664795, -0.011772156, -0.00048542023, -0.029281616, 0.013801575, 0.03100586, -0.03677368, -0.046661377, 0.004131317, 0.0017518997, 0.052368164, 0.015014648, -0.029388428, 0.011810303, -0.030761719, -0.050750732, -0.03567505, -0.017684937, 0.028625488, 0.02394104, -0.0018987656, 0.03173828, -0.0042304993, -0.00092458725, -0.027328491, -0.02331543, -0.08312988, 0.005344391, -0.04434204, 0.045043945, -0.00844574, 0.043884277, 0.045318604, 0.015602112, -0.045562744, 0.027389526, -0.03237915, -0.066711426, 0.027297974, -0.033355713, 0.0015563965, -0.033172607, 0.0070610046, 0.015434265, 0.003856659, 0.052825928, -0.0007777214, 0.02041626, -0.006626129, -0.014480591, 0.020126343, 0.044128418, 0.0340271, -0.042785645, 0.03387451, 0.021606445, -0.016113281, -0.03463745, -0.026031494, -0.035003662, 0.027328491, 0.022949219, -0.004310608, -0.02532959, 0.0025463104, 0.031921387, 0.040618896, -0.01965332, 0.0051574707, -0.000029146671, 0.039733887, 0.047943115, 0.03668213, 0.01940918, 0.049621582, 0.008911133, 0.0035591125, 0.053131104, -0.018188477, -0.01991272, -0.019348145, 0.017974854, 0.024673462, 0.024658203, -0.011001587, 0.02116394, -0.052947998, 0.004627228, -0.026977539, 0.015274048, 0.007865906, -0.0062942505, 0.02911377, 0.0101623535, 0.017532349, -0.016708374, -0.017471313, -0.019088745, -0.013801575, 0.032836914, 0.011482239, -0.05718994, 0.0027561188, 0.01007843, 0.03274536, -0.005138397, 0.018295288, 0.0013237, 0.008018494, -0.021087646, -0.010673523, -0.005882263, 0.050689697, 0.014175415, -0.011383057, 0.0209198, 0.020477295, -0.020568848, 0.08557129, 0.05883789, -0.015426636, 0.029022217, -0.021087646, 0.035217285, 0.017974854, -0.014923096, 0.014419556, 0.0044898987, 0.026031494, 0.024368286, -0.026870728, 0.010520935, -0.05230713, 0.010475159, 0.0060272217, -0.027328491, 0.000108003616, -0.028762817, 0.02609253, -0.026031494, -0.008079529, -0.018859863, 0.055541992, -0.01586914, -0.022583008, -0.007080078, 0.0009455681, -0.020233154, -0.01802063, -0.026245117, 0.0033683777, 0.0062179565, 0.03652954, -0.0012683868, -0.072143555, -0.074523926, 0.0018339157, 0.009208679, -0.009468079, -0.021072388, -0.028915405, 0.023956299, -0.002445221, -0.014732361, 0.038604736, -0.063964844, -0.0013141632, -0.050750732, 0.0033359528, 0.026351929, -0.013000488, -0.0090789795, 0.015701294, -0.009727478, -0.018234253, 0.04574585, 0.06524658, -0.035339355, -0.031433105, 0.075683594, 0.017089844, -0.002588272, 0.03567505, -0.0014104843, 0.003419876, -0.045715332, 0.0039901733, -0.03805542, -0.027923584, -0.027709961, -0.01852417, 0.048919678, -0.037628174, -0.00712204, -0.0814209, -0.02670288, -0.01927185, 0.016647339, 0.017700195, -0.029205322, -0.020446777, 0.014144897, -0.016296387, 0.021759033, -0.0390625, 0.03845215, 0.07635498, 0.007610321, -0.010520935, -0.0058174133, 0.03515625, 0.008911133, 0.0021038055, -0.029266357, -0.051940918, 0.009849548, 0.026519775, 0.01436615, -0.013908386, 0.0064582825, -0.11077881, -0.00907135, 0.05819702, -0.0033664703, -0.028518677, 0.026809692, -0.0791626, 0.026916504, -0.011276245, -0.0093307495, 0.028320312, 0.020187378, 0.002500534, 0.0093688965, 0.000910759, -0.03274536, 0.014808655, -0.03564453, -0.13269043, 0.03515625, -0.03869629, -0.020080566, 0.00023436546, -0.015594482, -0.041046143, 0.011947632, -0.018066406, 0.058654785, 0.0082473755, 0.028152466, 0.009559631, -0.059051514, -0.024017334, -0.0368042, -0.0043258667, 0.00020492077, -0.014518738, 0.030715942, -0.011070251, 0.024963379, 0.0158844, -0.02255249, -0.007659912, -0.01852417, -0.03555298, 0.017440796, -0.011657715, -0.033935547, -0.015113831, 0.009361267, -0.0011520386, 0.00051164627, -0.016952515, 0.0085372925, -0.037078857, 0.007724762, -0.026412964, -0.0035648346, 0.0018014908, 0.013198853, -0.027648926, -0.012214661, 0.029342651, -0.022094727, -0.05493164, 0.0053634644, 0.040222168, -0.0061149597, 0.04144287, -0.01725769, -0.015991211, 0.027297974, -0.017791748, -0.003211975, 0.008270264, 0.009353638, -0.014228821, 0.017684937, 0.00072193146, -0.007709503, -0.008415222, 0.015556335, -0.0093307495, 0.018554688, -0.029785156, -0.08123779, -0.025726318, -0.007843018, -0.1227417, -0.06573486, 0.0009794235, -0.0074768066, -0.016326904, -0.045715332, 0.028839111, -0.027236938, -0.03942871, -0.0013723373, -0.023971558, 0.007987976, 0.0036907196, -0.081726074, 0.01864624, 0.07720947, -0.018539429, 0.0038890839, 0.013336182, -0.009284973, -0.018432617, -0.029754639, 0.050048828, -0.01914978, 0.020767212, 0.0053901672, -0.014595032, 0.020431519, -0.018814087, 0.022750854, 0.03869629, -0.0096206665, 0.007106781, 0.01259613, 0.01979065, 0.04373169, -0.031951904, 0.035125732, 0.03024292, 0.0033245087, -0.09838867, 0.01826477, 0.010986328, -0.020614624, 0.027938843, -0.007385254, 0.0045166016, 0.027297974, -0.01739502, 0.044158936, -0.0037841797, 0.0049095154, 0.045166016, -0.013702393, -0.021087646, -0.004272461, 0.00605011, 0.013336182, 0.0009870529, 0.020050049, -0.017715454, 0.044708252, -0.029281616, -0.011665344, -0.0056991577, 0.009246826, -0.03765869, 0.019470215, -0.046844482, -0.0647583, -0.04360962, 0.0068473816, -0.008087158, 0.07159424, 0.06378174, -0.006500244, -0.004211426, -0.023376465, 0.062316895, 0.0035858154, -0.041900635, -0.10083008, 0.01322937, -0.02609253, -0.05203247, -0.04043579, 0.005897522, 0.0057640076, 0.028320312, 0.014099121, -0.029907227, -0.0018177032, 0.025115967, 0.066467285, 0.011268616, 0.007144928, -0.04046631, 0.018173218, -0.031188965, -0.0074882507, 0.016677856, 0.013885498, -0.0014352798, -0.026550293, 0.009765625, -0.030654907, -0.010757446, -0.032806396, 0.016281128, -0.005302429, 0.037597656, 0.012428284, 0.03515625, 0.028137207, 0.003232956, -0.00024580956, 0.0009584427, -0.037322998, 0.00009441376, 0.00003415346, 0.021408081, 0.00003629923, 0.0017223358, 0.045562744, 0.04171753, 0.0209198, 0.0049552917, -0.0007429123, 0.007926941, -0.000115931034, -0.004863739, 0.036956787, -0.02796936, -0.036010742, -0.003282547, 0.020706177, 0.039093018, -0.044647217, 0.046844482, -0.0018615723, 0.009033203, -0.0015745163, -0.036499023, 0.028320312, -0.019180298, 0.03302002, -0.056243896, -0.04321289, 0.004306793, 0.031555176, -0.029586792, 0.01637268, 0.016937256, 0.011161804, 0.026153564, 0.053375244, 0.023834229, -0.029785156, 0.039794922, -0.017028809, -0.02319336, 0.0053977966, -0.042297363, 0.003894806, 0.009521484, 0.023147583, -0.07312012, 0.030899048, -0.035827637, -0.014198303, -0.014533997, -0.026687622, 0.01663208, -0.062683105, 0.028182983, 0.0793457, -0.0099105835, 0.06640625, 0.027526855, 0.01399231, 0.0046157837, 0.053100586, -0.012329102, 0.028137207, 0.022583008, -0.07385254, -0.014945984, -0.008018494, 0.034057617, -0.006664276, 0.042266846, 0.013557434, 0.009902954, -0.06652832, 0.025421143, 0.013496399, -0.012428284, 0.029556274, -0.060333252, 0.022033691, -0.011940002, -0.009223938, 0.024642944, -0.03439331, -0.023468018, 0.0018835068, -0.013412476, -0.025848389, 0.0104522705, -0.0027770996, -0.042663574, -0.037841797, 0.01309967, 0.0075798035, 0.025665283, 0.0046195984, -0.0056037903, -0.030914307, 0.026519775, 0.033691406, -0.026657104, 0.0022792816, -0.03778076, -0.0109939575, 0.03527832, 0.05206299, -0.030090332, -0.0042152405, -0.0101623535, -0.041931152, -0.016159058, 0.010383606, -0.009300232, 0.005241394, -0.016799927, -0.02519226, -0.007171631, -0.018096924, 0.021850586, -0.01914978, -0.026245117, 0.0052719116, -0.01751709, -0.016845703, 0.026138306, 0.0027656555, -0.0046806335, 0.019378662, -0.004043579, -0.03186035, 0.014320374, 0.006500244, 0.02407837, -0.01737976, -0.05886841, -0.00047373772, 0.024932861, -0.0066375732, -0.0103302, 0.04714966, 0.02381897, 0.02949524, -0.015792847, 0.0064468384, 0.03189087, -0.018508911, -0.03543091, -0.0058174133, 0.0032539368, -0.0079193115, 0.06500244, 0.0061683655, -0.030532837, -0.027755737, -0.0713501, -0.029373169, 0.009376526, 0.017181396, 0.022979736, 0.01940918, 0.00052404404, 0.05215454, -0.02192688, -0.015594482, -0.03857422, 0.021774292, -0.026412964, -0.04711914, 0.035369873, 0.0012712479, 0.0006146431, -0.025543213, 0.021133423, 0.029510498, 0.00065660477, 0.01461792, -0.03439331, 0.0141067505, -0.029403687, -0.029464722, 0.041107178, 0.013687134, -0.020309448, 0.034942627, -0.005004883, 0.05847168, 0.019744873, 0.047332764, 0.041229248, 0.016357422, 0.009490967, -0.004180908, 0.025741577, -0.03253174, 0.029922485, -0.03527832, 0.013717651, -0.05429077, -0.011955261, -0.07067871, 0.023391724, 0.0022735596, 0.037750244, -0.0035324097, 0.017730713, 0.011642456, -0.024383545, 0.03189087, -0.0084991455, 0.07330322, -0.013771057, 0.007911682, -0.006996155, -0.048797607, 0.028335571, 0.055847168, -0.008522034, -0.006538391, -0.03741455, -0.008995056, 0.012542725, -0.0018157959, 0.0012454987, -0.023025513, -0.007282257, -0.026535034, 0.016235352, -0.016555786, 0.013786316, 0.0619812, 0.034606934, -0.020202637, -0.013473511, 0.0005955696, -0.01852417, -0.02420044, -0.0023937225, 0.045959473, -0.076538086, 0.018203735, -0.006504059, -0.02809143, -0.029724121, 0.05001831, 0.038970947, -0.030258179, -0.020751953, 0.013755798, 0.049926758, 0.022399902, 0.0064735413, -0.028778076, -0.014633179, 0.026870728, 0.030456543, -0.007598877, 0.029373169, 0.008743286, 0.05142212, -0.010505676, -0.0181427, -0.0039405823, -0.015464783, -0.029815674, 0.022003174, 0.02407837, 0.018814087, 0.008262634, -0.031982422, -0.005241394, 0.020874023, -0.06762695, -0.002840042, -0.004600525, 0.0501709, 0.049346924, 0.082092285, 0.024383545, -0.006160736, 0.006549835, -0.06072998, 0.028808594, 0.041137695, -0.015182495, 0.022842407, -0.049713135, -0.04940796, 0.014877319, -0.047302246, 0.06652832, -0.046661377, -0.018173218, -0.025726318, 0.043670654, 0.0284729, -0.025405884, -0.049438477, -0.00000756979, -0.032226562, -0.00409317, -0.019241333, -0.0050964355, -0.0063095093, 0.0039863586, 0.02848816, 0.043762207, 0.007598877, -0.013473511, -0.03149414, -0.058929443, 0.02482605, -0.005207062, 0.068603516, -0.0012865067, -0.0038795471, -0.008903503, 0.0072669983, 0.0025997162, -0.004623413, -0.044769287, 0.06347656, -0.016067505, -0.034179688, 0.02558899, 0.017807007, -0.007659912, -0.0143966675, -0.0236969, 0.008720398, -0.019577026, -0.008872986, 0.040924072, -0.041412354, -0.03060913, 0.0011062622, -0.05505371, 0.045288086, 0.022979736, -0.012634277, 0.03579712, -0.0035820007, -0.02078247, -0.023025513, 0.014251709, 0.020095825, -0.0029621124, -0.046905518, 0.020324707, 0.018539429, 0.032348633, -0.04748535, -0.036987305, 0.014862061, 0.015510559, 0.01838684, 0.03994751, 0.01348114, -0.0146865845, 0.004512787, -0.0043945312, 0.0042686462, -0.03274536, -0.0031700134, 0.0075645447, 0.049102783, 0.037353516, -0.002822876, 0.004470825, 0.017532349, -0.030258179, 0.0041389465, 0.0044670105, 0.0059280396, 0.025497437, -0.0026340485, 0.03894043, -0.032348633, -0.0018577576, -0.06149292, 0.0016098022, 0.005558014, 0.03756714, -0.033233643, 0.031341553, -0.010505676, 0.058380127, -0.044555664, -0.0395813, 0.053649902, 0.04586792, 0.02027893, 0.015151978, 0.006038666, 0.007972717, 0.013809204, -0.002696991, -0.004219055, 0.0028572083, -0.008331299, -0.011550903, -0.0069999695, -0.03894043, -0.04876709, -0.009017944, -0.024475098, 0.019180298, -0.03262329, 0.025466919, -0.020309448, -0.005554199, 0.0035743713, 0.015960693, 0.0049362183, -0.034210205, -0.04196167, 0.028060913, 0.032226562, -0.002632141 ], "summary": [ -0.009307861, -0.02381897, -0.020233154, -0.02897644, -0.052093506, -0.0011224747, -0.0836792, -0.009094238, 0.021499634, 0.018295288, -0.042938232, -0.014595032, 0.020950317, -0.026016235, 0.004512787, -0.037139893, -0.011924744, 0.026397705, -0.019897461, -0.026443481, 0.015823364, -0.037597656, -0.054260254, -0.007320404, 0.021087646, -0.048339844, -0.018981934, 0.017028809, 0.014701843, 0.03878784, 0.016174316, -0.03652954, 0.024902344, 0.0063438416, -0.0340271, 0.01626587, -0.04336548, 0.0061569214, -0.020080566, 0.017578125, 0.045410156, -0.005317688, 0.06488037, -0.0045776367, -0.01499176, 0.054382324, -0.016677856, -0.024520874, 0.026321411, -0.006729126, -0.00058460236, 0.019866943, -0.006542206, -0.013397217, -0.014823914, 0.01965332, -0.04660034, -0.007610321, -0.002412796, 0.0859375, 0.029647827, 0.0007557869, -0.013496399, -0.055877686, 0.007751465, 0.017730713, -0.03515625, -0.022766113, 0.0847168, 0.047821045, -0.022659302, 0.0031719208, 0.020248413, -0.066833496, 0.007499695, 0.03604126, 0.01625061, 0.00831604, -0.0007572174, -0.012878418, -0.038635254, 0.020812988, 0.0030002594, -0.050628662, 0.0041160583, -0.040100098, -0.021102905, 0.00008302927, 0.021377563, -0.044525146, 0.0010900497, 0.012390137, -0.023025513, 0.036865234, -0.016937256, -0.042144775, -0.0056037903, -0.03881836, -0.0022850037, -0.03463745, 0.050445557, -0.029525757, 0.0031414032, -0.0025367737, 0.047546387, 0.03591919, -0.06970215, -0.042785645, 0.074157715, 0.018478394, 0.004299164, 0.017608643, 0.04196167, -0.06463623, 0.037139893, 0.013420105, 0.01737976, 0.08459473, 0.03414917, 0.028640747, -0.03427124, -0.02671814, -0.0011978149, 0.078063965, -0.005897522, 0.01348114, 0.015640259, 0.021270752, -0.012481689, 0.02607727, -0.0020618439, 0.031555176, -0.04156494, -0.021942139, -0.053710938, -0.006126404, -0.007789612, -0.0023269653, -0.03503418, -0.023529053, 0.0579834, 0.019866943, -0.010414124, 0.011413574, -0.017501831, 0.055236816, 0.01838684, -0.03265381, -0.014831543, -0.01828003, -0.050750732, -0.01134491, 0.045318604, -0.045440674, -0.045166016, -0.08282471, -0.08929443, 0.0005841255, 0.054260254, -0.017333984, -0.0084991455, 0.019454956, 0.016540527, 0.02178955, 0.008140564, -0.032562256, 0.015731812, -0.004573822, 0.012954712, 0.0018167496, -0.033447266, 0.0048103333, -0.006877899, 0.00080394745, 0.0063705444, 0.0181427, -0.007331848, 0.028869629, 0.0044784546, -0.025009155, 0.0099105835, -0.032989502, 0.025177002, 0.013427734, -0.053649902, -0.031173706, -0.0030918121, 0.06439209, 0.06933594, 0.020187378, 0.002407074, -0.06427002, -0.019714355, -0.030197144, -0.029434204, -0.020462036, 0.034088135, 0.013832092, -0.0048828125, 0.023132324, 0.03491211, 0.032409668, -0.030136108, -0.07885742, -0.070251465, -0.026062012, -0.0066986084, 0.045959473, 0.022369385, 0.060424805, 0.02003479, 0.01927185, -0.037261963, 0.036895752, 0.014457703, -0.042907715, 0.03933716, -0.02798462, 0.015411377, -0.043304443, 0.050048828, 0.037139893, 0.0029678345, 0.087402344, -0.035888672, -0.0014982224, -0.009757996, 0.021270752, -0.014381409, 0.032196045, 0.0018177032, -0.030258179, 0.024627686, 0.033050537, -0.015258789, -0.013748169, 0.007911682, -0.06970215, 0.026367188, 0.04196167, -0.0012817383, 0.026031494, -0.028961182, 0.02696228, 0.024459839, -0.009086609, 0.0010604858, 0.019134521, 0.012786865, 0.038604736, 0.0011510849, 0.009490967, 0.015419006, 0.0075263977, 0.01486969, 0.038208008, -0.029373169, -0.042266846, 0.01259613, -0.015792847, 0.030166626, -0.028900146, -0.026473999, -0.01965332, 0.012535095, -0.07757568, -0.011772156, -0.03326416, 0.013847351, -0.034729004, 0.014511108, -0.062805176, 0.014709473, -0.049468994, -0.084228516, -0.011001587, 0.009155273, 0.045959473, -0.00022244453, -0.049102783, 0.0036697388, 0.013374329, -0.006248474, -0.011268616, 0.022094727, -0.0020484924, 0.010475159, 0.026535034, 0.008651733, 0.045684814, 0.04019165, 0.01675415, -0.0066833496, 0.014884949, 0.0002527237, 0.0023841858, 0.07397461, 0.036590576, -0.02406311, 0.013320923, 0.026977539, 0.039276123, -0.018112183, 0.0009946823, 0.03970337, -0.002401352, 0.048736572, 0.025924683, 0.020828247, 0.040100098, -0.06323242, 0.00067949295, 0.016952515, 0.04925537, -0.046691895, -0.018569946, -0.0064468384, 0.032684326, 0.023330688, 0.042999268, 0.09039307, -0.02659607, -0.020980835, 0.021484375, -0.014694214, -0.0284729, 0.045532227, -0.035369873, 0.05456543, 0.008300781, -0.006160736, -0.0045928955, -0.04257202, -0.015396118, -0.00011634827, -0.024871826, 0.0019512177, 0.017410278, -0.002029419, 0.05355835, 0.05166626, -0.017349243, 0.0006570816, -0.029510498, 0.0062789917, 0.01209259, 0.01838684, -0.00036907196, 0.0044441223, 0.020736694, -0.030914307, -0.016860962, -0.010787964, 0.053894043, 0.036254883, -0.03765869, -0.016052246, 0.045562744, -0.008705139, -0.020370483, 0.009437561, 0.02998352, -0.0093307495, -0.064086914, -0.012756348, -0.036834717, -0.029632568, -0.006298065, 0.008575439, 0.019439697, -0.007106781, 0.04498291, -0.051696777, -0.019454956, -0.011070251, 0.0036411285, 0.13476562, 0.025650024, -0.05291748, 0.081604004, 0.021865845, 0.050201416, -0.013504028, 0.048828125, 0.068359375, -0.011650085, -0.018371582, 0.017623901, 0.04269409, 0.037353516, 0.006729126, -0.040618896, -0.039276123, -0.013938904, 0.0032997131, 0.030456543, -0.041412354, -0.028808594, -0.016342163, -0.023986816, 0.07067871, -0.016418457, 0.007217407, 0.0062026978, -0.03289795, 0.052734375, -0.004737854, 0.01171875, 0.052856445, -0.07519531, 0.053894043, -0.04937744, 0.03845215, -0.06347656, -0.019851685, -0.03845215, -0.09362793, 0.007621765, -0.04269409, 0.022369385, 0.0035533905, -0.0066604614, 0.0016975403, 0.024429321, -0.033233643, 0.04449463, -0.04058838, 0.031188965, -0.030914307, 0.032806396, -0.013092041, 0.009033203, -0.008407593, -0.018112183, -0.03765869, 0.0044822693, -0.0029506683, 0.012107849, 0.0052604675, -0.03326416, -0.028411865, -0.031677246, -0.038024902, -0.01739502, 0.020050049, -0.04248047, -0.036834717, -0.020141602, 0.033813477, 0.04928589, -0.028640747, -0.00705719, 0.03186035, 0.03186035, -0.03945923, 0.0023021698, -0.03137207, 0.0043640137, 0.00013804436, -0.036499023, -0.007408142, 0.0009860992, -0.041809082, -0.048950195, 0.048706055, 0.009559631, -0.038146973, 0.022705078, 0.026016235, -0.031051636, 0.043548584, -0.030059814, -0.019058228, -0.008705139, -0.005332947, -0.046081543, 0.02456665, 0.016662598, 0.03149414, -0.043792725, -0.08337402, 0.050720215, -0.109069824, -0.06121826, -0.052734375, -0.002670288, -0.04031372, -0.047576904, -0.017120361, 0.0016126633, -0.027542114, -0.006477356, 0.036590576, -0.046081543, -0.021072388, 0.00504303, -0.026382446, 0.048034668, 0.026031494, -0.057006836, 0.059143066, 0.0022525787, -0.0057640076, 0.014183044, -0.019943237, 0.013061523, -0.015655518, -0.015380859, 0.003850937, -0.039611816, -0.00091362, -0.047058105, -0.008491516, -0.005558014, -0.0074806213, 0.004737854, 0.029724121, -0.055786133, 0.02709961, 0.025894165, 0.02432251, 0.06652832, -0.0029201508, 0.00541687, -0.022491455, 0.026641846, -0.05618286, 0.038146973, 0.0017547607, -0.013618469, 0.017593384, -0.0000030994415, -0.0059661865, 0.014472961, 0.00052309036, 0.009254456, -0.025512695, -0.0046157837, 0.007381439, -0.0047454834, -0.024749756, -0.023895264, 0.0060691833, 0.03213501, -0.023117065, 0.035858154, 0.0008869171, 0.040252686, -0.021636963, -0.009628296, 0.009017944, 0.02128601, 0.0016889572, -0.016159058, -0.03463745, -0.009162903, -0.020095825, 0.012992859, -0.0033340454, 0.055541992, 0.012016296, 0.024459839, -0.010192871, -0.014419556, 0.05090332, 0.028030396, -0.055511475, -0.09716797, -0.047332764, -0.017196655, -0.023635864, -0.014907837, -0.06329346, -0.00541687, -0.021438599, 0.027236938, -0.020202637, 0.021697998, -0.0012044907, 0.025146484, 0.019302368, -0.015716553, -0.040039062, -0.026855469, -0.018722534, 0.0368042, 0.0014619827, 0.042022705, -0.004184723, 0.0010643005, -0.03137207, -0.0017738342, -0.03302002, -0.054229736, -0.008605957, 0.020019531, -0.0030403137, 0.024749756, 0.013511658, 0.013572693, 0.034851074, -0.009429932, 0.0026397705, 0.0044784546, 0.0046691895, -0.041290283, -0.0044555664, 0.061523438, 0.0031337738, 0.028442383, -0.012214661, -0.005012512, -0.009536743, -0.0038280487, -0.0037670135, 0.006290436, 0.0076828003, -0.0035972595, 0.0109939575, 0.000028371811, 0.02243042, -0.000009059906, 0.017822266, 0.0060424805, -0.01725769, -0.03488159, 0.031799316, 0.018081665, -0.024353027, -0.0008378029, 0.010131836, -0.0020217896, -0.02268982, -0.0029335022, 0.009353638, 0.016601562, -0.020233154, -0.005241394, -0.035369873, -0.041900635, -0.0015535355, 0.009506226, -0.008758545, -0.040161133, 0.070007324, -0.024383545, -0.024841309, 0.024017334, -0.01687622, -0.040405273, -0.023956299, 0.00919342, -0.01448822, 0.033966064, 0.025375366, 0.002866745, -0.024154663, -0.009544373, 0.023803711, -0.028930664, -0.02078247, 0.039764404, -0.031463623, 0.018600464, 0.050079346, -0.03717041, -0.01777649, 0.036743164, -0.037353516, 0.017456055, 0.011238098, -0.078125, -0.021865845, -0.022033691, 0.022018433, -0.012466431, 0.030456543, 0.008964539, 0.016998291, -0.06542969, -0.01701355, -0.008583069, 0.024902344, 0.0062408447, -0.029373169, 0.0107803345, 0.022125244, 0.016784668, 0.003929138, 0.043518066, -0.0059318542, -0.006706238, 0.014755249, -0.033203125, -0.051239014, -0.024490356, -0.0096588135, 0.03845215, 0.0006504059, -0.03640747, 0.02178955, 0.05496216, -0.033935547, 0.02067566, -0.00047588348, 0.003540039, 0.004322052, 0.035980225, 0.015007019, -0.002073288, 0.011047363, 0.048553467, -0.01676941, -0.006385803, 0.003835678, -0.017028809, -0.044189453, 0.008705139, -0.02079773, 0.010414124, -0.033447266, 0.003955841, 0.0064964294, -0.036315918, 0.012260437, -0.011054993, -0.052093506, -0.023880005, -0.03353882, -0.015357971, 0.019836426, 0.0044288635, -0.0024089813, -0.004070282, 0.0024814606, -0.062164307, 0.030090332, 0.011413574, 0.011657715, -0.014297485, -0.048034668, 0.018173218, 0.017456055, 0.0022716522, -0.015342712, 0.028244019, 0.009223938, 0.054382324, -0.026229858, -0.014656067, 0.002752304, -0.00077342987, -0.006298065, -0.020431519, -0.0030059814, -0.032287598, 0.037109375, 0.028640747, 0.026382446, -0.0284729, -0.012268066, 0.006587982, -0.017028809, 0.0016126633, -0.017028809, 0.0012512207, 0.022857666, 0.032806396, 0.034606934, -0.019470215, -0.032928467, -0.009101868, -0.024505615, -0.031799316, 0.07849121, 0.031402588, -0.03213501, 0.010108948, -0.0006055832, 0.017166138, -0.014762878, 0.04135132, 0.02960205, -0.008613586, 0.006427765, -0.014511108, 0.052093506, -0.0011510849, 0.012313843, 0.017929077, 0.058929443, 0.020111084, -0.007926941, -0.021148682, -0.0018434525, -0.014564514, -0.019439697, -0.015853882, 0.01399231, -0.033081055, 0.06921387, -0.008766174, -0.022720337, -0.082458496, -0.05532837, -0.041503906, 0.06500244, -0.048828125, 0.0013904572, 0.0055351257, 0.009307861, -0.020507812, 0.00054597855, -0.03579712, 0.041778564, 0.02619934, -0.00945282, -0.0072021484, 0.017410278, -0.0076560974, -0.007369995, 0.036071777, -0.027069092, 0.04486084, 0.0005598068, 0.026245117, 0.022491455, -0.021484375, -0.029891968, -0.057495117, 0.046569824, -0.025863647, 0.0082473755, 0.03149414, 0.03829956, 0.013694763, -0.013946533, 0.010940552, -0.009086609, -0.008796692, 0.0050468445, -0.006580353, 0.009559631, -0.009162903, -0.019119263, 0.007232666, 0.0105896, -0.02507019, -0.004058838, -0.0016012192, 0.0574646, -0.031341553, -0.02319336, -0.011978149, 0.025299072, -0.0039405823, -0.011947632, -0.037261963, -0.019180298, 0.0040779114, 0.002866745, 0.00036263466, 0.023422241, 0.0107421875, 0.041625977, 0.043640137, -0.012245178, -0.0024929047, -0.042755127, -0.010055542, 0.021057129, 0.12109375, 0.030090332, 0.020385742, -0.01108551, 0.005645752, 0.044158936, -0.03704834, 0.033569336, -0.016494751, 0.030349731, 0.05722046, 0.044555664, -0.02204895, 0.009185791, 0.065979004, -0.027008057, -0.01953125, -0.010650635, 0.0104522705, -0.003484726, -0.030670166, 0.013313293, -0.016021729, -0.00029277802, 0.028167725, -0.07647705, 0.025360107, -0.034606934, 0.04928589, -0.049224854, -0.012550354, -0.037963867, -0.0074043274, -0.061553955, 0.016143799, -0.0184021, -0.034729004, -0.00016367435, -0.04675293, -0.033721924, -0.018692017, 0.00566864, 0.017364502, -0.023742676, -0.038269043, 0.042938232, 0.043640137, 0.07702637, 0.0206604, -0.018051147, 0.047912598, -0.010406494, 0.022109985, -0.059906006, -0.033203125, -0.008338928, 0.04638672, -0.020828247, 0.021224976, 0.041229248, 0.0015106201, -0.035858154, -0.036315918, 0.00086927414, -0.034362793, 0.035064697, 0.0390625, -0.023117065, -0.030471802, 0.012870789, -0.0395813, 0.028717041, -0.032348633, -0.017715454, 0.04888916, 0.00031924248, -0.0013628006, 0.013923645, 0.0073661804, -0.0058250427, -0.015090942, -0.062561035, -0.014335632, -0.015052795, 0.030395508, -0.023071289, -0.03744507, 0.03390503, 0.036865234, 0.012481689, -0.00009870529, -0.0025920868, -0.020462036, 0.008529663, 0.014892578, -0.0064468384, 0.0023593903, 0.024353027, 0.025115967, 0.045898438, -0.024002075, -0.026275635, 0.006259918, -0.013046265, -0.050567627, -0.019195557, -0.007987976, -0.009521484, -0.021575928, 0.0026855469, 0.0034008026, -0.015296936, -0.010726929, -0.035705566, -0.020202637, 0.019622803, 0.014968872, -0.023254395, 0.030426025, -0.022384644, 0.027740479, -0.04232788, -0.019515991, 0.0037441254, 0.008522034, -0.005794525, 0.001001358, 0.031097412, 0.012008667, 0.00712204, -0.006351471, 0.003921509, 0.016983032, 0.0054740906, -0.027938843, 0.012214661, -0.07824707, -0.014183044, -0.039794922, -0.020690918, -0.009971619, -0.013092041, 0.024932861, 0.02748108, -0.012718201, 0.028320312, 0.023376465, 0.002204895, 0.034973145, 0.008842468, 0.004524231, -0.019760132, 0.014656067 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09213v1
GRIM: GRaph-based Interactive narrative visualization for gaMes
Jorge Leandro, Sudha Rao, Michael Xu, Weijia Xu, Nebosja Jojic, Chris Brockett, Bill Dolan
cs.CL
Dialogue-based Role Playing Games (RPGs) require powerful storytelling. The narratives of these may take years to write and typically involve a large creative team. In this work, we demonstrate the potential of large generative text models to assist this process. \textbf{GRIM}, a prototype \textbf{GR}aph-based \textbf{I}nteractive narrative visualization system for ga\textbf{M}es, generates a rich narrative graph with branching storylines that match a high-level narrative description and constraints provided by the designer. Game designers can interactively edit the graph by automatically generating new sub-graphs that fit the edits within the original narrative and constraints. We illustrate the use of \textbf{GRIM} in conjunction with GPT-4, generating branching narratives for four well-known stories with different contextual constraints.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09213v1
2023-11-15T18:55:45
2023-11-15T18:55:45
{ "title": [ -0.018997192, -0.0129852295, -0.016784668, -0.036102295, -0.017303467, 0.000603199, -0.020355225, -0.021972656, -0.014404297, 0.022369385, 0.0006008148, 0.012413025, -0.04058838, -0.028640747, -0.0368042, -0.009010315, -0.0110321045, 0.014556885, -0.022445679, -0.043029785, -0.01235199, -0.058166504, 0.041992188, 0.04168701, 0.012962341, -0.011116028, -0.046569824, 0.017959595, -0.039001465, -0.034698486, -0.015205383, 0.012573242, 0.04598999, 0.0028476715, 0.00028133392, 0.038391113, -0.056518555, 0.015327454, 0.007637024, 0.00630188, -0.0005836487, -0.0059280396, -0.016952515, -0.043792725, -0.040985107, 0.029449463, -0.06933594, -0.006378174, -0.015403748, 0.062469482, 0.019561768, 0.021026611, 0.00023376942, 0.053619385, 0.014045715, -0.04776001, -0.018218994, -0.02619934, 0.03640747, 0.032928467, 0.03186035, -0.046203613, 0.02720642, 0.015594482, -0.030136108, -0.03668213, -0.026351929, 0.035308838, 0.05126953, 0.007446289, -0.0029640198, 0.022613525, -0.010437012, -0.029083252, -0.017745972, 0.059265137, 0.006580353, 0.013648987, 0.03967285, -0.026168823, -0.03161621, -0.015701294, -0.01285553, -0.03250122, 0.022460938, -0.013244629, -0.020004272, -0.020523071, -0.015991211, -0.059326172, 0.0025405884, 0.010940552, 0.00655365, -0.014579773, -0.04550171, -0.017074585, -0.044891357, 0.006286621, 0.003616333, -0.015159607, -0.011222839, 0.032562256, -0.059570312, -0.018005371, 0.013313293, 0.041259766, -0.019683838, 0.00630188, 0.015556335, 0.035217285, 0.0026016235, 0.024932861, 0.020446777, 0.027908325, 0.0012540817, -0.021362305, -0.013801575, 0.042144775, 0.001958847, 0.0423584, -0.012718201, -0.022750854, -0.018859863, 0.020996094, 0.03036499, -0.017730713, -0.039276123, 0.030975342, 0.0026168823, 0.036956787, 0.009803772, 0.029052734, -0.10021973, -0.06713867, -0.0579834, 0.04458618, -0.009315491, -0.011833191, -0.021636963, 0.012275696, -0.0000923872, -0.007144928, 0.04232788, -0.019546509, 0.049804688, 0.0006914139, 0.052764893, 0.01109314, -0.022338867, -0.019485474, 0.029541016, 0.014343262, 0.0024681091, 0.019104004, -0.0016956329, 0.008651733, -0.10369873, -0.0067634583, 0.03161621, 0.035095215, -0.004535675, 0.02381897, 0.031311035, 0.0038604736, 0.043182373, -0.019500732, -0.02810669, 0.019256592, 0.006828308, 0.0385437, -0.022247314, 0.02330017, 0.0020503998, -0.0022773743, -0.0027637482, -0.015411377, 0.021362305, -0.016036987, 0.020446777, 0.04559326, 0.03338623, -0.011245728, -0.019821167, 0.059417725, -0.053131104, 0.008590698, 0.003019333, -0.0031967163, 0.026672363, 0.007633209, -0.027709961, 0.058776855, -0.03152466, -0.03286743, -0.034301758, -0.026245117, 0.013313293, 0.011749268, 0.0036525726, 0.0049858093, -0.036590576, -0.018432617, -0.02796936, 0.018157959, -0.004337311, -0.048828125, 0.0019359589, 0.016601562, -0.014595032, 0.055847168, 0.054840088, 0.021057129, -0.056884766, 0.031219482, 0.0024604797, -0.062438965, 0.028793335, 0.008956909, 0.016464233, -0.014755249, 0.012901306, -0.004638672, 0.028411865, 0.06829834, 0.015930176, -0.028579712, 0.030136108, -0.04949951, 0.05154419, -0.008476257, 0.061035156, -0.027709961, 0.051513672, 0.046936035, -0.0019664764, -0.022125244, 0.021102905, -0.002960205, 0.002653122, 0.00907135, 0.0016355515, -0.029754639, -0.024810791, 0.015007019, 0.002960205, -0.04360962, 0.005268097, 0.018188477, 0.0077285767, 0.025268555, 0.040039062, 0.033996582, 0.035095215, 0.020141602, -0.013961792, 0.041809082, 0.0023860931, 0.035186768, -0.047973633, 0.024276733, -0.002811432, 0.047576904, 0.012123108, 0.019104004, -0.059783936, 0.0056381226, -0.04232788, -0.0001552105, 0.012176514, 0.0046539307, 0.026519775, -0.01701355, 0.013145447, -0.012649536, 0.01260376, -0.010322571, -0.03173828, 0.015777588, 0.03829956, -0.062042236, -0.020126343, -0.0006170273, 0.027679443, -0.0042266846, 0.044921875, -0.005306244, -0.0010232925, -0.0602417, -0.010749817, 0.00003582239, 0.03277588, 0.041534424, -0.011016846, 0.012619019, 0.0064888, -0.0054893494, 0.09173584, 0.04724121, 0.004547119, 0.008605957, -0.040130615, 0.028396606, -0.021652222, 0.01689148, -0.007751465, 0.030914307, 0.010925293, 0.0074043274, -0.036132812, -0.022064209, -0.0019607544, 0.0071754456, 0.014930725, -0.04824829, -0.029754639, -0.036346436, -0.003917694, -0.043426514, -0.0692749, -0.030090332, 0.070617676, -0.07867432, -0.048706055, -0.01083374, -0.049926758, 0.0012454987, -0.0027713776, -0.02848816, -0.05529785, 0.031173706, 0.028503418, 0.0074768066, -0.018936157, 0.015098572, -0.01625061, 0.017105103, -0.020828247, -0.015914917, -0.032226562, 0.012191772, -0.009185791, 0.011077881, 0.03286743, -0.04547119, 0.02470398, -0.046051025, 0.012245178, 0.014877319, -0.016418457, 0.019256592, -0.0015716553, -0.014503479, -0.0021533966, 0.0022449493, 0.0670166, 0.036346436, -0.024093628, 0.021514893, 0.06359863, -0.028030396, -0.023986816, 0.00005632639, -0.037322998, -0.018188477, 0.0078048706, -0.019424438, -0.0340271, 0.01777649, 0.029205322, 0.07318115, -0.024856567, -0.006164551, -0.03604126, -0.0038986206, 0.024719238, -0.02381897, 0.00038194656, -0.01725769, -0.015823364, -0.011856079, 0.0018138885, 0.013389587, -0.034057617, -0.023391724, 0.1282959, -0.0011205673, -0.021987915, 0.006134033, 0.049346924, 0.028518677, -0.006378174, -0.06124878, -0.0035095215, 0.0011577606, 0.015640259, -0.009674072, -0.0057373047, 0.0345459, -0.11218262, -0.0016145706, 0.008544922, 0.023483276, -0.010147095, 0.01991272, -0.08227539, 0.05065918, -0.039978027, -0.024505615, 0.034576416, 0.04486084, -0.0119018555, 0.027511597, -0.008735657, -0.0019350052, -0.014785767, -0.02078247, -0.08062744, 0.009590149, -0.025527954, -0.038085938, 0.0015707016, -0.020858765, -0.02897644, 0.015991211, 0.00042581558, 0.07434082, 0.013633728, -0.006134033, 0.03060913, -0.018203735, -0.0000885725, -0.0071029663, -0.014877319, -0.04232788, -0.018356323, -0.0077934265, -0.023025513, 0.049224854, 0.0037212372, 0.0059814453, -0.05441284, -0.0067710876, -0.017730713, 0.015159607, 0.008003235, -0.038208008, -0.0024929047, -0.015823364, -0.03753662, 0.027999878, -0.009048462, 0.0027103424, -0.056427002, 0.010917664, -0.023986816, 0.015068054, 0.017333984, 0.00091695786, -0.05822754, -0.0019454956, 0.014053345, -0.01335907, -0.026885986, -0.019821167, 0.02067566, 0.01083374, -0.00730896, -0.016616821, -0.040985107, 0.026901245, -0.02798462, 0.011795044, 0.036346436, -0.010009766, -0.0035991669, -0.0010900497, -0.012390137, -0.007881165, -0.017868042, 0.006038666, 0.045898438, -0.009544373, 0.05429077, -0.040405273, 0.00381279, 0.005302429, -0.12512207, -0.025772095, -0.00059843063, 0.006175995, -0.029830933, -0.0090789795, 0.013687134, 0.015335083, -0.012741089, 0.01576233, -0.012939453, -0.0072402954, -0.0135269165, -0.06915283, -0.0014734268, 0.07019043, -0.01914978, 0.027938843, 0.0869751, -0.020248413, -0.009719849, -0.012580872, 0.028915405, 0.07348633, 0.03225708, 0.018478394, 0.019256592, 0.03250122, -0.01977539, -0.005970001, 0.054992676, -0.026748657, 0.0031795502, 0.013801575, -0.0010690689, 0.0035037994, -0.016036987, 0.045684814, 0.02178955, -0.013679504, -0.05419922, 0.032073975, 0.014419556, 0.0069618225, 0.0068473816, -0.051605225, 0.019256592, 0.012763977, 0.03717041, 0.07067871, -0.0046958923, -0.027328491, 0.010368347, 0.0012130737, 0.0066604614, 0.016555786, 0.0127334595, 0.022506714, -0.0013751984, 0.006263733, -0.031082153, 0.043518066, -0.025161743, 0.009284973, -0.01576233, -0.014328003, -0.06311035, -0.017974854, -0.066223145, -0.021133423, -0.040771484, 0.037231445, -0.020462036, 0.012359619, 0.010238647, 0.007129669, -0.019592285, 0.007293701, 0.026626587, 0.0016851425, 0.008613586, -0.035858154, -0.017700195, 0.015388489, -0.06555176, -0.010955811, -0.020263672, -0.042266846, 0.02067566, -0.022155762, -0.038909912, 0.013420105, 0.029251099, 0.10900879, 0.066589355, 0.0057296753, -0.0736084, 0.06726074, 0.012374878, -0.015823364, 0.007247925, 0.022399902, 0.0022583008, -0.047302246, -0.049194336, -0.001783371, -0.017547607, -0.004890442, 0.030761719, -0.015113831, 0.042541504, -0.021209717, 0.033996582, 0.017959595, 0.013587952, 0.015914917, 0.011909485, -0.028884888, -0.01361084, 0.002954483, 0.043945312, -0.00084114075, 0.020477295, 0.005531311, 0.007789612, -0.010353088, -0.016738892, 0.014160156, -0.005012512, -0.0050086975, 0.0026874542, 0.03668213, -0.027893066, -0.039855957, 0.0031986237, 0.011207581, 0.029144287, -0.040252686, 0.04385376, -0.0018348694, 0.01449585, 0.0071983337, -0.02230835, 0.031036377, -0.028060913, 0.017044067, -0.060943604, -0.08929443, -0.020843506, 0.0680542, -0.035125732, -0.02154541, 0.0052490234, 0.03817749, 0.0015535355, 0.084350586, 0.051483154, 0.007801056, 0.026870728, -0.00047039986, 0.0009813309, -0.051940918, -0.03253174, 0.008255005, 0.0037841797, 0.00071811676, -0.07940674, 0.025863647, -0.037841797, -0.0155181885, -0.012992859, -0.015716553, 0.013671875, -0.06311035, 0.052581787, 0.10229492, 0.00039076805, 0.04623413, -0.03289795, 0.022964478, 0.03604126, 0.042114258, 0.022750854, -0.006755829, 0.018692017, -0.04711914, 0.03439331, 0.020263672, -0.0020771027, 0.014228821, 0.017669678, -0.0050354004, -0.01838684, 0.020233154, 0.022232056, 0.027923584, 0.0032405853, -0.00080251694, -0.042053223, 0.010864258, 0.02015686, 0.00023841858, 0.0047454834, 0.0030651093, -0.057006836, -0.04208374, 0.0021266937, -0.03866577, 0.007850647, -0.008911133, -0.039978027, -0.056884766, -0.002714157, 0.0013818741, 0.0023975372, -0.013694763, 0.023712158, -0.039886475, 0.0051078796, 0.07305908, 0.00006991625, 0.059936523, -0.047454834, -0.01777649, 0.07525635, 0.03753662, 0.0036029816, 0.004600525, 0.006462097, -0.042633057, -0.043426514, -0.007419586, -0.020339966, -0.001291275, -0.018875122, -0.076171875, -0.025405884, 0.032043457, 0.018249512, -0.0013656616, -0.018295288, 0.03262329, 0.007610321, -0.0004324913, 0.02154541, 0.010147095, -0.01890564, 0.011009216, 0.0087509155, 0.013633728, 0.04815674, -0.034332275, 0.0018348694, -0.0025730133, -0.04837036, 0.028839111, 0.01638794, 0.015167236, -0.032928467, -0.0020141602, 0.026290894, -0.03704834, -0.01436615, -0.017654419, 0.05206299, -0.042114258, 0.019683838, -0.012840271, 0.012237549, -0.045043945, 0.023956299, -0.0007662773, 0.02355957, -0.041381836, -0.064697266, -0.031402588, 0.005508423, 0.027801514, 0.014778137, -0.005367279, -0.023651123, 0.023910522, -0.029907227, -0.02508545, -0.070373535, 0.020050049, -0.014793396, -0.03378296, 0.051818848, 0.009056091, 0.0127334595, -0.017349243, 0.01852417, 0.008041382, 0.008003235, 0.0017232895, -0.026306152, 0.007865906, -0.023910522, -0.041900635, 0.022903442, 0.018737793, -0.04373169, 0.035064697, -0.00037646294, 0.061157227, 0.027740479, 0.048034668, 0.056396484, 0.037475586, 0.025558472, -0.0027065277, -0.0041770935, -0.036315918, 0.023956299, -0.057006836, 0.024108887, -0.038269043, -0.0056381226, -0.06390381, 0.023773193, 0.024108887, 0.018356323, 0.010848999, 0.00472641, 0.012763977, 0.017990112, 0.020858765, 0.015625, 0.046722412, 0.020462036, -0.0030441284, -0.008483887, 0.017410278, 0.028564453, 0.038330078, 0.015022278, 0.0011739731, -0.012207031, -0.022109985, -0.005630493, 0.02947998, 0.01751709, -0.00944519, -0.0063552856, -0.025466919, -0.01576233, -0.01399231, 0.009315491, 0.0440979, 0.046173096, 0.014282227, 0.0105896, 0.016052246, 0.0022411346, -0.05001831, 0.02960205, 0.0579834, -0.06341553, 0.023406982, -0.024719238, -0.025512695, -0.01701355, 0.0158844, 0.050994873, -0.070129395, -0.020324707, 0.029510498, 0.02909851, -0.026611328, 0.0025100708, -0.051574707, -0.033843994, -0.016738892, 0.028793335, -0.024780273, -0.012252808, 0.00970459, 0.0012950897, 0.002105713, -0.051971436, 0.008514404, 0.020248413, -0.008285522, 0.033233643, 0.01727295, 0.017791748, 0.026885986, -0.029190063, 0.031234741, 0.016525269, -0.019302368, -0.00014472008, 0.0016021729, 0.04348755, 0.04147339, 0.08203125, 0.03314209, -0.004924774, -0.014015198, -0.028320312, 0.015777588, 0.033966064, -0.024215698, 0.016464233, -0.032989502, -0.031280518, 0.03225708, -0.008880615, 0.042175293, -0.040618896, 0.0000025629997, -0.0037937164, -0.00046682358, 0.05532837, -0.05117798, -0.02355957, -0.0016422272, -0.026245117, 0.005672455, -0.015792847, -0.044281006, -0.020904541, 0.0057029724, 0.0007805824, 0.009506226, -0.020507812, -0.046813965, -0.0036563873, -0.053741455, 0.0040512085, -0.023849487, 0.040100098, -0.002878189, -0.0061531067, -0.002943039, 0.007873535, -0.01109314, -0.014831543, -0.027252197, 0.027908325, -0.024108887, -0.03753662, 0.006263733, 0.005672455, -0.027526855, -0.023132324, -0.047454834, 0.017288208, -0.02973938, 0.0044059753, 0.048309326, -0.038116455, -0.039916992, 0.00015187263, -0.0317688, 0.032165527, 0.0046806335, 0.0021743774, 0.029220581, 0.03152466, -0.048583984, -0.024917603, -0.01663208, 0.011383057, 0.020111084, -0.045684814, 0.01448822, 0.016067505, 0.026977539, -0.055725098, -0.050750732, 0.0022411346, 0.035949707, -0.020935059, 0.04071045, 0.01675415, -0.010070801, 0.010574341, 0.011428833, 0.00038194656, -0.026107788, -0.05529785, -0.07269287, 0.038970947, 0.031555176, 0.0054512024, -0.04916382, 0.037628174, 0.024124146, 0.008239746, 0.033172607, -0.013298035, 0.024276733, -0.0052757263, 0.044311523, -0.014656067, -0.009254456, -0.04296875, 0.01776123, -0.0028457642, 0.01637268, -0.031219482, 0.030273438, -0.016662598, 0.016571045, -0.015327454, -0.027236938, -0.0063095093, 0.035980225, -0.0053977966, 0.07556152, -0.04522705, -0.02319336, -0.0018558502, -0.019561768, -0.008407593, -0.033599854, 0.051757812, -0.05834961, -0.020355225, -0.023284912, -0.03555298, -0.02168274, -0.04083252, 0.02796936, -0.06304932, 0.0057258606, -0.040863037, -0.011405945, -0.00077438354, 0.035003662, 0.010147095, -0.015106201, -0.035369873, -0.0013122559, 0.04031372, -0.01789856 ], "summary": [ -0.00077819824, -0.029907227, 0.0015735626, -0.056365967, -0.06427002, 0.019454956, -0.07800293, 0.0044517517, -0.0066452026, 0.02722168, -0.0009608269, -0.007801056, 0.0019073486, -0.033721924, -0.006252289, -0.02709961, -0.008666992, -0.0011863708, -0.029052734, -0.036468506, 0.009010315, -0.037963867, -0.03640747, 0.053741455, 0.0007901192, 0.010177612, 0.040161133, 0.02029419, -0.0014791489, 0.017791748, 0.02432251, -0.046813965, 0.0046577454, -0.007080078, 0.02960205, 0.01977539, -0.02381897, 0.0118255615, 0.031158447, -0.019927979, 0.0046310425, 0.0020313263, 0.028533936, -0.027282715, -0.017044067, 0.013656616, -0.021377563, -0.036315918, 0.031219482, 0.06939697, 0.0010299683, 0.031082153, -0.02658081, 0.07952881, -0.012649536, -0.020904541, -0.024169922, -0.005584717, 0.02218628, 0.025634766, 0.008293152, -0.023925781, 0.0014209747, -0.016052246, -0.019836426, -0.0033092499, -0.025100708, -0.014129639, 0.031158447, 0.014038086, 0.020385742, -0.010009766, -0.005367279, -0.06951904, 0.021453857, 0.14282227, -0.059295654, 0.037750244, 0.030975342, -0.02116394, -0.0112838745, 0.023803711, 0.0008702278, -0.054748535, 0.00705719, -0.044006348, -0.0031795502, -0.0034217834, 0.022216797, -0.051208496, 0.0013256073, 0.039398193, -0.032104492, 0.010177612, -0.023773193, -0.055389404, -0.044067383, -0.08721924, 0.00052690506, -0.007896423, 0.055725098, -0.034332275, 0.050048828, 0.002193451, -0.009925842, 0.014945984, -0.021148682, 0.025161743, 0.02420044, 0.03390503, -0.002702713, -0.050598145, 0.031433105, 0.016281128, -0.0063972473, -0.013504028, -0.010612488, 0.052734375, -0.014923096, 0.052612305, -0.018829346, -0.021072388, 0.008483887, 0.023468018, 0.02003479, -0.0027809143, -0.030029297, 0.033111572, -0.01134491, 0.024642944, 0.03265381, 0.03845215, -0.072387695, -0.027359009, -0.066833496, -0.008644104, 0.011177063, -0.029556274, -0.0390625, 0.0015058517, 0.009635925, 0.005470276, 0.013221741, -0.027069092, 0.028411865, -0.0067749023, 0.013038635, 0.04815674, 0.013420105, -0.014503479, 0.027526855, 0.005252838, 0.009338379, 0.0024604797, 0.024047852, -0.036956787, -0.00983429, -0.028518677, 0.044921875, -0.015899658, -0.007888794, 0.0025558472, 0.020965576, 0.012863159, -0.004562378, -0.019760132, -0.0058021545, -0.004425049, 0.009681702, -0.041656494, 0.016555786, 0.04421997, 0.069885254, -0.029678345, -0.014053345, -0.032836914, -0.036743164, 0.0034503937, 0.012229919, 0.02255249, 0.024520874, -0.016403198, 0.0058135986, 0.023895264, -0.031555176, 0.05029297, -0.02204895, 0.038146973, 0.040863037, 0.0040512085, -0.052520752, 0.006877899, -0.009094238, -0.026611328, 0.0059509277, -0.03173828, 0.0043411255, -0.014183044, 0.008140564, -0.0017356873, 0.010978699, -0.04257202, 0.005508423, -0.038116455, -0.10656738, -0.03164673, -0.038085938, 0.047668457, 0.010749817, 0.025115967, 0.022537231, 0.016937256, -0.03591919, 0.012084961, -0.019348145, -0.027709961, 0.013427734, 0.053527832, 0.029434204, -0.006816864, 0.057556152, -0.021835327, 0.034606934, 0.04562378, 0.0118255615, -0.009712219, 0.008888245, -0.0009493828, 0.052764893, 0.003484726, 0.030731201, -0.03527832, 0.033325195, 0.066467285, 0.013427734, 0.005832672, 0.04257202, -0.057006836, 0.013069153, 0.0017776489, 0.037017822, -0.01763916, -0.06951904, -0.052459717, -0.066833496, -0.08917236, -0.009178162, -0.008262634, -0.0104522705, -0.005180359, 0.015037537, -0.0036792755, 0.02758789, 0.049468994, -0.029632568, 0.028686523, -0.0087890625, -0.004886627, -0.016159058, 0.01713562, -0.0060424805, 0.0357666, 0.024337769, 0.00868988, -0.031982422, -0.030410767, -0.036315918, -0.015022278, -0.008468628, -0.027328491, 0.04055786, -0.0012598038, 0.0061416626, -0.0569458, -0.00730896, -0.0011034012, -0.029907227, 0.027511597, 0.040161133, -0.04135132, -0.033569336, 0.0072288513, 0.020706177, -0.02671814, 0.01737976, 0.017196655, -0.001156807, -0.07910156, 0.008056641, 0.047546387, 0.044891357, 0.025161743, -0.010795593, 0.04611206, -0.010307312, 0.0069847107, 0.08294678, 0.003862381, 0.030227661, -0.031677246, 0.041748047, 0.03314209, -0.06854248, 0.04425049, -0.013534546, 0.04168701, -0.008560181, -0.009819031, 0.00080156326, -0.043914795, 0.056274414, 0.0413208, 0.02041626, -0.0022945404, 0.0013771057, -0.0015830994, -0.0023345947, 0.030303955, 0.0044403076, 0.04397583, 0.08300781, -0.08282471, -0.043670654, -0.014823914, -0.073913574, -0.004047394, 0.040283203, -0.023849487, -0.039764404, 0.001663208, -0.016296387, -0.022903442, 0.0061149597, 0.059661865, -0.0071487427, -0.0047798157, 0.009208679, -0.023605347, -0.017227173, -0.009536743, 0.01008606, -0.01777649, -0.0032691956, 0.0010900497, -0.024398804, -0.017990112, 0.0496521, -0.00969696, 0.04559326, 0.01524353, -0.0030517578, -0.0030727386, -0.005508423, 0.027618408, 0.033050537, 0.010604858, -0.0056877136, 0.020401001, 0.019714355, -0.039276123, -0.040924072, 0.02670288, -0.015144348, -0.0138168335, -0.021224976, -0.005924225, -0.05130005, 0.080322266, 0.03640747, 0.040924072, 0.023986816, 0.04324341, -0.039276123, -0.03012085, -0.032836914, -0.042114258, 0.0690918, 0.00166893, 0.014816284, 0.052978516, 0.034240723, 0.039916992, -0.014678955, 0.0046463013, 0.11102295, 0.0019254684, 0.010871887, 0.0031967163, 0.056549072, 0.017623901, 0.013046265, -0.0541687, 0.0017776489, -0.009796143, 0.013404846, -0.0025501251, -0.013153076, 0.023406982, -0.04736328, -0.014389038, 0.0053749084, -0.00007033348, 0.022979736, -0.013839722, -0.0385437, 0.087402344, -0.012710571, -0.00097322464, 0.049194336, -0.02041626, 0.02519226, 0.0423584, 0.019851685, -0.00497818, -0.053222656, -0.021606445, -0.035186768, -0.00036287308, -0.011116028, 0.019256592, 0.0027942657, 0.014480591, -0.03125, 0.00598526, 0.019546509, 0.05206299, -0.007461548, -0.011260986, 0.020263672, 0.012626648, 0.0012254715, -0.009246826, -0.011184692, -0.012062073, -0.00015115738, 0.048858643, -0.013671875, -0.009757996, -0.000813961, -0.030410767, -0.059570312, -0.018096924, -0.03213501, -0.004398346, 0.002374649, -0.019165039, -0.0058403015, -0.048736572, -0.047088623, -0.011352539, -0.027191162, 0.030654907, -0.044769287, 0.0317688, -0.015533447, 0.01071167, -0.027908325, 0.013832092, 0.030227661, 0.01398468, 0.028457642, -0.004295349, -0.020492554, 0.01876831, 0.032196045, -0.018035889, -0.013221741, -0.006427765, -0.019180298, -0.0028381348, -0.0049362183, 0.038269043, -0.017700195, -0.04940796, 0.024597168, -0.04827881, 0.010169983, 0.00642395, 0.0446167, -0.025939941, 0.039764404, 0.00067710876, 0.03994751, -0.04876709, -0.01398468, 0.009803772, -0.09423828, -0.061767578, -0.008026123, 0.0058288574, -0.05178833, 0.012962341, 0.010513306, 0.0064697266, -0.005470276, 0.016586304, -0.008132935, 0.06695557, 0.0017995834, -0.04043579, -0.013191223, -0.00044965744, -0.017913818, 0.0110321045, 0.043945312, -0.021270752, 0.052856445, 0.045715332, 0.022781372, 0.07116699, 0.06427002, 0.0256958, -0.004875183, 0.01914978, -0.0137786865, 0.018341064, 0.01083374, -0.013046265, 0.0030670166, 0.0071907043, 0.04058838, 0.0206604, -0.009414673, -0.0013990402, 0.019165039, 0.034606934, -0.039489746, 0.020645142, -0.017578125, 0.0078048706, 0.031982422, -0.014404297, -0.0060043335, -0.010795593, 0.033447266, 0.012374878, -0.016799927, -0.024963379, -0.035491943, -0.009536743, -0.011650085, 0.015777588, 0.026565552, 0.020767212, -0.019546509, 0.010604858, -0.030593872, 0.061920166, -0.04724121, 0.023605347, -0.004070282, -0.029556274, -0.08538818, -0.024780273, -0.022018433, 0.017837524, -0.06756592, 0.055725098, -0.010726929, -0.026611328, 0.020370483, 0.010437012, -0.010955811, -0.018035889, -0.006198883, 0.014923096, -0.007537842, -0.044952393, -0.029067993, -0.009986877, -0.03930664, 0.007835388, -0.07659912, -0.09472656, -0.008544922, -0.0045928955, -0.04244995, -0.0112838745, 0.009223938, 0.09527588, 0.062286377, 0.03869629, -0.08660889, 0.011505127, 0.0030574799, 0.00894928, -0.010597229, -0.0022411346, -0.026000977, -0.039154053, -0.04019165, 0.02067566, -0.015434265, -0.031707764, 0.021148682, -0.007762909, 0.051696777, -0.017654419, -0.0209198, 0.012207031, 0.059631348, -0.004623413, 0.013801575, 0.0079574585, -0.032440186, -0.03540039, 0.010772705, 0.07623291, -0.006996155, -0.02420044, 0.025222778, -0.03375244, -0.012588501, 0.033996582, -0.032592773, 0.023513794, -0.012290955, 0.060760498, 0.0072898865, -0.03262329, -0.001042366, -0.0023155212, -0.018432617, -0.019439697, 0.017303467, -0.018005371, 0.031173706, 0.00894928, -0.028869629, -0.018798828, -0.023712158, -0.010498047, 0.00068712234, -0.051849365, 0.026306152, 0.03173828, 0.004070282, 0.00022292137, -0.02508545, 0.025039673, -0.0051994324, 0.046447754, 0.023498535, -0.013801575, 0.021560669, -0.0020751953, 0.0035648346, -0.020126343, -0.017532349, -0.042144775, -0.022842407, 0.0079193115, -0.022445679, 0.045898438, 0.009216309, 0.013092041, -0.022644043, -0.033721924, 0.027145386, -0.048217773, -0.03326416, 0.045196533, -0.06274414, 0.0362854, -0.037994385, 0.00680542, -0.008781433, 0.037597656, -0.018630981, -0.037200928, 0.008338928, -0.0028743744, -0.0027637482, -0.016326904, -0.021697998, 0.07092285, 0.03125, 0.012832642, 0.027053833, 0.013999939, -0.01914978, -0.003818512, 0.025299072, 0.025436401, -0.035949707, 0.035461426, 0.00041890144, -0.02684021, 0.019439697, 0.050445557, -0.037353516, -0.04837036, 0.036712646, -0.020965576, -0.030593872, 0.0025520325, -0.026153564, 0.019073486, 0.007484436, -0.01272583, -0.007171631, 0.019119263, -0.0041770935, -0.0009460449, -0.02368164, 0.041107178, -0.013053894, 0.0574646, -0.009460449, -0.002521515, 0.033203125, 0.013191223, 0.00028467178, 0.00066185, -0.046142578, -0.028289795, -0.056640625, -0.014778137, -0.023712158, 0.059143066, -0.025527954, -0.042938232, -0.009483337, -0.0031986237, 0.0066337585, -0.009483337, -0.036010742, 0.013618469, -0.002248764, -0.0017595291, 0.0028209686, -0.01876831, -0.020843506, -0.006340027, -0.0059318542, 0.026535034, 0.032226562, -0.02053833, 0.064575195, -0.015838623, -0.0049324036, 0.008682251, 0.053588867, 0.04824829, -0.047546387, -0.005771637, -0.000014126301, -0.055664062, -0.017288208, -0.033416748, 0.03567505, -0.02798462, -0.004009247, -0.013580322, 0.0064468384, -0.06188965, -0.03970337, 0.061920166, 0.04611206, -0.007522583, -0.05706787, -0.011604309, -0.039733887, 0.027053833, 0.014221191, -0.006893158, 0.0107421875, 0.02053833, -0.006958008, -0.04119873, -0.053375244, 0.0071907043, -0.02923584, -0.052612305, 0.10217285, -0.013771057, -0.025497437, -0.0020561218, -0.019073486, 0.03289795, 0.031951904, 0.037231445, -0.017868042, -0.024520874, -0.038848877, -0.036499023, 0.048675537, 0.03353882, -0.019561768, 0.06652832, 0.03765869, 0.032836914, 0.020050049, 0.006828308, 0.028442383, 0.03253174, 0.017410278, 0.015258789, -0.012260437, -0.010238647, 0.015563965, -0.021759033, -0.0158844, -0.030380249, -0.013870239, -0.018981934, 0.059661865, -0.026687622, 0.014816284, 0.00041675568, 0.011276245, -0.02696228, 0.020401001, -0.009185791, 0.043029785, 0.033355713, 0.015579224, -0.0043411255, 0.005897522, -0.032043457, 0.01586914, 0.05105591, -0.00023400784, 0.004764557, -0.0065574646, 0.032440186, 0.02645874, -0.047424316, -0.017669678, -0.04788208, 0.030136108, -0.032928467, -0.063964844, -0.0072746277, 0.00025749207, 0.011856079, -0.019317627, 0.058776855, 0.0021972656, 0.00067949295, 0.030303955, 0.030914307, 0.00831604, 0.038879395, -0.012916565, 0.01008606, 0.01953125, -0.026535034, 0.002281189, 0.015464783, 0.052612305, -0.043914795, -0.007774353, 0.043701172, 0.0063552856, -0.037902832, 0.005619049, -0.049072266, -0.031173706, -0.013320923, -0.0012359619, -0.014556885, -0.005065918, 0.023330688, 0.0036830902, 0.048339844, -0.009857178, 0.016326904, 0.012893677, 0.03781128, 0.032562256, 0.03074646, -0.015022278, 0.016540527, -0.02116394, 0.025543213, 0.015075684, 0.036010742, 0.016998291, -0.01373291, 0.023025513, 0.055877686, 0.058410645, 0.00053453445, 0.03564453, 0.016586304, -0.026931763, 0.024642944, -0.023925781, 0.006023407, -0.021865845, -0.012870789, 0.02041626, -0.0121154785, 0.017990112, -0.0010356903, -0.025909424, 0.025543213, -0.01399231, -0.04006958, 0.019607544, -0.020767212, -0.012519836, -0.010643005, -0.012634277, 0.02885437, 0.0126571655, -0.06677246, 0.002565384, -0.00592041, -0.02923584, 0.00969696, 0.008636475, -0.019378662, 0.00030875206, 0.032470703, -0.014122009, 0.007865906, 0.040740967, 0.027374268, -0.014129639, 0.08050537, -0.011375427, 0.011428833, -0.03866577, -0.038024902, 0.013084412, 0.048034668, -0.0435791, 0.034301758, 0.021636963, -0.01411438, -0.05984497, 0.010017395, -0.010154724, -0.024505615, 0.08508301, 0.0025024414, -0.020446777, -0.02796936, 0.024307251, -0.023147583, 0.012489319, -0.026184082, 0.0135269165, 0.04257202, 0.04537964, -0.037872314, -0.010604858, -0.017669678, -0.028213501, 0.04864502, -0.005458832, 0.026245117, -0.031921387, 0.025222778, -0.03164673, -0.074645996, -0.048828125, -0.019699097, 0.019729614, -0.01386261, 0.011634827, 0.012954712, -0.01902771, -0.014778137, -0.01448822, -0.020858765, 0.00075626373, -0.034820557, 0.023498535, 0.0018758774, -0.013748169, -0.031921387, 0.015174866, 0.02583313, 0.0018348694, -0.0043792725, -0.0049591064, -0.0072746277, -0.001783371, 0.03656006, -0.013183594, 0.012145996, -0.032287598, -0.022521973, 0.010314941, 0.013008118, -0.04260254, 0.040008545, -0.024414062, 0.0021457672, -0.023620605, 0.02420044, -0.039123535, 0.010284424, -0.0033187866, 0.03829956, -0.01977539, 0.02305603, -0.0047950745, -0.00957489, -0.020370483, -0.013572693, 0.041290283, -0.057281494, -0.03253174, 0.020141602, -0.027038574, -0.08203125, -0.0362854, -0.020629883, -0.051086426, 0.024017334, 0.007297516, -0.011474609, 0.024124146, 0.0053367615, 0.005050659, -0.015945435, 0.01574707, 0.021820068, -0.023544312, 0.018295288 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09212v1
Controllable Text Summarization: Unraveling Challenges, Approaches, and Prospects -- A Survey
Ashok Urlana, Pruthwik Mishra, Tathagato Roy, Rahul Mishra
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
Generic text summarization approaches often fail to address the specific intent and needs of individual users. Recently, scholarly attention has turned to the development of summarization methods that are more closely tailored and controlled to align with specific objectives and user needs. While a growing corpus of research is devoted towards a more controllable summarization, there is no comprehensive survey available that thoroughly explores the diverse controllable aspects or attributes employed in this context, delves into the associated challenges, and investigates the existing solutions. In this survey, we formalize the Controllable Text Summarization (CTS) task, categorize controllable aspects according to their shared characteristics and objectives, and present a thorough examination of existing methods and datasets within each category. Moreover, based on our findings, we uncover limitations and research gaps, while also delving into potential solutions and future directions for CTS.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09212v1
2023-11-15T18:55:43
2023-11-15T18:55:43
{ "title": [ -0.014122009, 0.01108551, -0.0103302, -0.05795288, 0.002363205, 0.020263672, -0.038208008, -0.023254395, -0.003824234, 0.0657959, -0.0072364807, 0.037841797, 0.0029945374, 0.008926392, -0.060638428, 0.015510559, -0.01020813, 0.034118652, -0.02809143, -0.03375244, -0.0038452148, -0.05886841, 0.02381897, 0.025405884, -0.009605408, -0.029968262, -0.024765015, 0.0007138252, -0.04309082, -0.03744507, -0.019424438, 0.009117126, 0.04135132, 0.02583313, -0.011909485, 0.037139893, -0.047058105, 0.020645142, 0.0061149597, -0.0056648254, 0.008354187, 0.0065574646, -0.003522873, 0.011833191, -0.036712646, 0.0259552, -0.071899414, -0.033813477, -0.007160187, -0.003206253, 0.024871826, 0.037750244, 0.010475159, -0.01826477, 0.020507812, -0.009529114, 0.0021877289, 0.0067253113, 0.047973633, 0.0072250366, 0.0006108284, -0.038360596, 0.023712158, 0.0036506653, -0.018447876, -0.023452759, -0.0013990402, 0.023834229, 0.08520508, 0.010643005, -0.041107178, 0.024276733, 0.0027256012, 0.00011008978, -0.039245605, 0.010574341, 0.018569946, 0.00064086914, 0.04058838, -0.00806427, -0.036865234, -0.0011472702, -0.018920898, -0.04574585, 0.03540039, -0.025634766, -0.027648926, -0.010932922, -0.03781128, -0.06616211, -0.0047073364, 0.0005540848, -0.04321289, 0.006839752, -0.02709961, -0.02027893, -0.0006489754, 0.03729248, -0.026031494, -0.040405273, -0.013519287, 0.023376465, -0.030822754, -0.018417358, 0.019821167, 0.01423645, -0.031158447, 0.021942139, 0.04547119, 0.045135498, -0.021697998, 0.025756836, 0.010383606, 0.005077362, -0.016113281, -0.0033569336, -0.018188477, 0.015960693, 0.012245178, 0.0149002075, 0.00894165, -0.017303467, 0.0004003048, 0.035003662, -0.00340271, -0.010314941, -0.03491211, 0.0042495728, 0.032226562, 0.004383087, 0.011024475, 0.04067993, -0.10046387, -0.07635498, -0.04257202, 0.051727295, -0.017684937, 0.0066184998, -0.012825012, 0.0055999756, -0.0030288696, -0.019638062, 0.009567261, 0.0008945465, 0.0029468536, 0.0099105835, 0.061553955, -0.011672974, -0.045776367, -0.02684021, -0.057373047, 0.04144287, 0.05783081, -0.035186768, -0.09729004, -0.07421875, -0.13745117, -0.04067993, 0.03741455, -0.04159546, 0.016738892, 0.0028858185, -0.015167236, 0.006160736, 0.02798462, -0.010276794, -0.0009455681, 0.02494812, 0.013298035, 0.025253296, -0.020706177, 0.010734558, 0.04550171, -0.011054993, -0.020736694, 0.0039749146, 0.0055999756, -0.011497498, 0.035583496, -0.0064315796, 0.013221741, -0.016433716, 0.0016489029, 0.056854248, -0.0836792, -0.020126343, 0.00687027, 0.047607422, 0.052825928, 0.01789856, -0.042785645, -0.0017910004, -0.02507019, -0.040527344, -0.044281006, -0.019058228, 0.018966675, 0.028411865, -0.0048713684, -0.0043754578, -0.024673462, 0.0079422, -0.024124146, -0.007335663, -0.0014867783, -0.029876709, -0.008094788, 0.02281189, -0.053222656, 0.029006958, 0.080444336, 0.0019626617, -0.04055786, 0.03189087, 0.011238098, -0.067871094, 0.02859497, -0.0062026978, 0.0066947937, -0.04208374, 0.00699234, -0.004043579, 0.014083862, 0.030380249, 0.017562866, -0.017837524, 0.014625549, -0.022598267, 0.059661865, 0.014076233, 0.083740234, -0.02986145, 0.036743164, 0.0041160583, -0.01626587, -0.045806885, -0.024551392, -0.04144287, 0.017944336, 0.028045654, 0.0019254684, 0.011772156, -0.020401001, 0.0036125183, 0.05834961, -0.038604736, -0.0037879944, 0.018310547, 0.014198303, 0.010719299, 0.0491333, -0.0037117004, 0.045562744, 0.0074157715, 0.010665894, 0.04800415, 0.026641846, 0.0390625, -0.049591064, 0.022613525, -0.00440979, 0.01725769, 0.02684021, 0.0036754608, -0.030899048, 0.0052719116, 0.010627747, 0.039520264, 0.008132935, -0.009048462, 0.004096985, 0.02722168, 0.019042969, 0.002866745, 0.00038146973, -0.043884277, -0.005558014, 0.013427734, 0.010025024, -0.04534912, -0.01701355, 0.0039024353, 0.026931763, -0.0010032654, 0.027786255, -0.011787415, 0.012207031, -0.012077332, -0.0060806274, -0.019836426, 0.035217285, 0.033599854, 0.009414673, -0.012123108, 0.008842468, -0.0008568764, 0.12597656, 0.059936523, -0.011222839, 0.036315918, -0.013542175, 0.028945923, -0.0036315918, 0.004711151, 0.005847931, 0.027191162, 0.041748047, -0.008163452, -0.04272461, 0.020462036, -0.052337646, -0.007068634, -0.007949829, -0.02015686, -0.06365967, -0.072021484, -0.009933472, -0.065979004, -0.08532715, -0.04269409, 0.10119629, -0.038604736, -0.020843506, 0.009170532, -0.027557373, -0.029266357, 0.014961243, -0.03527832, 0.00040125847, 0.0059394836, 0.033172607, 0.014389038, -0.04449463, 0.018218994, 0.0028591156, 0.006504059, -0.034698486, 0.023025513, -0.029769897, 0.0026779175, -0.031143188, -0.014961243, 0.010749817, -0.056365967, 0.03439331, -0.0362854, 0.003282547, 0.026473999, -0.015686035, 0.006023407, -0.0051727295, -0.016952515, -0.01159668, 0.013801575, 0.048034668, -0.016235352, -0.013031006, 0.05050659, 0.032165527, 0.00031995773, 0.015487671, 0.014984131, -0.009681702, -0.059661865, -0.0021800995, -0.030776978, -0.041229248, -0.012420654, 0.007221222, 0.058746338, -0.023727417, -0.024993896, -0.032989502, 0.0037517548, 0.017852783, -0.013313293, -0.022750854, -0.043914795, 0.021820068, -0.018295288, -0.005584717, 0.012260437, -0.016586304, 0.021591187, 0.068603516, 0.00944519, -0.017822266, -0.008659363, 0.031188965, 0.019134521, -0.015930176, -0.041107178, -0.043701172, -0.0063705444, 0.014625549, 0.004211426, -0.010620117, -0.017211914, -0.07299805, -0.00013041496, 0.031982422, 0.012535095, -0.026870728, 0.03048706, -0.06149292, 0.027313232, -0.002609253, -0.02507019, 0.023239136, 0.03314209, 0.0066223145, 0.00982666, -0.0022697449, -0.0012359619, -0.0051994324, -0.03741455, -0.09295654, 0.009033203, -0.025894165, -0.019195557, 0.004764557, -0.06573486, -0.029403687, 0.0045700073, -0.013534546, 0.041656494, 0.032196045, 0.016967773, -0.005428314, -0.01423645, 0.013725281, -0.049346924, -0.0049819946, -0.023254395, -0.0129470825, 0.0014410019, -0.002275467, 0.03250122, 0.007434845, -0.005695343, -0.06298828, 0.015144348, 0.005771637, 0.033416748, 0.0043678284, -0.04006958, -0.00003170967, -0.04168701, -0.014709473, 0.03189087, -0.012382507, 0.004070282, -0.047454834, 0.006542206, -0.023803711, 0.017181396, 0.004447937, 0.012718201, -0.02696228, -0.02645874, 0.010299683, -0.03137207, -0.007850647, 0.00038790703, 0.03918457, -0.003118515, -0.013473511, -0.021224976, -0.05947876, 0.030761719, -0.025405884, 0.0069351196, 0.008865356, -0.0043678284, 0.023223877, 0.017105103, -0.03125, 0.006679535, -0.04046631, -0.006626129, -0.008216858, 0.0043296814, -0.0093688965, -0.07897949, -0.0019340515, -0.016830444, -0.10858154, -0.034454346, 0.014549255, -0.027694702, -0.033569336, -0.035369873, 0.02104187, -0.020233154, -0.024597168, 0.018218994, -0.010063171, 0.013343811, 0.0018501282, -0.06756592, -0.032928467, 0.08959961, 0.02180481, 0.02911377, 0.07501221, 0.0062217712, -0.012672424, -0.010017395, 0.031188965, 0.030838013, 0.042144775, 0.016494751, -0.011352539, 0.020965576, -0.018188477, -0.002626419, 0.038116455, 0.0090789795, -0.002588272, -0.0132751465, -0.0121154785, 0.030700684, -0.055480957, 0.053588867, 0.027618408, -0.02192688, -0.07946777, 0.047821045, -0.008018494, 0.009941101, 0.028121948, -0.015197754, 0.041870117, -0.004447937, -0.0013599396, 0.037261963, -0.008712769, -0.016326904, 0.04916382, -0.0071258545, -0.0059547424, 0.0016822815, 0.017288208, 0.02748108, 0.021881104, -0.016174316, -0.028381348, 0.02267456, -0.050476074, -0.003835678, -0.023971558, -0.015914917, -0.0024471283, 0.008956909, -0.05822754, -0.030914307, -0.050231934, 0.011566162, -0.004512787, 0.07977295, 0.025756836, 0.021347046, -0.039916992, 0.022232056, -0.0067367554, 0.0048446655, 0.018814087, -0.029129028, -0.016983032, 0.0036468506, -0.04876709, -0.025909424, -0.041229248, -0.0135269165, 0.01689148, 0.0009551048, 0.0070762634, 0.016311646, 0.028305054, 0.03753662, 0.04852295, -0.011657715, -0.024856567, 0.043182373, -0.021652222, 0.01423645, -0.0013256073, 0.03768921, -0.0009112358, 0.008094788, 0.012748718, -0.024002075, -0.02166748, -0.021392822, 0.015319824, -0.010238647, 0.046569824, 0.008544922, 0.0440979, 0.020507812, -0.0053253174, 0.02772522, 0.024917603, -0.014625549, -0.013252258, 0.029632568, 0.017196655, -0.013977051, -0.016662598, 0.024673462, 0.009506226, 0.027160645, 0.018249512, -0.014160156, 0.017166138, 0.028182983, 0.0049476624, 0.0027923584, -0.02796936, -0.023956299, 0.0031414032, 0.00712204, 0.048583984, -0.038391113, 0.052246094, 0.014831543, 0.021331787, 0.04043579, -0.0019016266, 0.03302002, -0.017028809, 0.01399231, -0.04284668, -0.047058105, 0.006958008, 0.027648926, -0.01322937, -0.0021362305, 0.001335144, 0.034606934, -0.002023697, 0.06286621, 0.024291992, 0.048065186, -0.02331543, -0.009208679, 0.00970459, -0.06088257, -0.023239136, 0.0011138916, 0.00049829483, 0.005264282, -0.05606079, -0.00036358833, -0.029556274, -0.03479004, -0.03375244, 0.008361816, -0.01247406, -0.055236816, 0.038848877, 0.06109619, 0.035064697, 0.023925781, -0.04815674, 0.037719727, -0.004146576, 0.06890869, -0.00944519, 0.030731201, 0.055603027, -0.041290283, 0.025466919, 0.007633209, 0.021026611, 0.021575928, 0.02835083, 0.011024475, 0.02696228, -0.05065918, 0.018341064, 0.038116455, 0.0026130676, -0.004863739, -0.043762207, 0.010375977, 0.007698059, -0.010787964, 0.004299164, -0.011062622, -0.02861023, 0.0008568764, -0.015853882, -0.03414917, 0.01184082, -0.010169983, -0.044158936, -0.027908325, 0.023254395, -0.008125305, -0.012649536, 0.024429321, 0.030014038, -0.008102417, 0.0011606216, 0.07055664, -0.030090332, 0.038970947, -0.005355835, 0.028503418, 0.07562256, 0.0018825531, -0.010879517, -0.011039734, 0.017791748, -0.037963867, -0.028808594, -0.00087833405, -0.022216797, -0.013244629, -0.015609741, -0.017044067, -0.017089844, -0.023925781, 0.018569946, -0.016326904, -0.033721924, 0.028778076, -0.006175995, 0.002073288, 0.010536194, 0.037506104, -0.0010871887, 0.001452446, 0.018569946, -0.04260254, -0.011444092, 0.03265381, 0.04534912, -0.042510986, -0.03869629, -0.021759033, 0.03363037, 0.0012731552, 0.03564453, 0.0052833557, 0.026626587, 0.05831909, 0.019607544, 0.021270752, 0.0725708, -0.028945923, -0.031051636, -0.042633057, 0.0032958984, -0.038604736, 0.060272217, -0.015991211, -0.020126343, -0.033081055, -0.023086548, -0.018539429, 0.038391113, 0.031311035, 0.002658844, 0.03640747, -0.0119018555, 0.039215088, -0.02758789, -0.03414917, -0.048431396, 0.059570312, 0.011756897, 0.0007686615, -0.0068359375, -0.04046631, -0.024627686, -0.022888184, 0.017944336, 0.013404846, 0.00031137466, 0.029037476, -0.0317688, 0.00078201294, -0.02532959, -0.04360962, 0.0357666, 0.014091492, -0.022521973, 0.076293945, -0.01953125, 0.054229736, 0.014320374, 0.06488037, 0.051879883, 0.011505127, -0.0021247864, 0.01826477, 0.021896362, -0.039215088, -0.010528564, -0.07849121, -0.019332886, -0.058807373, -0.0018072128, -0.040039062, -0.012306213, 0.012008667, 0.025726318, -0.002281189, 0.01638794, 0.017715454, -0.015602112, 0.037322998, -0.044311523, 0.04815674, -0.011932373, -0.0008659363, -0.021621704, -0.021957397, 0.03503418, 0.036254883, -0.00274086, 0.009552002, -0.058654785, -0.02394104, 0.00819397, 0.010520935, 0.013771057, -0.010749817, -0.01626587, -0.056121826, 0.007850647, -0.0071487427, 0.012535095, 0.0395813, 0.040649414, -0.011024475, 0.0009536743, 0.017608643, 0.0075416565, -0.013801575, -0.0064582825, 0.045532227, -0.06311035, 0.014480591, -0.005504608, -0.032806396, -0.023452759, 0.040924072, 0.03161621, -0.053131104, -0.020202637, 0.028381348, 0.03286743, -0.022705078, 0.027435303, -0.023498535, -0.006286621, 0.016113281, 0.026641846, -0.0018100739, 0.014060974, 0.027267456, 0.025878906, 0.017745972, -0.0073013306, 0.0058403015, 0.018600464, -0.014312744, 0.03164673, -0.006828308, 0.033966064, 0.003189087, -0.041931152, 0.022567749, 0.0023441315, -0.023223877, -0.020233154, 0.029647827, 0.029312134, 0.046295166, 0.076049805, 0.028015137, 0.003604889, -0.018508911, -0.04525757, 0.022003174, 0.0524292, -0.041625977, -0.023956299, -0.035186768, -0.033203125, -0.01448822, -0.0725708, -0.0022201538, -0.049072266, -0.0027427673, -0.029953003, 0.04525757, 0.0135269165, -0.048797607, -0.04824829, 0.01247406, -0.055603027, -0.009857178, 0.010818481, 0.012466431, -0.070251465, -0.037994385, 0.06726074, -0.032562256, -0.012016296, 0.010391235, -0.017486572, -0.06793213, -0.00062704086, -0.03050232, 0.03894043, -0.044403076, -0.00047636032, -0.009124756, 0.015716553, 0.011062622, -0.02998352, -0.03668213, 0.012641907, -0.014526367, -0.031036377, -0.008972168, -0.0055732727, -0.016738892, 0.012825012, -0.0541687, 0.02180481, -0.027572632, 0.023284912, 0.00030708313, -0.050445557, -0.034851074, -0.00071525574, -0.041137695, 0.02671814, 0.021347046, -0.015205383, 0.032928467, -0.0010480881, -0.022445679, -0.020812988, 0.0057678223, 0.035858154, 0.009178162, -0.024673462, -0.0056991577, 0.026947021, 0.056549072, -0.058776855, -0.05706787, -0.0004529953, 0.03189087, -0.029968262, 0.07086182, 0.01234436, 0.015640259, 0.007411957, 0.05758667, 0.0019931793, -0.057739258, -0.0034370422, -0.033935547, 0.025024414, 0.05670166, -0.0049057007, -0.009262085, 0.044189453, 0.0101623535, -0.015098572, -0.011711121, -0.013542175, -0.031433105, 0.012535095, 0.02268982, 0.01889038, -0.06561279, -0.07879639, 0.014152527, 0.012557983, 0.02255249, -0.016464233, 0.031707764, -0.024505615, 0.05368042, -0.039154053, -0.057159424, 0.029968262, 0.025665283, -0.007911682, 0.058258057, -0.013214111, 0.0064582825, -0.017425537, -0.0001218915, 0.006526947, -0.00090789795, 0.000582695, 0.013938904, 0.025268555, -0.05911255, -0.040283203, 0.009643555, -0.03277588, 0.044311523, -0.024505615, -0.005836487, 0.01411438, -0.031433105, -0.00009608269, 0.03137207, -0.0025405884, -0.02319336, -0.046325684, -0.030853271, 0.042663574, -0.014083862 ], "summary": [ 0.024917603, 0.00014281273, 0.016555786, -0.007926941, -0.029037476, 0.029434204, -0.0446167, -0.07006836, 0.03668213, 0.0625, -0.030075073, 0.047546387, 0.01928711, 0.0020618439, -0.041656494, 0.023010254, 0.004928589, -0.0015621185, -0.022277832, -0.036376953, 0.005859375, -0.049224854, 0.0082473755, 0.014801025, -0.004272461, -0.035125732, 0.009613037, 0.007621765, 0.015731812, 0.012390137, -0.00095796585, -0.022140503, 0.00015699863, 0.03668213, -0.004699707, 0.014282227, -0.008300781, 0.007865906, 0.016448975, 0.007167816, 0.029403687, 0.0015716553, 0.103393555, 0.02468872, 0.019302368, 0.008773804, 0.042114258, -0.043121338, 0.021087646, -0.06585693, -0.007347107, 0.016998291, 0.007129669, -0.06866455, -0.01966858, 0.0209198, 0.031921387, 0.023010254, 0.02671814, -0.050445557, -0.049987793, -0.019332886, 0.043762207, 0.012191772, 0.013038635, -0.00242424, 0.07128906, -0.00092840195, 0.018310547, 0.026489258, 0.019470215, 0.015342712, 0.018814087, -0.0546875, -0.0070762634, 0.02859497, -0.024917603, -0.020736694, 0.029815674, -0.016784668, -0.054534912, -0.00050115585, -0.011985779, -0.04800415, 0.010025024, 0.0053977966, -0.034851074, 0.0052452087, -0.013053894, -0.031188965, -0.013618469, -0.010276794, -0.06488037, 0.052703857, 0.012062073, -0.017211914, 0.04562378, 0.002122879, -0.015686035, -0.056793213, 0.013389587, -0.025161743, -0.022262573, 0.01109314, 0.017303467, 0.017425537, -0.0075531006, 0.06652832, 0.08288574, 0.03326416, 0.0054130554, 0.038604736, 0.01852417, -0.010139465, -0.024459839, -0.019989014, -0.018478394, 0.046661377, 0.0043525696, 0.027709961, 0.0047302246, 0.029449463, -0.018096924, 0.05999756, -0.0029563904, 0.035461426, 0.016403198, -0.030380249, 0.019042969, -0.0050811768, -0.025405884, 0.022354126, -0.01828003, -0.003396988, -0.006877899, -0.0024852753, 0.025360107, 0.0072784424, -0.01713562, -0.047210693, 0.027023315, 0.02609253, -0.009307861, -0.00415802, 0.0039863586, 0.010910034, 0.020111084, 0.008644104, -0.012886047, -0.0067634583, -0.018127441, 0.028839111, 0.082214355, -0.05050659, -0.12231445, -0.12854004, -0.0869751, -0.047088623, 0.035308838, -0.0847168, 0.04171753, -0.018447876, -0.044067383, 0.025161743, 0.013252258, 0.007095337, 0.036071777, 0.020767212, 0.0047416687, -0.019302368, -0.03933716, 0.0284729, 0.032073975, -0.027328491, -0.0046195984, 0.0028629303, -0.026931763, -0.021087646, 0.025100708, 0.02609253, 0.008285522, -0.030929565, -0.029403687, 0.044525146, -0.06555176, -0.004173279, 0.00390625, 0.072387695, 0.047424316, 0.014801025, -0.0000026226044, -0.050842285, -0.014251709, 0.006175995, -0.022506714, -0.02330017, -0.00806427, 0.009399414, -0.020629883, -0.007221222, 0.0435791, 0.0039138794, 0.0067634583, -0.041290283, -0.023101807, -0.02281189, -0.00274086, 0.02720642, -0.05065918, -0.0124435425, 0.052734375, -0.059143066, -0.02128601, 0.053375244, 0.016067505, -0.030929565, 0.043884277, -0.016235352, 0.008506775, -0.047332764, 0.042266846, 0.032714844, 0.0033397675, 0.07159424, -0.012901306, -0.02067566, 0.014457703, 0.014411926, 0.056121826, 0.0026874542, 0.07739258, -0.038360596, 0.037628174, 0.040405273, 0.007221222, -0.0073432922, 0.03289795, -0.04800415, 0.003786087, 0.014389038, 0.023971558, 0.037628174, -0.03439331, -0.024795532, 0.035186768, -0.058380127, -0.019577026, 0.0075950623, 0.0027179718, 0.0015602112, 0.041015625, -0.025421143, 0.03060913, -0.018096924, 0.004219055, 0.026306152, -0.02947998, -0.006061554, -0.039794922, 0.015525818, -0.011604309, -0.021621704, 0.02545166, -0.019485474, 0.033447266, -0.0071983337, 0.054718018, 0.06427002, 0.01864624, -0.039001465, -0.02406311, 0.010383606, 0.002105713, 0.021377563, 0.02154541, -0.032684326, -0.0057792664, -0.0025939941, 0.011169434, -0.019088745, -0.011131287, 0.007419586, -0.021026611, -0.014038086, 0.0054779053, -0.034057617, -0.0026550293, -0.009132385, 0.0032539368, 0.0037937164, 0.025558472, 0.040161133, -0.013328552, 0.018432617, -0.013671875, -0.004886627, 0.085998535, 0.003080368, 0.011245728, -0.0357666, 0.041168213, 0.03338623, -0.06506348, 0.031402588, 0.004623413, 0.028900146, 0.051116943, -0.016357422, -0.002861023, -0.016342163, -0.029571533, -0.04006958, 0.0011224747, 0.06652832, -0.068847656, -0.065979004, -0.022476196, 0.027664185, -0.03161621, 0.013313293, 0.10827637, -0.024765015, -0.011634827, 0.020324707, -0.024398804, -0.044647217, 0.051727295, -0.041107178, -0.018096924, -0.05166626, -0.017837524, -0.06829834, -0.040283203, 0.0390625, 0.012298584, -0.0025978088, -0.011749268, 0.05831909, 0.0057411194, -0.0030899048, -0.032714844, 0.010314941, 0.0014486313, -0.043670654, 0.018295288, 0.02128601, -0.014671326, 0.012687683, 0.034118652, 0.039642334, -0.05923462, -0.009017944, 0.007419586, 0.021621704, 0.033843994, -0.024612427, -0.018585205, 0.027709961, 0.015419006, -0.029174805, 0.027252197, 0.007904053, -0.004261017, -0.031143188, 0.0060157776, -0.013015747, -0.00459671, -0.025100708, 0.029891968, 0.035736084, -0.0038795471, 0.02558899, -0.050048828, 0.007873535, 0.01889038, -0.020889282, 0.029525757, -0.016464233, 0.043029785, 0.030899048, 0.014381409, 0.019042969, 0.016845703, 0.018417358, 0.029159546, 0.017364502, 0.039855957, 0.021469116, 0.027252197, -0.001335144, -0.017730713, -0.02961731, 0.0061836243, -0.032409668, -0.0110321045, 0.015945435, -0.006816864, -0.038909912, 0.020370483, -0.0309906, -0.008140564, 0.022567749, 0.015083313, -0.00957489, -0.020339966, 0.029556274, -0.013793945, -0.009757996, 0.020050049, 0.008651733, -0.00522995, -0.050598145, -0.017410278, -0.036254883, -0.006023407, -0.020202637, 0.019699097, -0.0017242432, -0.027709961, 0.011009216, 0.033111572, -0.03656006, -0.00041604042, 0.011444092, -0.012641907, 0.053466797, 0.005908966, 0.031021118, -0.020065308, 0.005382538, 0.015411377, -0.027618408, 0.011703491, -0.0018587112, -0.0075416565, 0.032104492, -0.02809143, -0.019744873, -0.013656616, -0.04034424, -0.05090332, 0.0309906, 0.024169922, 0.005794525, -0.00041770935, -0.011123657, 0.037139893, -0.044708252, 0.018371582, 0.07788086, 0.015197754, 0.0001449585, -0.014144897, 0.008300781, -0.051116943, -0.021255493, -0.01399231, 0.01890564, 0.078430176, -0.03945923, -0.022766113, -0.018157959, 0.008758545, 0.020019531, 0.022720337, 0.011665344, -0.059692383, -0.013122559, -0.06439209, 0.026687622, -0.0013799667, 0.016052246, -0.023269653, -0.021484375, 0.026611328, -0.025344849, 0.026672363, -0.016647339, 0.020248413, -0.03201294, -0.06500244, 0.036865234, 0.00187397, -0.08123779, -0.05480957, 0.017547607, -0.06726074, -0.05908203, 0.0064888, -0.009590149, -0.048553467, 0.0013523102, 0.027770996, -0.023712158, -0.002500534, 0.010223389, -0.014183044, 0.093566895, 0.006843567, -0.076660156, 0.020767212, 0.005130768, 0.02508545, 0.035247803, 0.0019102097, 0.034973145, 0.07019043, 0.0020389557, 0.004837036, 0.012779236, 0.03930664, -0.040649414, 0.012969971, -0.005340576, -0.00039744377, 0.03100586, 0.011428833, 0.017654419, 0.00920105, -0.01689148, -0.0028018951, 0.068847656, -0.05895996, 0.0052719116, 0.054718018, 0.009963989, -0.06060791, 0.08496094, -0.015037537, 0.006664276, 0.019119263, 0.026565552, -0.006389618, -0.024765015, 0.028213501, -0.02204895, -0.010429382, -0.03414917, 0.015609741, 0.0289917, -0.012573242, 0.026138306, 0.013252258, 0.052001953, 0.0033340454, -0.029327393, -0.04498291, -0.0072746277, -0.07116699, 0.00087451935, -0.015731812, -0.0016212463, -0.023071289, 0.0067710876, -0.012687683, -0.012382507, -0.08074951, 0.029388428, 0.0041999817, 0.051574707, 0.017196655, 0.05355835, -0.008934021, -0.02330017, -0.002521515, 0.01360321, 0.00060367584, -0.019119263, -0.053955078, 0.0070533752, -0.04660034, -0.017730713, -0.0736084, -0.052978516, -0.057495117, 0.02633667, 0.011299133, 0.022781372, 0.016952515, 0.026687622, 0.020751953, 0.01007843, -0.026138306, 0.027191162, -0.023956299, 0.050872803, -0.0014429092, 0.04425049, 0.030151367, 0.046081543, -0.0011062622, -0.027908325, -0.018997192, -0.03152466, -0.0121154785, 0.0041999817, 0.027709961, 0.029190063, 0.04800415, 0.004470825, -0.049804688, 0.00522995, 0.0031032562, -0.009231567, 0.034454346, 0.032714844, -0.04949951, -0.007194519, -0.028015137, -0.02015686, -0.018234253, 0.000518322, 0.027679443, -0.019134521, -0.008216858, 0.034088135, 0.042297363, -0.013977051, 0.037109375, -0.025466919, 0.0074272156, 0.0011787415, -0.0003414154, 0.0030059814, -0.014099121, 0.037719727, 0.01637268, 0.044281006, -0.0016107559, 0.013473511, 0.033813477, -0.0054512024, -0.026138306, -0.005996704, 0.009490967, -0.0011787415, -0.004634857, -0.0028514862, -0.02520752, -0.028579712, -0.023284912, 0.061523438, 0.035949707, 0.012466431, 0.009162903, -0.021728516, -0.019073486, -0.05706787, -0.022033691, -0.0034217834, -0.017974854, -0.02217102, -0.04248047, -0.032806396, 0.051574707, -0.047576904, -0.024093628, 0.032409668, -0.0052719116, -0.008934021, 0.0009036064, 0.035217285, -0.006713867, 0.013420105, -0.043518066, 0.007545471, -0.020523071, 0.043060303, -0.03024292, -0.014129639, 0.019866943, -0.030151367, -0.046539307, -0.03277588, 0.006801605, 0.044067383, 0.016708374, 0.027145386, 0.014724731, -0.026641846, -0.0070495605, 0.036834717, 0.025741577, -0.032318115, -0.0019874573, 0.05606079, 0.00774765, -0.028869629, 0.009361267, 0.0040359497, -0.0066719055, 0.016830444, -0.0022583008, -0.0077667236, 0.004119873, -0.004436493, -0.04638672, 0.024215698, 0.034606934, 0.008575439, 0.00096940994, 0.013046265, 0.027008057, 0.017486572, -0.04156494, 0.042541504, 0.005607605, 0.050079346, 0.010620117, 0.019561768, 0.040252686, -0.011314392, 0.0052604675, -0.0052833557, -0.0013694763, 0.0115737915, 0.024017334, -0.04824829, -0.03805542, 0.04449463, -0.004322052, 0.02355957, -0.022018433, -0.037384033, 0.01612854, -0.037506104, -0.046081543, 0.038391113, 0.013916016, 0.011436462, 0.021072388, 0.006362915, -0.056396484, 0.016464233, 0.043792725, -0.0067214966, -0.036743164, 0.034332275, 0.03274536, -0.09472656, -0.013458252, -0.034240723, 0.04135132, 0.015609741, 0.051208496, 0.0067443848, 0.0048217773, 0.06121826, 0.018341064, 0.020523071, 0.034606934, -0.005996704, -0.017974854, -0.03237915, 0.004875183, -0.04147339, 0.018188477, -0.0017280579, -0.011665344, -0.013137817, 0.014389038, 0.007896423, 0.041168213, 0.021408081, -0.011459351, 0.047027588, -0.007881165, 0.034973145, -0.0423584, -0.013824463, 0.0049324036, 0.031829834, -0.012710571, 0.0028896332, 0.011390686, -0.035949707, -0.028381348, 0.013290405, 0.0079193115, -0.0070991516, 0.009666443, 0.032287598, 0.009315491, 0.0022239685, 0.011787415, -0.0061302185, 0.013618469, -0.0071372986, 0.033111572, 0.013664246, -0.0038490295, 0.019378662, -0.004337311, -0.008171082, 0.005428314, -0.010055542, -0.01651001, -0.0051727295, -0.006706238, -0.032073975, -0.0287323, -0.02217102, -0.052124023, -0.0049591064, -0.032348633, 0.06774902, 0.008071899, -0.011314392, -0.012207031, 0.019134521, -0.005168915, 0.015838623, -0.002943039, -0.047210693, -0.018936157, -0.022994995, -0.0026359558, -0.020065308, 0.02494812, -0.02809143, 0.022735596, 0.06262207, -0.0038490295, 0.013153076, -0.068237305, 0.011657715, 0.011299133, -0.0054969788, -0.01537323, -0.037719727, 0.006072998, -0.045135498, 0.0060424805, 0.013267517, 0.020080566, 0.013977051, -0.0059432983, 0.019424438, -0.010498047, 0.010215759, 0.022827148, 0.0099487305, 0.0027256012, 0.0127334595, -0.031799316, -0.008903503, 0.030319214, -0.0096588135, -0.016555786, 0.012786865, 0.07006836, -0.036193848, 0.015197754, 0.0058021545, 0.02420044, -0.050445557, -0.0060653687, -0.032196045, 0.0026893616, 0.011253357, -0.02470398, 0.0076408386, 0.002986908, 0.054718018, 0.019210815, 0.062683105, 0.03829956, -0.002565384, 0.038024902, 0.001408577, 0.013977051, 0.017074585, -0.00944519, 0.019302368, -0.025146484, 0.025314331, 0.0010185242, 0.0317688, 0.010009766, -0.016616821, -0.0021400452, 0.009223938, 0.052368164, 0.004802704, 0.019332886, -0.021392822, -0.006401062, 0.01687622, -0.018127441, -0.019638062, -0.05117798, -0.03390503, 0.0068206787, -0.074645996, -0.076538086, -0.02571106, -0.034118652, -0.000893116, -0.039886475, 0.04272461, -0.049926758, -0.0022068024, -0.035858154, -0.017120361, -0.06500244, 0.00818634, 0.012763977, -0.009902954, -0.038116455, -0.06781006, 0.016021729, -0.04949951, 0.012580872, 0.047943115, -0.01940918, -0.0847168, 0.050994873, 0.010169983, 0.081848145, -0.0051116943, -0.034820557, -0.008399963, 0.027786255, 0.040130615, -0.037841797, -0.032684326, 0.022842407, 0.013450623, -0.022888184, -0.0025730133, 0.005088806, -0.025436401, -0.03289795, -0.013618469, -0.0013828278, -0.0178833, 0.0066223145, 0.008171082, -0.009468079, -0.03717041, -0.0007162094, -0.029510498, 0.009147644, -0.0056762695, 0.012687683, 0.060455322, 0.016677856, 0.025543213, -0.0031051636, 0.015975952, -0.023803711, 0.03036499, -0.011451721, -0.03933716, 0.020507812, 0.02041626, -0.053771973, -0.04321289, 0.015914917, 0.0496521, 0.012374878, 0.003572464, -0.01838684, -0.017791748, -0.0031032562, 0.04940796, -0.0152282715, -0.03277588, 0.0413208, 0.014816284, 0.023391724, 0.026947021, -0.016418457, -0.002292633, 0.017456055, -0.0022468567, -0.036224365, -0.014770508, 0.025680542, -0.074523926, 0.031585693, 0.012046814, -0.0022888184, -0.088012695, -0.056121826, -0.031463623, 0.0056648254, -0.027923584, -0.016815186, 0.01789856, -0.07141113, -0.010025024, -0.046447754, 0.010505676, -0.012702942, -0.00894165, -0.014030457, 0.043029785, 0.0036735535, 0.024429321, -0.024902344, 0.012718201, 0.019592285, 0.018585205, -0.023071289, 0.04864502, 0.023269653, -0.08026123, -0.0062332153, -0.0019207001, -0.020370483, 0.040649414, 0.019424438, -0.00806427, 0.07824707, -0.03427124, 0.032104492, 0.026031494, -0.030380249, -0.0036239624, -0.006591797, 0.03314209, -0.028274536, 0.010253906 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09210v1
Chain-of-Note: Enhancing Robustness in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models
Wenhao Yu, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Kaixin Ma, Hongwei Wang, Dong Yu
cs.CL, cs.AI
Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) represent a substantial advancement in the capabilities of large language models, notably in reducing factual hallucination by leveraging external knowledge sources. However, the reliability of the retrieved information is not always guaranteed. The retrieval of irrelevant data can lead to misguided responses, and potentially causing the model to overlook its inherent knowledge, even when it possesses adequate information to address the query. Moreover, standard RALMs often struggle to assess whether they possess adequate knowledge, both intrinsic and retrieved, to provide an accurate answer. In situations where knowledge is lacking, these systems should ideally respond with "unknown" when the answer is unattainable. In response to these challenges, we introduces Chain-of-Noting (CoN), a novel approach aimed at improving the robustness of RALMs in facing noisy, irrelevant documents and in handling unknown scenarios. The core idea of CoN is to generate sequential reading notes for retrieved documents, enabling a thorough evaluation of their relevance to the given question and integrating this information to formulate the final answer. We employed ChatGPT to create training data for CoN, which was subsequently trained on an LLaMa-2 7B model. Our experiments across four open-domain QA benchmarks show that RALMs equipped with CoN significantly outperform standard RALMs. Notably, CoN achieves an average improvement of +7.9 in EM score given entirely noisy retrieved documents and +10.5 in rejection rates for real-time questions that fall outside the pre-training knowledge scope.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09210v1
2023-11-15T18:54:53
2023-11-15T18:54:53
{ "title": [ 0.013885498, 0.0040893555, -0.0076293945, -0.058502197, 0.008384705, 0.0041160583, -0.039978027, -0.024887085, 0.016983032, 0.048034668, -0.017654419, 0.021316528, 0.028518677, 0.0031223297, -0.05706787, 0.021453857, -0.022155762, 0.014587402, -0.071777344, -0.05795288, 0.0028877258, -0.084350586, -0.0009074211, 0.025131226, 0.04034424, -0.05709839, -0.060943604, 0.008125305, -0.001789093, -0.014923096, -0.0019493103, -0.016403198, 0.05419922, 0.016723633, -0.036071777, -0.0028762817, -0.038116455, 0.0152282715, -0.021850586, 0.024719238, 0.032073975, -0.025146484, 0.000059723854, -0.004070282, -0.04623413, 0.021621704, -0.03060913, -0.0067253113, 0.011772156, 0.03050232, 0.005619049, 0.02822876, -0.01776123, 0.010421753, 0.020645142, -0.01638794, -0.021743774, 0.029708862, 0.024246216, 0.05227661, 0.02368164, -0.01676941, 0.0006299019, -0.0110321045, -0.03173828, -0.019195557, -0.012664795, 0.020324707, 0.044708252, 0.0019235611, -0.01979065, 0.008270264, 0.010482788, -0.0340271, -0.030197144, 0.037231445, 0.009239197, -0.0051193237, 0.04852295, -0.034851074, 0.0011167526, -0.00049877167, 0.004508972, -0.018493652, 0.01309967, -0.033691406, -0.024765015, -0.0076141357, -0.020050049, -0.07556152, -0.0052948, -0.04083252, -0.032287598, 0.020523071, -0.012969971, -0.0423584, -0.009971619, 0.031021118, 0.0018119812, -0.03173828, -0.019836426, 0.03161621, -0.06384277, -0.012863159, 0.013298035, 0.040863037, -0.010108948, 0.005256653, 0.017242432, 0.024002075, -0.009185791, 0.05441284, 0.0027885437, 0.0047798157, -0.0062065125, -0.004245758, -0.02810669, 0.01826477, 0.0010633469, 0.021484375, -0.0067329407, -0.022277832, 0.015792847, -0.0015134811, 0.0069885254, -0.022857666, -0.04849243, 0.021636963, -0.027450562, 0.038116455, 0.0082473755, 0.048065186, -0.1027832, -0.075683594, -0.080078125, 0.03942871, -0.030426025, 0.01739502, -0.018737793, -0.009483337, 0.036132812, -0.013893127, 0.018630981, 0.02243042, -0.010482788, 0.0051651, 0.07409668, -0.006187439, -0.06866455, -0.039123535, -0.023788452, 0.026535034, 0.048461914, -0.020858765, -0.070373535, -0.050476074, -0.111572266, -0.033203125, 0.013328552, -0.027801514, 0.008308411, 0.004760742, 0.006893158, -0.0041160583, 0.008377075, -0.012825012, -0.01914978, 0.008773804, 0.020126343, 0.066223145, -0.019744873, 0.007068634, 0.0211792, 0.027770996, 0.00024437904, 0.020370483, 0.043670654, 0.005279541, 0.031829834, -0.0118637085, 0.019485474, -0.008972168, 0.060424805, 0.015670776, -0.08068848, 0.0032539368, -0.007858276, 0.059020996, 0.062927246, 0.0018348694, -0.019943237, -0.002199173, -0.03817749, -0.021713257, -0.04031372, -0.023590088, 0.036743164, 0.024887085, 0.0035800934, 0.005252838, -0.013549805, 0.0021572113, -0.023864746, -0.025009155, -0.035705566, -0.021087646, -0.025299072, 0.024887085, -0.018341064, 0.037994385, 0.074523926, 0.03012085, -0.066467285, 0.030075073, -0.019866943, -0.022918701, 0.036193848, -0.0030765533, 0.010643005, -0.0075645447, 0.0027618408, 0.0010061264, 0.009483337, 0.050933838, 0.007972717, -0.016555786, 0.017913818, -0.02911377, 0.03387451, 0.0069122314, 0.0635376, -0.026687622, 0.048980713, 0.046539307, 0.0049057007, -0.036743164, -0.0027656555, -0.06707764, 0.032836914, 0.020233154, -0.0115356445, -0.0033073425, -0.022033691, 0.02609253, 0.06549072, -0.0020542145, -0.0068588257, 0.028656006, 0.018981934, 0.04498291, 0.048950195, 0.033721924, 0.035491943, 0.020614624, 0.0012388229, 0.06060791, 0.011001587, 0.017532349, -0.031188965, 0.02078247, 0.008659363, 0.010681152, -0.013221741, 0.0047721863, -0.03591919, 0.0146102905, -0.0017194748, 0.020339966, 0.0036373138, 0.015159607, 0.015670776, -0.012664795, 0.025772095, -0.009132385, -0.017837524, -0.028640747, -0.015083313, 0.025604248, 0.019546509, -0.05895996, 0.015220642, 0.021713257, 0.07055664, 0.0018386841, 0.016464233, -0.008033752, 0.015274048, -0.013923645, -0.028396606, 0.003709793, 0.048950195, 0.030075073, 0.019577026, -0.013999939, -0.020065308, 0.009590149, 0.085876465, 0.044006348, -0.024490356, 0.043426514, -0.028564453, 0.029159546, 0.03869629, -0.017303467, 0.013092041, 0.012901306, 0.017120361, 0.024551392, -0.023101807, 0.0034122467, -0.029266357, 0.037231445, -0.002084732, -0.009773254, -0.045959473, -0.053771973, -0.0030727386, -0.03543091, -0.0692749, -0.05517578, 0.08691406, -0.025970459, 0.0023002625, 0.017227173, -0.012123108, -0.039093018, 0.03503418, -0.021652222, -0.00076532364, 0.008476257, 0.020385742, -0.0007715225, -0.06939697, -0.026535034, -0.008041382, 0.013214111, -0.009941101, -0.009544373, -0.024383545, 0.022003174, 0.013755798, 0.003206253, 0.0061912537, -0.04083252, 0.016143799, -0.049224854, 0.01020813, 0.014038086, -0.033233643, -0.0009293556, 0.0065345764, -0.008850098, 0.014572144, 0.0335083, 0.08868408, -0.045715332, -0.07550049, 0.071777344, 0.025802612, -0.0015420914, 0.015022278, 0.02468872, 0.0017194748, -0.07751465, -0.024459839, -0.036621094, -0.03466797, 0.0008625984, 0.00447464, 0.03488159, -0.020050049, -0.012420654, -0.057800293, -0.016952515, 0.016036987, -0.012832642, 0.033813477, -0.018432617, -0.0309906, 0.0060806274, -0.015625, 0.016921997, -0.017684937, 0.048950195, 0.0692749, 0.015419006, -0.023590088, 0.020904541, -0.01121521, 0.008399963, -0.029800415, -0.02130127, -0.028335571, -0.008956909, 0.02330017, 0.02381897, -0.0345459, -0.0390625, -0.06335449, -0.0029640198, 0.047973633, -0.005027771, -0.015037537, 0.027526855, -0.08508301, 0.047332764, -0.029571533, -0.010818481, 0.033691406, -0.021591187, 0.01966858, -0.004699707, 0.016418457, -0.051574707, 0.005207062, -0.05923462, -0.1149292, 0.0236969, -0.004814148, -0.037872314, -0.010864258, -0.05834961, -0.038360596, -0.001329422, 0.006454468, 0.046325684, 0.01133728, -0.0013599396, 0.00957489, -0.023712158, -0.0023860931, -0.036224365, -0.027801514, -0.018615723, -0.013839722, 0.002445221, -0.00047063828, 0.018035889, 0.0126953125, -0.008666992, -0.014709473, 0.0015411377, -0.041931152, 0.014030457, -0.008514404, -0.04336548, 0.0032920837, -0.007411957, -0.019836426, -0.0020580292, -0.029663086, 0.006542206, -0.013298035, 0.016967773, -0.011688232, 0.014144897, 0.024017334, 0.004386902, -0.022750854, -0.027542114, 0.0047073364, -0.013954163, -0.044158936, -0.0262146, 0.04977417, 0.023956299, -0.057861328, -0.01008606, -0.03945923, 0.012504578, -0.0030918121, 0.0070533752, -0.0017623901, 0.019012451, -0.03225708, -0.012176514, 0.004890442, -0.006252289, 0.022125244, 0.018447876, -0.00025868416, 0.013336182, -0.0002963543, -0.085754395, -0.013786316, -0.000320673, -0.11193848, -0.049591064, -0.0062789917, -0.010597229, -0.0093688965, -0.034423828, 0.015487671, -0.0395813, -0.050628662, 0.007537842, -0.019683838, -0.017105103, -0.024810791, -0.1081543, 0.015098572, 0.08691406, 0.006088257, 0.053466797, 0.04824829, -0.013938904, -0.041046143, -0.01637268, 0.044921875, 0.00598526, 0.033935547, 0.016357422, 0.0029258728, 0.022262573, -0.008964539, 0.021408081, 0.039001465, -0.040924072, 0.026611328, 0.012825012, -0.013298035, 0.022979736, -0.021514893, 0.042297363, 0.00094509125, 0.005531311, -0.06707764, 0.049743652, -0.007068634, 0.0052108765, -0.004169464, -0.028900146, 0.0016994476, -0.0026416779, 0.028823853, 0.033477783, -0.0027618408, 0.010604858, 0.03125, -0.023040771, -0.020111084, 0.0022392273, 0.027770996, 0.001294136, 0.0058288574, 0.02293396, -0.008483887, 0.02708435, -0.009086609, -0.022445679, -0.013412476, 0.013679504, -0.03463745, -0.0059165955, -0.057678223, -0.064819336, -0.03643799, 0.013366699, -0.013793945, 0.046295166, 0.031082153, 0.0079956055, -0.021255493, 0.0015802383, 0.034484863, 0.014533997, -0.011512756, -0.05770874, 0.016448975, -0.025360107, -0.041931152, -0.03591919, -0.00919342, 0.004737854, 0.027069092, -0.0010385513, -0.012451172, 0.003868103, 0.024108887, 0.036834717, 0.029190063, -0.010284424, -0.028579712, 0.029037476, 0.008598328, -0.05911255, 0.01777649, -0.0047073364, 0.00945282, -0.03878784, 0.011016846, -0.027526855, -0.026489258, -0.06427002, 0.05380249, 0.009223938, 0.044403076, 0.004886627, 0.009231567, 0.045288086, 0.017242432, -0.0071258545, 0.0013246536, -0.031555176, 0.006263733, -0.0184021, 0.02519226, -0.0052375793, 0.007827759, 0.06323242, 0.0101623535, 0.026870728, -0.0011262894, -0.020568848, 0.010063171, 0.016326904, 0.00920105, 0.03060913, -0.037994385, -0.055999756, -0.007785797, 0.005290985, 0.035461426, -0.027008057, 0.029922485, -0.013648987, 0.043945312, 0.025421143, -0.027923584, 0.027114868, -0.011940002, 0.015464783, -0.06323242, -0.08135986, -0.020233154, 0.042907715, -0.022766113, -0.0032367706, 0.011062622, -0.002878189, 0.0032730103, 0.030059814, -0.005115509, -0.025787354, -0.005264282, -0.037200928, -0.03314209, -0.019973755, -0.05758667, 0.010299683, 0.0107040405, 0.011947632, -0.027038574, 0.004776001, -0.056365967, -0.026184082, -0.032226562, -0.03479004, 0.047088623, -0.06896973, 0.007282257, 0.07470703, 0.0039482117, 0.04284668, -0.023254395, 0.02406311, 0.035369873, 0.052124023, 0.014251709, 0.006538391, 0.038116455, -0.023010254, 0.025344849, 0.012062073, 0.021362305, -0.00064468384, 0.054260254, 0.013084412, 0.020614624, -0.05831909, 0.020507812, 0.015167236, 0.0019435883, 0.02142334, -0.057891846, 0.0068855286, 0.011169434, 0.0067863464, 0.01676941, -0.014076233, -0.02659607, -0.017181396, -0.0013046265, -0.044189453, -0.0063552856, -0.008728027, -0.058929443, -0.020828247, -0.00014615059, 0.0032291412, 0.0055999756, 0.020767212, -0.00573349, -0.04272461, 0.02986145, 0.05593872, -0.021011353, 0.002292633, -0.0020999908, 0.009223938, 0.03387451, 0.016220093, -0.031219482, -0.009841919, 0.0034046173, -0.0418396, -0.020706177, 0.021331787, 0.013290405, -0.0024719238, 0.013801575, 0.0021572113, 0.02520752, -0.0064048767, 0.028671265, 0.00111866, 0.00061893463, 0.048065186, 0.00034952164, 0.01448822, 0.012886047, 0.013145447, 0.015098572, 0.00440979, 0.01399231, -0.062042236, 0.042633057, 0.0090789795, 0.047973633, -0.023468018, -0.076293945, 0.019607544, 0.016571045, -0.007511139, 0.0046310425, 0.02835083, 0.026229858, 0.013061523, 0.032073975, 0.016235352, 0.0552063, -0.040802002, -0.021713257, -0.030731201, -0.0035953522, -0.04940796, 0.044128418, 0.00207901, -0.007698059, -0.03515625, -0.030639648, -0.028900146, 0.01979065, 0.025253296, -0.018707275, 0.0065727234, -0.023330688, 0.03265381, 0.004348755, -0.02507019, -0.054901123, 0.04724121, 0.0087890625, -0.008964539, 0.0021133423, -0.018432617, -0.003189087, -0.018463135, 0.008491516, 0.0039520264, -0.031219482, 0.010292053, -0.032562256, 0.020568848, -0.022918701, -0.017822266, 0.04147339, 0.0132369995, -0.020370483, 0.04611206, -0.013031006, 0.0541687, 0.021697998, 0.038635254, 0.07385254, 0.01499939, -0.02166748, 0.003929138, 0.024429321, -0.032470703, 0.02720642, -0.045074463, 0.027938843, -0.053527832, 0.0035629272, -0.08300781, 0.020080566, 0.029205322, 0.035858154, -0.01360321, 0.016448975, 0.00472641, 0.0077285767, 0.029800415, -0.0066184998, 0.053649902, -0.04071045, 0.007160187, -0.019561768, -0.072387695, 0.04324341, 0.04940796, 0.00068712234, -0.03842163, -0.03942871, -0.01687622, 0.014572144, -0.0028972626, 0.012489319, -0.038604736, -0.025970459, -0.052612305, 0.02796936, 0.0048065186, 0.053497314, 0.039367676, -0.014015198, 0.00037240982, -0.006702423, -0.02748108, -0.02671814, -0.007911682, -0.03955078, 0.0045318604, -0.059906006, -0.0065574646, -0.018676758, 0.0030994415, -0.027282715, 0.02494812, 0.03805542, -0.06689453, -0.031204224, 0.0026836395, 0.051879883, -0.008018494, 0.012832642, -0.03552246, -0.022338867, 0.00415802, 0.034973145, -0.0010595322, 0.03286743, 0.0011978149, 0.018615723, -0.0010681152, -0.024642944, 0.013969421, 0.0018472672, 0.007507324, 0.02722168, -0.001996994, 0.052856445, -0.034210205, -0.04248047, 0.027404785, 0.009590149, -0.07678223, -0.023971558, 0.030517578, 0.034973145, 0.047943115, 0.08215332, 0.016403198, 0.006828308, -0.0052375793, -0.041503906, 0.015090942, 0.047973633, -0.021972656, 0.025939941, -0.052490234, -0.049835205, 0.025985718, -0.061553955, 0.04916382, -0.049224854, -0.0039138794, -0.021835327, 0.017959595, 0.022857666, -0.02897644, -0.024139404, -0.014823914, -0.028518677, 0.009033203, 0.004322052, -0.036132812, -0.020889282, -0.02078247, 0.00459671, -0.00017511845, -0.0014848709, 0.021972656, -0.015945435, -0.09075928, -0.0052108765, -0.029434204, 0.027862549, -0.03225708, 0.0017385483, 0.0061416626, -0.0178833, 0.015525818, -0.045654297, -0.04321289, -0.018753052, -0.012969971, -0.022781372, 0.002122879, 0.010726929, -0.02027893, -0.054840088, -0.02973938, 0.004547119, -0.042022705, 0.028656006, 0.007045746, -0.061920166, -0.0016384125, 0.005695343, -0.04083252, 0.03616333, 0.019958496, -0.0046310425, 0.037963867, 0.03062439, -0.04034424, -0.009231567, -0.0096588135, 0.007843018, 0.016525269, -0.06149292, 0.0057525635, 0.013076782, 0.0395813, -0.04135132, -0.04196167, 0.022750854, 0.013328552, -0.017333984, 0.03515625, 0.023361206, 0.004196167, 0.025512695, 0.0017080307, 0.0043258667, -0.048797607, -0.018325806, -0.043548584, 0.027664185, 0.032165527, -0.015098572, -0.0003335476, 0.039642334, -0.019454956, -0.002922058, 0.005996704, -0.0317688, -0.0070533752, 0.006122589, 0.024597168, -0.0071983337, -0.040893555, -0.059753418, 0.03213501, -0.006214142, 0.02758789, -0.024978638, 0.034606934, -0.0129852295, 0.027862549, -0.031051636, -0.036224365, 0.061187744, 0.022003174, 0.025283813, -0.008354187, 0.022735596, 0.013198853, -0.010665894, -0.0032405853, -0.0059394836, 0.00024282932, 0.0317688, -0.002878189, 0.022964478, -0.02734375, -0.0345459, -0.007396698, -0.018463135, 0.025772095, -0.043945312, 0.016830444, -0.02468872, -0.02494812, -0.003528595, 0.010467529, 0.031555176, -0.009918213, -0.052215576, -0.032226562, 0.02798462, -0.017486572 ], "summary": [ 0.02949524, -0.03286743, 0.026901245, -0.033172607, -0.050689697, 0.0056877136, -0.035064697, -0.021774292, 0.028579712, 0.023452759, -0.030700684, 0.0008625984, 0.0011577606, -0.005065918, -0.020645142, -0.026779175, -0.020004272, 0.033813477, -0.032073975, -0.03778076, 0.0012893677, -0.055023193, -0.027618408, 0.018554688, 0.017837524, -0.029144287, -0.00894928, -0.0016107559, 0.04437256, 0.0340271, 0.02255249, -0.04434204, 0.045288086, 0.028778076, -0.084228516, -0.00058603287, -0.0014867783, 0.0010948181, -0.048614502, 0.06628418, 0.026672363, -0.016677856, 0.03152466, -0.010475159, -0.021408081, 0.05508423, -0.030975342, -0.017578125, 0.035583496, 0.038604736, -0.011795044, -0.00044560432, -0.01309967, 0.025680542, -0.023605347, -0.049835205, -0.016418457, 0.022827148, 0.005672455, 0.055999756, 0.016357422, 0.03012085, -0.019683838, -0.04827881, -0.0087509155, 0.00655365, 0.061279297, -0.026260376, 0.054870605, 0.003019333, -0.017227173, 0.04626465, 0.015808105, -0.06628418, 0.00096845627, 0.045928955, 0.004814148, 0.003856659, 0.0021877289, -0.009086609, 0.007926941, 0.04296875, 0.026657104, -0.037231445, -0.018875122, -0.056854248, -0.02027893, -0.005207062, -0.036956787, -0.060577393, -0.019561768, -0.004436493, -0.09472656, 0.022583008, 0.01939392, -0.039398193, 0.02406311, -0.0014448166, -0.0030708313, -0.053649902, 0.0064964294, -0.015258789, -0.055480957, 0.0051002502, 0.023788452, 0.08477783, -0.0047035217, -0.05114746, 0.02708435, -0.010673523, 0.016433716, 0.037109375, 0.0061035156, -0.053833008, 0.009796143, 0.022857666, -0.0146102905, 0.045043945, 0.024780273, 0.016021729, -0.016647339, -0.0036830902, 0.013175964, 0.020019531, -0.029266357, -0.02154541, 0.0052986145, 0.0010204315, -0.027145386, 0.02607727, -0.016235352, 0.039642334, -0.012962341, -0.027740479, -0.054718018, -0.008369446, -0.022964478, 0.011550903, -0.014404297, -0.029342651, 0.03656006, -0.005378723, 0.019363403, 0.030044556, -0.013870239, 0.06561279, 0.03289795, -0.033294678, -0.029830933, -0.032470703, -0.036743164, -0.027755737, 0.041870117, -0.041046143, -0.056884766, -0.062194824, -0.08862305, 0.0054244995, 0.004623413, -0.013809204, 0.009567261, -0.011314392, 0.0015506744, 0.026016235, -0.025924683, 0.000021517277, -0.006175995, -0.010269165, 0.009109497, 0.031021118, -0.009140015, -0.0008597374, 0.033935547, -0.004497528, -0.006263733, 0.002708435, 0.026504517, 0.04989624, 0.022323608, -0.018585205, 0.005054474, -0.019485474, 0.089782715, -0.0070228577, -0.031143188, 0.027114868, 0.006134033, 0.09643555, 0.025787354, 0.014030457, -0.011116028, -0.035217285, -0.012054443, -0.015655518, -0.039764404, -0.001964569, 0.0035800934, 0.021850586, -0.021133423, 0.016342163, 0.006214142, 0.010803223, -0.0340271, -0.029815674, -0.089660645, -0.02468872, -0.019485474, 0.020355225, 0.0034179688, 0.038085938, 0.042816162, 0.025115967, -0.053527832, 0.045837402, 0.00021004677, -0.032958984, 0.03866577, -0.018966675, 0.023284912, -0.011444092, 0.024627686, 0.057617188, -0.02168274, 0.03756714, -0.024597168, -0.04498291, 0.0044059753, -0.001200676, 0.008720398, -0.020858765, 0.06665039, -0.008918762, 0.0019054413, 0.024032593, 0.001452446, -0.007843018, 0.026275635, -0.07989502, 0.027862549, 0.036468506, 0.008995056, 0.020141602, -0.06530762, -0.010192871, 0.06237793, 0.015792847, -0.009132385, 0.016647339, -0.040985107, 0.0021076202, 0.04260254, 0.03414917, 0.009643555, 0.04824829, 0.010803223, 0.013336182, 0.017196655, 0.014770508, -0.036315918, 0.018539429, 0.0022945404, -0.025314331, -0.0231781, -0.015075684, -0.0004992485, -0.030059814, 0.040100098, 0.025665283, 0.019210815, -0.061431885, 0.009002686, 0.030776978, 0.003522873, -0.050933838, -0.014381409, -0.031707764, -0.014480591, 0.0395813, 0.019485474, -0.04901123, 0.006214142, 0.019943237, 0.023925781, -0.012863159, 0.013580322, 0.010093689, 0.014190674, -0.008544922, -0.023208618, 0.076660156, 0.07861328, 0.02166748, 0.012145996, -0.037994385, -0.0129852295, 0.021255493, -0.023254395, 0.020706177, 0.00015842915, -0.0022354126, -0.031829834, 0.041107178, 0.018249512, -0.013946533, 0.016021729, -0.018585205, 0.009521484, 0.017791748, 0.0018491745, -0.00818634, -0.018478394, 0.053375244, 0.029449463, 0.0793457, -0.043792725, -0.052856445, -0.016326904, 0.025100708, -0.055755615, -0.046051025, 0.08862305, -0.025222778, 0.012748718, 0.044128418, -0.018814087, -0.053833008, 0.08337402, -0.020111084, 0.037719727, -0.0070343018, -0.03652954, -0.02470398, -0.06689453, -0.00079631805, 0.014968872, 0.019546509, -0.0025596619, 0.0071411133, -0.010185242, 0.018066406, 0.023376465, -0.060028076, -0.011459351, -0.0014705658, -0.017669678, -0.001502037, -0.0037994385, 0.0054397583, -0.040374756, -0.01335907, 0.011299133, -0.012123108, 0.0121154785, 0.025512695, 0.054016113, -0.038970947, -0.042266846, 0.051635742, 0.01197052, -0.019134521, 0.010917664, 0.02709961, -0.0023097992, -0.10430908, -0.018112183, -0.016708374, -0.04034424, -0.009262085, 0.026641846, 0.038726807, 0.030548096, 0.05606079, -0.06890869, -0.029541016, -0.038024902, -0.009918213, 0.10522461, 0.019348145, -0.038085938, 0.05493164, 0.02859497, 0.028839111, -0.0014410019, 0.011520386, 0.055755615, 0.0059280396, -0.03640747, 0.035858154, -0.014167786, 0.008514404, -0.019424438, 0.012031555, -0.041046143, -0.022201538, 0.013801575, 0.026794434, -0.009262085, -0.035369873, 0.00028657913, -0.036621094, 0.055236816, 0.011886597, 0.032684326, 0.009735107, -0.03564453, 0.074157715, -0.011520386, 0.015403748, 0.02935791, -0.08642578, 0.06311035, -0.068237305, 0.02609253, -0.066223145, 0.009613037, -0.08203125, -0.072143555, 0.0041275024, -0.017715454, 0.018356323, -0.014190674, 0.011405945, -0.03036499, 0.0032997131, 0.028930664, 0.0524292, -0.02116394, -0.0065612793, -0.0021457672, -0.023498535, 0.013069153, -0.03475952, -0.0051002502, 0.009506226, 0.024154663, 0.008522034, -0.029937744, -0.07836914, -0.0018196106, -0.044128418, -0.0357666, -0.017807007, -0.020950317, 0.02142334, 0.009750366, -0.023162842, -0.025619507, -0.030944824, -0.03149414, -0.0058784485, -0.030700684, 0.014457703, 0.008705139, 0.04260254, -0.0071868896, 0.05508423, -0.011894226, 0.008964539, 0.024291992, -0.012710571, -0.02180481, 0.0019340515, -0.012199402, -0.038848877, 0.066711426, 0.025024414, -0.097839355, 0.0101623535, -0.040374756, 0.020111084, 0.051757812, -0.038482666, 0.0017518997, -0.0066871643, -0.009262085, -0.050842285, 0.025817871, -0.010955811, 0.03945923, -0.023590088, -0.06829834, 0.040496826, -0.040802002, -0.059814453, -0.019012451, -0.008125305, -0.023162842, -0.04714966, 0.0063285828, 0.036987305, 0.028427124, -0.031951904, 0.02255249, -0.0023097992, -0.046722412, 0.004627228, -0.018173218, 0.051757812, 0.0011978149, -0.067871094, 0.036376953, -0.0030517578, 0.009666443, 0.029922485, 0.01171875, 0.0013208389, -0.010864258, 0.021453857, 0.03717041, 0.014839172, 0.016998291, 0.0033950806, 0.019607544, 0.0028381348, 0.010505676, 0.05130005, 0.030044556, -0.05065918, 0.05291748, -0.00063991547, 0.00015974045, 0.023117065, 0.0036621094, 0.008911133, -0.00687027, 0.027404785, -0.0345459, 0.06890869, -0.0010824203, -0.01701355, 0.006713867, 0.024047852, -0.02041626, 0.011482239, 0.01890564, -0.025238037, -0.02305603, 0.0021972656, 0.04989624, 0.013328552, -0.039978027, -0.03866577, 0.010475159, 0.039733887, 0.00059461594, 0.02822876, -0.003293991, 0.03515625, -0.024261475, 0.03527832, -0.025299072, -0.014663696, -0.00919342, -0.011192322, -0.006916046, -0.044006348, -0.0073242188, -0.0011339188, -0.0039520264, 0.00945282, 0.023147583, 0.007904053, -0.010772705, -0.00995636, 0.017822266, 0.010375977, -0.010009766, -0.07299805, 0.022964478, -0.045288086, -0.02192688, -0.028503418, -0.035003662, -0.024169922, -0.023925781, 0.019882202, -0.0012626648, 0.002073288, 0.011489868, 0.023422241, -0.0065345764, 0.02960205, 0.0036010742, 0.015319824, 0.016204834, -0.02671814, 0.029968262, -0.016021729, 0.016571045, -0.008132935, -0.0019836426, -0.018920898, -0.035583496, -0.030334473, 0.030380249, 0.040222168, 0.03375244, 0.009284973, 0.030822754, 0.030441284, 0.009933472, 0.019378662, -0.003124237, -0.00667572, -0.025009155, 0.030914307, 0.00068187714, 0.015007019, -0.0061569214, 0.057647705, -0.010131836, -0.008033752, 0.012145996, -0.020248413, 0.011459351, 0.024276733, 0.033325195, 0.0040397644, 0.008987427, -0.012931824, 0.03062439, 0.008308411, 0.019851685, 0.008804321, 0.015235901, 0.004837036, 0.02897644, 0.060668945, -0.016815186, -0.039215088, 0.022399902, -0.0362854, -0.033599854, -0.07788086, -0.008743286, 0.066833496, -0.0026988983, 0.008468628, -0.0013542175, -0.016098022, 0.003458023, -0.010360718, -0.035858154, -0.03643799, 0.010101318, -0.033203125, -0.03186035, -0.011886597, -0.009147644, -0.011253357, 0.0029449463, 0.0105896, 0.024475098, -0.03579712, 0.0062446594, -0.010368347, -0.018295288, -0.020935059, 0.008361816, -0.031341553, -0.04736328, -0.002243042, -0.044311523, 0.008392334, 0.008888245, 0.015686035, -0.028625488, 0.051971436, -0.03250122, 0.013313293, 0.025848389, -0.023620605, -0.014701843, -0.016830444, 0.0055999756, 0.008041382, 0.060760498, 0.018814087, 0.024383545, -0.04449463, 0.0016336441, -0.011947632, -0.006313324, -0.0067825317, -0.01626587, 0.010482788, -0.01727295, 0.026382446, 0.015045166, 0.046447754, 0.0073242188, 0.020904541, 0.021270752, 0.009819031, -0.050811768, -0.011146545, -0.01576233, 0.010215759, 0.012870789, -0.026916504, 0.0015592575, 0.031951904, -0.005680084, 0.005340576, -0.020996094, 0.0748291, 0.016647339, 0.009643555, -0.018249512, 0.010856628, -0.007835388, 0.012382507, -0.047698975, -0.014472961, -0.0015258789, 0.0034732819, -0.010658264, 0.013626099, 0.008522034, 0.0046577454, -0.0023517609, 0.006072998, 0.040771484, -0.030517578, 0.00969696, -0.00970459, -0.012954712, 0.022659302, -0.009178162, -0.008468628, 0.035858154, 0.023910522, -0.05722046, 0.022232056, 0.052490234, -0.06109619, 0.027801514, 0.04397583, 0.052368164, -0.018341064, -0.058776855, -0.0031490326, 0.036346436, -0.015106201, 0.014152527, 0.035125732, 0.0027713776, 0.007633209, 0.014503479, 0.010223389, 0.013877869, -0.0014629364, -0.0043296814, -0.029373169, 0.018859863, -0.042663574, 0.009727478, -0.011634827, -0.007575989, -0.016830444, -0.01222229, 0.01890564, 0.013771057, 0.004421234, -0.012191772, 0.010971069, -0.033813477, -0.0064468384, 0.06365967, -0.04257202, -0.049346924, 0.026611328, -0.0073547363, -0.010627747, 0.08050537, -0.024246216, 0.008575439, -0.022079468, -0.006702423, -0.016525269, -0.028701782, 0.011787415, 0.029434204, 0.023361206, 0.0005245209, 0.013626099, 0.030227661, 0.020385742, -0.02243042, 0.0005736351, 0.0109939575, 0.0390625, 0.03744507, 0.013824463, 0.029434204, -0.0051879883, -0.0008058548, 0.015731812, 0.026947021, -0.02456665, 0.04876709, -0.011672974, 0.025115967, -0.009666443, -0.016677856, -0.044403076, 0.0423584, 0.01864624, 0.0071907043, 0.023773193, 0.0069351196, 0.0061073303, 0.02041626, -0.011604309, 0.024032593, 0.013000488, -0.017364502, -0.0061950684, -0.009124756, -0.048095703, 0.02067566, 0.053497314, 0.024673462, -0.016036987, -0.018814087, 0.024124146, 0.035614014, -0.036834717, -0.04385376, -0.08306885, 0.031463623, -0.05230713, 0.021835327, 0.033935547, 0.07598877, -0.011642456, -0.045532227, 0.017593384, 0.0022144318, -0.03616333, -0.007320404, -0.022781372, -0.0057907104, -0.011749268, -0.011528015, -0.006160736, -0.017959595, -0.0014038086, 0.03640747, 0.021652222, 0.050109863, -0.05545044, 0.022201538, -0.007751465, 0.0021133423, -0.02670288, -0.003643036, -0.036621094, -0.024658203, 0.02243042, 0.018554688, -0.0029010773, 0.023971558, 0.005935669, -0.02444458, -0.016067505, -0.010406494, 0.013641357, 0.009025574, 0.011451721, 0.03277588, -0.043304443, 0.07067871, -0.041900635, -0.034576416, 0.050842285, -0.008262634, -0.040405273, -0.0104522705, 0.066467285, 0.072753906, 0.045440674, 0.09411621, -0.03338623, 0.03842163, 0.034698486, 0.03643799, 0.020935059, -0.010955811, -0.0018959045, -0.03842163, -0.020736694, -0.0034656525, -0.020462036, -0.029663086, 0.03286743, -0.049621582, -0.026260376, -0.02960205, -0.004219055, -0.03363037, 0.013450623, -0.015289307, -0.05609131, -0.016937256, 0.0026874542, 0.0025501251, -0.02482605, -0.019943237, -0.018859863, 0.016220093, 0.0055274963, 0.002248764, 0.027664185, -0.013145447, -0.0129852295, -0.026382446, 0.027130127, 0.026062012, 0.007736206, -0.018798828, 0.045928955, -0.003320694, 0.013900757, -0.0501709, -0.03186035, 0.009605408, 0.03286743, 0.02255249, 0.01940918, 0.05581665, 0.00018179417, -0.051757812, -0.04244995, 0.028274536, -0.052490234, 0.04748535, -0.02230835, -0.035003662, 0.026107788, 0.015296936, -0.034576416, 0.01272583, -0.0048980713, 0.006664276, 0.012817383, 0.062927246, -0.047821045, -0.014633179, -0.039520264, -0.023452759, 0.030715942, -0.05517578, 0.0029506683, -0.024734497, 0.01197052, -0.026489258, -0.0011835098, 0.032409668, 0.052246094, -0.026535034, -0.025726318, -0.0017337799, 0.00831604, 0.04232788, 0.05480957, 0.012107849, -0.047698975, 0.072265625, 0.047698975, 0.014297485, 0.012039185, -0.024765015, 0.031921387, 0.0014657974, -0.047180176, -0.022201538, 0.0007972717, 0.042114258, -0.018234253, 0.018737793, 0.027664185, -0.049835205, -0.050201416, -0.037109375, 0.010185242, 0.00032544136, 0.014007568, -0.021133423, 0.016723633, -0.006843567, 0.0070991516, -0.011581421, 0.012565613, 0.036895752, -0.0070877075, 0.040527344, -0.019607544, 0.05279541, 0.0154418945, 0.0042266846, -0.024673462, 0.00056648254, -0.023071289, 0.041503906, -0.0395813, -0.010391235, -0.05697632, -0.04498291, -0.01727295, -0.02406311, 0.0008058548, -0.054534912, 0.04434204, 0.02772522, -0.013877869, 0.036102295, 0.01234436, 0.043823242, 0.008987427, -0.00022470951, 0.009689331, 0.0048599243, 0.019073486 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09206v1
TableLlama: Towards Open Large Generalist Models for Tables
Tianshu Zhang, Xiang Yue, Yifei Li, Huan Sun
cs.CL
Semi-structured tables are ubiquitous. There has been a variety of tasks that aim to automatically interpret, augment, and query tables. Current methods often require pretraining on tables or special model architecture design, are restricted to specific table types, or have simplifying assumptions about tables and tasks. This paper makes the first step towards developing open-source large language models (LLMs) as generalists for a diversity of table-based tasks. Towards that end, we construct TableInstruct, a new dataset with a variety of realistic tables and tasks, for instruction tuning and evaluating LLMs. We further develop the first open-source generalist model for tables, TableLlama, by fine-tuning Llama 2 (7B) with LongLoRA to address the long context challenge. We experiment under both in-domain setting and out-of-domain setting. On 7 out of 8 in-domain tasks, TableLlama achieves comparable or better performance than the SOTA for each task, despite the latter often has task-specific design. On 6 out-of-domain datasets, it achieves 6-48 absolute point gains compared with the base model, showing that training on TableInstruct enhances the model's generalizability. We will open-source our dataset and trained model to boost future work on developing open generalist models for tables.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09206v1
2023-11-15T18:47:52
2023-11-15T18:47:52
{ "title": [ -0.012420654, 0.00034999847, -0.053985596, -0.09899902, 0.022979736, 0.016098022, -0.07287598, -0.0017051697, 0.035186768, 0.034454346, -0.011985779, 0.0021305084, 0.0036182404, -0.000688076, -0.05834961, 0.024887085, 0.009239197, 0.010604858, -0.03225708, -0.03829956, -0.02507019, -0.046539307, 0.03668213, 0.031982422, 0.0574646, -0.034576416, -0.04434204, 0.012016296, -0.008285522, -0.010864258, 0.010307312, -0.023071289, 0.040893555, 0.015464783, 0.025039673, 0.017501831, -0.03942871, 0.025680542, -0.0034236908, 0.014923096, 0.025177002, -0.010635376, -0.01838684, -0.024261475, -0.04473877, 0.029449463, -0.07171631, -0.024383545, -0.022109985, 0.0602417, 0.012466431, 0.039886475, -0.024765015, 0.046661377, 0.013938904, -0.026550293, 0.019882202, -0.0690918, 0.014289856, 0.066833496, 0.037078857, -0.032592773, 0.013504028, -0.0065727234, -0.05102539, -0.023468018, -0.009429932, 0.012931824, 0.06542969, -0.016082764, -0.027114868, 0.043060303, -0.004131317, -0.01146698, -0.038269043, 0.0043144226, 0.04296875, 0.002292633, 0.014312744, -0.0035514832, 0.019851685, 0.006412506, 0.01134491, -0.036315918, 0.014411926, -0.059570312, -0.014152527, -0.005092621, -0.0059318542, -0.06842041, 0.0027542114, -0.004547119, -0.033569336, 0.031799316, -0.0015459061, -0.022842407, -0.026168823, 0.03012085, -0.012001038, -0.006088257, -0.008171082, 0.024841309, -0.03579712, -0.033599854, 0.020599365, 0.046844482, -0.022644043, -0.04473877, 0.01360321, 0.04055786, 0.0038204193, 0.024993896, 0.0053100586, 0.010231018, 0.02619934, -0.0045547485, -0.03375244, 0.039489746, -0.008842468, 0.029678345, -0.020614624, -0.044647217, -0.012969971, 0.014259338, 0.024551392, -0.00920105, -0.03781128, 0.03829956, -0.024597168, 0.015174866, 0.022460938, 0.04055786, -0.08166504, -0.05960083, -0.043029785, 0.05117798, 0.003944397, -0.02947998, -0.028656006, 0.025680542, 0.0063705444, -0.0044403076, 0.016860962, -0.033111572, -0.002544403, 0.0104599, 0.08660889, -0.01689148, -0.07293701, -0.021224976, -0.054718018, 0.07965088, 0.050842285, 0.0063476562, -0.08569336, -0.03186035, -0.12780762, -0.018432617, 0.012069702, -0.023361206, 0.0019054413, -0.008216858, -0.013175964, -0.046936035, 0.016281128, 0.0016765594, -0.03741455, 0.030578613, 0.0140686035, 0.038879395, -0.034179688, 0.016601562, 0.05291748, 0.009414673, -0.009346008, 0.013786316, 0.014328003, -0.020065308, 0.039123535, -0.034210205, 0.0056114197, -0.0025596619, -0.021835327, 0.07489014, -0.06213379, 0.010345459, -0.0031776428, 0.0017166138, 0.05517578, 0.0070266724, -0.060760498, 0.024169922, -0.045898438, -0.007671356, -0.038482666, -0.041168213, 0.02407837, 0.015037537, -0.0004107952, 0.0071105957, -0.02557373, -0.020599365, -0.029052734, 0.0141067505, -0.009002686, -0.029953003, -0.015037537, 0.007762909, -0.025772095, 0.064819336, 0.06665039, 0.015419006, -0.060516357, 0.042388916, 0.017364502, -0.07720947, 0.027709961, 0.00248909, -0.004283905, 0.011665344, -0.00705719, -0.020385742, -0.004638672, 0.038146973, -0.01676941, -0.00093126297, 0.01108551, -0.0070762634, 0.038513184, 0.022018433, 0.08496094, -0.043762207, 0.025726318, 0.024276733, 0.0071792603, -0.008926392, 0.018051147, -0.016479492, 0.009460449, 0.015098572, 0.0028934479, -0.0104522705, -0.020980835, 0.023452759, 0.048065186, 0.008422852, 0.017349243, 0.007904053, 0.007888794, 0.02418518, 0.040649414, 0.039154053, 0.05343628, 0.0069122314, -0.008514404, 0.06378174, -0.0071525574, 0.015464783, -0.018188477, 0.01625061, -0.0069465637, 0.033843994, -0.0066947937, 0.009460449, -0.061645508, 0.00831604, -0.04034424, -0.00365448, -0.00038337708, 0.018157959, 0.049804688, 0.00031757355, 0.0060043335, -0.0029029846, 0.012504578, 0.026535034, -0.026275635, 0.005004883, 0.025238037, -0.041534424, -0.019821167, -0.015914917, 0.023208618, 0.0013694763, 0.03945923, 0.016555786, -0.0018281937, -0.015716553, -0.010696411, 0.013961792, 0.03479004, 0.042999268, 0.022064209, -0.004512787, 0.01335144, 0.023117065, 0.09082031, 0.062561035, -0.02130127, 0.013572693, -0.0234375, 0.013725281, 0.0010557175, -0.020828247, 0.011604309, 0.025344849, 0.018554688, 0.029403687, -0.018722534, -0.019958496, -0.026550293, 0.022583008, 0.0031986237, 0.002500534, -0.0736084, -0.06762695, 0.0020618439, -0.030639648, -0.02734375, -0.012680054, 0.085876465, -0.031921387, -0.026824951, -0.00016093254, -0.00044298172, -0.029006958, -0.0030288696, -0.0413208, -0.017868042, 0.021331787, 0.03543091, 0.028198242, -0.05984497, -0.03475952, -0.010116577, 0.016098022, -0.034942627, 0.038391113, -0.045562744, 0.0052757263, -0.029647827, -0.03656006, 0.040039062, -0.06994629, 0.014289856, -0.061309814, 0.013938904, 0.010986328, -0.046295166, 0.01449585, 0.01361084, -0.012107849, -0.04272461, 0.0011205673, 0.05432129, -0.0006580353, -0.014587402, 0.0053710938, 0.015357971, -0.03845215, 0.021942139, 0.011016846, -0.0013132095, -0.070129395, -0.013999939, -0.037475586, -0.02279663, -0.013153076, 0.02520752, 0.08062744, -0.043670654, 0.014923096, -0.055419922, -0.020477295, -0.016220093, -0.0066223145, 0.021087646, -0.037719727, -0.04043579, -0.0062408447, -0.015823364, 0.030136108, -0.06567383, 0.038513184, 0.06793213, 0.016921997, 0.014785767, 0.017715454, 0.040130615, -0.0067443848, -0.008087158, 0.0017700195, -0.008987427, 0.0045928955, -0.009025574, 0.021331787, -0.018310547, -0.005836487, -0.07269287, 0.0064048767, 0.05166626, -0.0028858185, -0.030685425, 0.020462036, -0.07208252, 0.060272217, -0.008300781, -0.0033664703, 0.026184082, 0.042785645, -0.008872986, 0.013038635, 0.001540184, -0.038238525, 0.020019531, -0.03552246, -0.08770752, 0.035980225, -0.056121826, -0.018936157, 0.016189575, -0.03201294, -0.048706055, -0.016357422, -0.0034446716, 0.064819336, 0.010673523, 0.03237915, 0.008476257, -0.052093506, -0.00049829483, -0.0335083, -0.024856567, -0.015289307, -0.012199402, -0.013626099, 0.007583618, 0.035461426, 0.020645142, -0.016921997, 0.015426636, -0.0034637451, -0.022598267, 0.038848877, -0.0037384033, -0.03942871, -0.01586914, 0.0047836304, -0.013923645, 0.015205383, -0.023452759, -0.0016727448, -0.030532837, 0.016815186, -0.018417358, -0.0026283264, 0.010261536, 0.0043258667, -0.02017212, -0.013160706, 0.022979736, -0.012557983, -0.07965088, -0.0034332275, 0.028259277, 0.0029506683, -0.0056152344, -0.011390686, -0.0059280396, -0.011314392, -0.03378296, 0.037017822, -0.004257202, 0.012214661, -0.0077705383, -0.016220093, -0.01133728, 0.038604736, -0.06161499, -0.026245117, 0.035461426, -0.0052375793, -0.0056114197, -0.049041748, 0.02659607, -0.0044822693, -0.1116333, -0.038879395, 0.015808105, -0.017700195, -0.02420044, -0.03845215, 0.02368164, -0.009559631, -0.01625061, 0.012283325, -0.026260376, 0.0017957687, -0.0060806274, -0.076049805, 0.0055007935, 0.059143066, -0.027008057, 0.030319214, 0.03024292, -0.02178955, 0.008216858, -0.04220581, 0.006996155, 0.018234253, 0.048980713, -0.026687622, -0.0395813, 0.03137207, -0.033966064, 0.031173706, -0.007434845, 0.028060913, -0.029953003, -0.0017709732, 0.012870789, 0.0085372925, 0.027374268, 0.028961182, -0.000477314, -0.0039634705, -0.0368042, 0.0059890747, -0.032989502, -0.026031494, 0.025100708, 0.021575928, 0.008956909, 0.0073127747, 0.0015172958, 0.038757324, -0.016479492, -0.0096206665, 0.02960205, -0.0068244934, -0.023880005, 0.019866943, 0.050720215, 0.026748657, -0.00016665459, 0.019683838, 0.02748108, 0.066223145, -0.028640747, 0.0003068447, -0.0070114136, 0.009185791, -0.06652832, -0.0046539307, -0.05041504, -0.046539307, -0.043518066, 0.029678345, 0.006969452, 0.008613586, 0.032165527, 0.01663208, -0.054229736, -0.009765625, -0.014770508, -0.01348114, 0.035736084, -0.020111084, -0.0026283264, -0.0061187744, -0.03164673, -0.018188477, -0.020706177, -0.04107666, 0.016662598, -0.0006737709, -0.00059843063, 0.016723633, 0.038146973, 0.040802002, 0.0335083, -0.011619568, -0.047668457, -0.020996094, -0.0073432922, 0.008003235, 0.00071811676, -0.0072021484, 0.013549805, -0.0126571655, -0.015357971, -0.002773285, -0.010025024, -0.038635254, 0.007820129, 0.008544922, 0.041137695, 0.005718231, -0.0033283234, 0.019378662, 0.014305115, -0.02809143, -0.004383087, -0.029434204, 0.003370285, -0.03289795, 0.032226562, -0.012451172, 0.005405426, 0.03491211, 0.009925842, 0.0061073303, 0.023071289, -0.005393982, 0.021484375, -0.006011963, 0.0018672943, 0.038726807, -0.015060425, -0.027114868, -0.00017917156, 0.008911133, 0.032440186, -0.04824829, 0.053131104, -0.0129776, 0.037475586, 0.017501831, -0.020370483, 0.020950317, -0.011489868, 0.02015686, -0.06427002, -0.04385376, -0.00349617, 0.048980713, -0.024765015, -0.003358841, -0.008331299, 0.006893158, -0.007965088, 0.04055786, 0.05078125, -0.0005722046, -0.016616821, -0.035125732, -0.014915466, -0.012329102, -0.0597229, -0.0019321442, 0.014312744, 0.023757935, -0.012359619, 0.00774765, -0.08886719, -0.0112838745, 0.0009965897, -0.0035953522, -0.0049476624, -0.08087158, 0.026153564, 0.06817627, 0.023864746, 0.030166626, 0.017349243, -0.0070343018, 0.026062012, 0.046142578, 0.0071792603, 0.023895264, -0.0066566467, -0.0151901245, 0.011688232, 0.0029945374, -0.0012645721, -0.009414673, 0.041046143, -0.008041382, -0.015274048, -0.015777588, 0.032958984, 0.015380859, -0.0051574707, 0.008056641, -0.050354004, 0.007171631, -0.018630981, 0.0043258667, 0.02229309, -0.036987305, -0.05392456, -0.030334473, 0.0009794235, -0.061279297, 0.046020508, 0.043548584, -0.04977417, -0.04510498, 0.025314331, -0.015716553, -0.0077438354, 0.007949829, 0.025772095, -0.032928467, 0.027038574, 0.020935059, -0.046051025, 0.021392822, -0.0135269165, 0.010803223, 0.04498291, 0.022872925, -0.035491943, -0.00076675415, -0.009292603, -0.06011963, -0.028793335, 0.0015897751, 0.0007901192, 0.00032615662, -0.012863159, -0.02684021, 0.016296387, 0.0061035156, 0.02279663, 0.011367798, -0.026168823, 0.024978638, 0.013191223, 0.016464233, 0.022155762, 0.0005016327, 0.0022888184, 0.013076782, 0.009727478, -0.04574585, -0.0024662018, -0.01701355, -0.014602661, 0.00039219856, -0.05871582, 0.011787415, 0.009788513, 0.009300232, -0.017227173, 0.02947998, 0.027572632, 0.011199951, 0.005908966, 0.00013017654, 0.056427002, -0.021514893, -0.020828247, -0.0027160645, -0.0007710457, -0.04168701, 0.02368164, -0.010223389, -0.0076293945, -0.038330078, -0.03543091, -0.03262329, 0.017730713, 0.034484863, -0.01361084, 0.024337769, -0.046081543, -0.0042266846, -0.0074691772, -0.022323608, -0.017288208, 0.019256592, 0.004901886, -0.018295288, 0.011985779, -0.026367188, -0.0007901192, -0.016723633, 0.0079193115, 0.0013666153, -0.008590698, 0.009422302, -0.0023555756, 0.014755249, -0.044036865, -0.021453857, 0.06616211, 0.009223938, -0.03137207, 0.0524292, -0.023376465, 0.055786133, 0.030899048, 0.02835083, 0.028381348, 0.0011262894, 0.022583008, 0.0029239655, 0.04486084, -0.026870728, -0.0001513958, -0.039215088, -0.0016736984, -0.040618896, 0.0019369125, -0.05493164, 0.00894928, 0.0052452087, 0.015060425, 0.01965332, 0.011550903, 0.03125, -0.0072746277, 0.035949707, 0.005821228, 0.054260254, -0.002664566, -0.0006766319, 0.027816772, -0.021102905, 0.0033893585, 0.04498291, 0.0013399124, -0.008308411, -0.03881836, 0.0046043396, -0.003250122, 0.0033721924, 0.0001784563, 0.0062942505, 0.006137848, -0.020629883, 0.05441284, 0.011123657, 0.051879883, 0.06390381, 0.010406494, 0.02470398, -0.060028076, -0.007881165, -0.0109939575, -0.011047363, 0.005630493, 0.032073975, -0.023864746, 0.01725769, -0.018737793, -0.02520752, -0.00598526, 0.0014820099, 0.057281494, -0.050048828, -0.053131104, -0.017044067, 0.060546875, 0.0038928986, 0.0018634796, -0.03564453, 0.013626099, 0.038848877, 0.015357971, 0.017929077, 0.05230713, 0.04336548, 0.039794922, -0.026489258, -0.03591919, 0.036865234, -0.0309906, 0.027420044, 0.026107788, -0.027191162, 0.072753906, 0.006980896, -0.044189453, 0.045440674, 0.0014362335, -0.09991455, 0.014312744, 0.026412964, 0.07220459, 0.06311035, 0.09844971, 0.031982422, 0.0003142357, 0.0015926361, -0.055389404, 0.020965576, 0.049835205, -0.02659607, 0.014152527, -0.03930664, -0.053131104, 0.021072388, -0.05807495, 0.024551392, -0.034118652, -0.004802704, -0.0047340393, -0.0038452148, 0.055358887, -0.041412354, -0.009689331, -0.014205933, -0.011924744, 0.0021190643, 0.024429321, -0.03262329, -0.03555298, 0.006038666, 0.022918701, 0.00025224686, -0.007850647, -0.008392334, -0.032226562, -0.062316895, 0.0057525635, -0.009239197, 0.036193848, -0.029907227, 0.0047683716, -0.0009975433, 0.0045814514, -0.017929077, -0.08856201, -0.035125732, -0.037963867, 0.0039634705, -0.045837402, 0.01737976, 0.010009766, -0.01966858, -0.030548096, -0.02420044, -0.0004196167, -0.029937744, 0.003686905, 0.01184845, -0.07525635, -0.003774643, 0.00844574, -0.02848816, 0.061401367, 0.032104492, -0.0061073303, 0.023880005, 0.010818481, -0.030349731, -0.03555298, -0.0056037903, 0.02053833, -0.0012140274, -0.0670166, 0.014724731, 0.028900146, 0.035888672, -0.03829956, -0.0317688, 0.040100098, 0.004348755, 0.012260437, 0.040222168, 0.028625488, -0.0109939575, 0.0044517517, 0.012260437, -0.0037975311, -0.043151855, -0.027008057, -0.02909851, 0.05255127, 0.039031982, -0.008956909, -0.021087646, 0.031433105, -0.019302368, -0.007904053, 0.038482666, 0.021530151, 0.021591187, 0.02696228, 0.060577393, -0.05581665, -0.020111084, 0.0021915436, -0.0011634827, -0.015136719, -0.0019283295, -0.012199402, -0.0022068024, -0.03515625, 0.032684326, -0.031585693, -0.06262207, 0.03753662, 0.033050537, -0.0021038055, 0.035949707, -0.020355225, -0.011009216, 0.015159607, -0.007205963, -0.015991211, 0.00762558, -0.002714157, -0.020935059, -0.00844574, -0.01852417, -0.03982544, -0.008308411, -0.049438477, 0.044525146, -0.024368286, 0.00434494, -0.0033893585, -0.019042969, -0.017868042, 0.012825012, -0.01461792, -0.0524292, -0.050750732, -0.038208008, 0.042266846, -0.004917145 ], "summary": [ -0.01928711, 0.00023043156, -0.044036865, -0.041534424, -0.015823364, 0.012054443, -0.09466553, -0.006855011, 0.005622864, 0.040771484, -0.032470703, 0.004108429, 0.005622864, -0.009124756, -0.0011606216, -0.03100586, 0.0074310303, -0.03793335, -0.040985107, -0.036468506, 0.024765015, -0.038635254, -0.020614624, 0.0069618225, 0.03375244, -0.021606445, -0.022521973, -0.018539429, 0.038330078, 0.04852295, 0.018585205, -0.060424805, -0.0010128021, 0.012863159, 0.020935059, 0.024459839, -0.039367676, 0.023986816, 0.0072898865, 0.023025513, 0.040100098, -0.012550354, 0.052490234, -0.012191772, 0.009788513, 0.036499023, -0.00762558, -0.06185913, 0.004787445, -0.0040016174, -0.012680054, 0.06359863, -0.009841919, -0.0027770996, 0.0012283325, -0.0057144165, -0.00793457, -0.01600647, -0.0045814514, 0.06274414, 0.029785156, 0.016540527, -0.009613037, -0.018829346, -0.014205933, -0.006214142, -0.023269653, -0.013061523, 0.06286621, -0.013504028, -0.0065078735, 0.028701782, 0.008270264, -0.032287598, -0.00012743473, 0.0018520355, 0.028656006, 0.017288208, -0.005897522, -0.009925842, 0.025222778, 0.06640625, 0.047790527, -0.07879639, 0.030685425, -0.05883789, -0.0074005127, -0.011260986, 0.011764526, -0.041259766, -0.0011930466, 0.02809143, -0.074645996, 0.03048706, 0.016052246, -0.05480957, -0.0016222, 0.0069389343, -0.034973145, -0.021575928, 0.026260376, -0.023925781, 0.004966736, -0.027069092, 0.0077552795, 0.02949524, -0.030456543, -0.07043457, 0.022918701, 0.034332275, -0.00014340878, -0.012924194, 0.010177612, 0.0031490326, -0.01235199, -0.024917603, -0.04776001, 0.043395996, -0.011383057, 0.023330688, -0.029953003, -0.0030097961, 0.0030612946, 0.051696777, -0.0016412735, 0.023742676, 0.01864624, 0.001953125, -0.0035476685, 0.004425049, 0.02420044, 0.044677734, -0.040039062, -0.027175903, -0.06524658, 0.021011353, 0.022949219, -0.009117126, -0.020736694, 0.014434814, 0.0058631897, -0.005783081, 0.008880615, 0.0053215027, -0.007648468, 0.031311035, 0.072631836, -0.021118164, -0.08538818, -0.049682617, -0.046447754, 0.0925293, 0.03894043, -0.028900146, -0.06707764, -0.08728027, -0.07623291, -0.017990112, 0.05041504, -0.03189087, -0.012741089, -0.006263733, 0.022750854, -0.046295166, -0.050354004, -0.01473999, -0.0104904175, -0.007881165, 0.021347046, 0.0011301041, -0.029388428, 0.023010254, 0.08905029, -0.0068893433, -0.016479492, 0.006298065, -0.05444336, 0.024093628, 0.03463745, -0.06573486, -0.0005674362, -0.023803711, -0.0013427734, 0.045196533, -0.02394104, 0.010345459, -0.022628784, 0.030090332, 0.074401855, 0.018539429, -0.04751587, -0.041992188, 0.009483337, 0.047851562, 0.0011425018, -0.08117676, -0.016952515, -0.021911621, -0.015975952, -0.009635925, -0.00013506413, -0.025131226, -0.0090789795, -0.017929077, -0.04373169, -0.024597168, -0.010154724, 0.017303467, 0.02178955, 0.048187256, 0.0058403015, -0.015960693, -0.033721924, 0.072509766, 0.009986877, -0.034851074, 0.023788452, -0.002796173, 0.012069702, -0.02418518, 0.044158936, 0.0012216568, 0.017105103, 0.04663086, -0.04827881, 0.0027008057, -0.011413574, 0.043945312, 0.0040626526, 0.011352539, 0.06854248, -0.029327393, 0.011108398, 0.035064697, 0.0013437271, -0.0045928955, 0.034332275, -0.05227661, 0.021728516, 0.021850586, 0.0037612915, -0.016616821, -0.062194824, -0.018112183, 0.018356323, 0.03274536, 0.01171875, 0.00466156, -0.009269714, 0.033935547, -0.03475952, 0.013542175, 0.029724121, -0.007873535, -0.022583008, 0.054748535, -0.024368286, -0.0067214966, 0.0074653625, -0.034820557, 0.01637268, -0.01423645, -0.013687134, -0.008575439, 0.007965088, -0.012382507, 0.011528015, 0.00020706654, -0.017700195, 0.00077676773, 0.019989014, -0.014320374, -0.0059509277, -0.02859497, -0.040496826, 0.03781128, -0.0132751465, 0.026855469, 0.03253174, -0.005569458, 0.005344391, -0.025466919, 0.0011129379, -0.008560181, 0.05618286, 0.011314392, 0.0071029663, 0.012580872, 0.015312195, 0.04586792, 0.022872925, 0.044708252, 0.023361206, 0.02003479, 0.017105103, 0.01399231, 0.0758667, 0.041992188, -0.016693115, -0.009811401, 0.03604126, 0.020385742, -0.027832031, -0.0054740906, 0.040008545, 0.0032520294, 0.031173706, 0.039855957, 0.025726318, 0.011413574, -0.035247803, 0.036865234, 0.02508545, 0.10083008, -0.07159424, -0.06585693, -0.015335083, 0.036834717, -0.008987427, -0.0037899017, 0.1270752, -0.022277832, 0.0009274483, 0.001326561, -0.01751709, -0.051239014, 0.037231445, -0.03186035, 0.049316406, -0.0063591003, -0.022399902, -0.010398865, -0.048706055, -0.021392822, -0.005657196, -0.013710022, -0.0034675598, -0.021255493, -0.025299072, 0.029525757, 0.00007253885, -0.041015625, 0.025482178, -0.052459717, 0.0033283234, -0.02268982, -0.005680084, 0.00067281723, -0.009773254, 0.011566162, -0.013122559, -0.008865356, 0.013519287, 0.036712646, 0.03793335, -0.027297974, -0.04324341, 0.00038290024, -0.026397705, -0.051239014, 0.030731201, 0.033355713, 0.015701294, -0.08532715, -0.030349731, -0.036346436, -0.009963989, -0.022872925, 0.04711914, 0.043914795, 0.010185242, 0.05883789, -0.058532715, -0.024230957, -0.013038635, -0.021270752, 0.122802734, 0.024291992, -0.039031982, 0.062805176, 0.029891968, 0.0597229, -0.0619812, 0.023651123, 0.034362793, 0.029876709, 0.018463135, 0.015472412, 0.009567261, -0.016815186, -0.0049591064, 0.009590149, 0.0116119385, 0.0010433197, 0.0033283234, 0.004749298, -0.0390625, -0.005012512, -0.05935669, 0.010345459, 0.049041748, 0.008598328, 0.020507812, 0.0007095337, -0.03062439, 0.06323242, -0.00089740753, 0.010627747, 0.02255249, -0.02017212, 0.035980225, -0.0259552, 0.012123108, -0.027679443, -0.006275177, -0.025680542, -0.060943604, 0.01763916, -0.054260254, 0.031829834, 0.039123535, -0.0053253174, -0.028793335, -0.008407593, -0.015991211, 0.05899048, -0.026657104, 0.041229248, -0.01398468, -0.025527954, 0.0048713684, -0.023834229, -0.024536133, 0.010932922, -0.007183075, 0.06732178, 0.028564453, -0.0073661804, 0.034362793, -0.05496216, 0.022583008, 0.008178711, -0.05130005, 0.01146698, -0.031677246, -0.015571594, 0.013435364, -0.019470215, 0.03225708, 0.07489014, -0.016159058, -0.019363403, -0.0038452148, 0.017852783, -0.047973633, -0.004180908, -0.060791016, 0.034820557, 0.03744507, -0.06427002, 0.010429382, -0.04067993, -0.0395813, 0.022003174, 0.023925781, 0.045288086, -0.076538086, 0.04437256, 0.003774643, -0.053894043, 0.041870117, 0.0025482178, -0.034118652, -0.010925293, 0.011985779, -0.032226562, 0.021987915, 0.03060913, -0.013946533, -0.042633057, -0.026062012, 0.014274597, -0.021621704, -0.037963867, 0.0007491112, 0.002368927, -0.049682617, -0.048095703, 0.0077323914, 0.032409668, 0.026245117, 0.009918213, 0.0395813, 0.0068359375, 0.002199173, -0.0030994415, -0.015602112, 0.086364746, -0.0037174225, -0.06524658, 0.036987305, -0.038238525, -0.052490234, 0.03152466, 0.009475708, 0.006164551, 0.03665161, 0.022979736, 0.004928589, 0.014038086, 0.039642334, -0.022521973, -0.06124878, -0.019363403, -0.00020301342, 0.004180908, 0.017837524, -0.023834229, 0.002708435, 0.008415222, 0.0011053085, 0.02243042, 0.017196655, 0.006263733, -0.0061531067, 0.021118164, -0.009254456, 0.035949707, -0.027130127, -0.0368042, 0.050933838, 0.058563232, -0.035003662, -0.005569458, -0.010299683, -0.031951904, -0.028900146, -0.0015630722, 0.038635254, 0.029754639, -0.02532959, -0.014945984, 0.027267456, 0.062683105, -0.0045700073, -0.0084991455, -0.0025787354, 0.02230835, 0.0014753342, -0.002670288, 0.010322571, 0.010955811, -0.034973145, -0.0309906, -0.043792725, -0.005092621, -0.044830322, 0.05493164, 0.024337769, -0.021484375, 0.024047852, 0.019622803, -0.032043457, -0.005378723, -0.022094727, 0.0071105957, -0.013832092, -0.062927246, -0.050628662, -0.0020141602, -0.023605347, -0.005935669, -0.06542969, -0.055541992, -0.046173096, -0.0038051605, 0.0078125, 0.013061523, 0.0357666, 0.017822266, 0.00299263, -0.015167236, -0.01890564, -0.056915283, -0.038238525, 0.038879395, -0.016586304, -0.014633179, -0.011817932, 0.025863647, 0.008369446, 0.010101318, -0.008117676, -0.06616211, -0.019134521, 0.03213501, -0.0574646, -0.0065193176, -0.024383545, 0.00856781, 0.012779236, -0.011993408, -0.020050049, -0.010002136, 0.053497314, -0.023788452, 0.035003662, 0.0046157837, -0.0045318604, 0.04144287, -0.022918701, -0.01725769, 0.015731812, -0.014404297, -0.0077819824, 0.039367676, -0.025985718, 0.03704834, 0.021987915, -0.006362915, 0.008880615, -0.017547607, -0.0022716522, -0.012069702, -0.03414917, 0.008583069, 0.05819702, 0.011154175, -0.02835083, 0.03930664, 0.014076233, 0.0070266724, -0.02432251, -0.012786865, 0.021911621, -0.0040245056, 0.00969696, 0.017333984, 0.0039711, -0.022506714, -0.012252808, -0.0053100586, 0.010482788, -0.014587402, 0.00087833405, -0.04449463, -0.02180481, 0.025421143, -0.029296875, -0.056365967, 0.01663208, 0.008964539, 0.018432617, -0.0012483597, -0.013839722, -0.0149383545, -0.020004272, 0.002576828, -0.025466919, -0.040802002, -0.024856567, 0.012512207, 0.0047798157, 0.016830444, 0.056915283, -0.0579834, -0.00013375282, 0.03375244, -0.041503906, 0.0236969, -0.020492554, -0.017593384, -0.0124053955, -0.012237549, -0.014030457, 0.016738892, 0.027252197, 0.005493164, -0.0019207001, 0.0020484924, 0.0017652512, -0.008399963, 0.01399231, -0.019042969, -0.014793396, 0.011894226, -0.020370483, 0.02947998, 0.009094238, -0.008270264, -0.033966064, -0.014587402, 0.007926941, -0.0063323975, 0.010848999, 0.024383545, -0.01802063, -0.01739502, 0.034088135, -0.04534912, -0.0112838745, 0.02897644, 0.00030493736, 0.0025482178, 0.00059890747, 0.005268097, -0.05078125, 0.019439697, 0.033599854, 0.026748657, 0.0002387762, 0.0028648376, 0.0050735474, -0.00015592575, 0.0076942444, -0.034362793, -0.056121826, -0.026687622, -0.03237915, 0.012687683, -0.013183594, -0.00440979, -0.0055160522, 0.00484848, 0.006351471, 0.014816284, -0.055480957, 0.020324707, -0.01638794, -0.034454346, 0.027572632, -0.031555176, -0.04055786, 0.02406311, 0.013755798, -0.008506775, 0.007965088, -0.009155273, -0.0030879974, -0.056671143, -0.02268982, -0.007701874, 0.023376465, 0.0010690689, 0.01448822, 0.02331543, 0.021316528, 0.024383545, -0.0028038025, 0.012840271, 0.030853271, -0.02696228, 0.0027923584, -0.002603531, 0.026382446, -0.033447266, -0.040161133, 0.013748169, 0.031799316, -0.0053482056, 0.013374329, 0.015220642, 0.011711121, 0.0015058517, -0.022583008, 0.017456055, 0.00982666, 0.0077667236, 0.04168701, -0.042114258, -0.033691406, 0.002483368, -0.007637024, -0.010879517, 0.07342529, -0.020584106, -0.0026855469, 0.008087158, 0.017303467, -0.012237549, -0.02017212, 0.025222778, 0.03060913, 0.018951416, -0.016448975, -0.021377563, 0.018920898, 0.027038574, -0.040649414, 0.011474609, -0.0040359497, 0.06524658, 0.034301758, -0.018753052, -0.031921387, -0.037384033, 0.02330017, 0.0062789917, 0.028396606, 0.00034856796, 0.025863647, -0.004573822, 0.005039215, -0.0309906, -0.021484375, -0.026153564, 0.03302002, -0.016693115, -0.015548706, 0.056274414, -0.003929138, 0.011428833, 0.029220581, -0.055480957, 0.043701172, -0.00737381, -0.0055885315, -0.013298035, 0.027420044, -0.024291992, -0.0040016174, 0.033935547, 0.0040664673, -0.00044083595, -0.022155762, 0.0064430237, 0.014434814, -0.02494812, -0.0027561188, -0.042114258, 0.010009766, -0.026657104, 0.03503418, 0.025527954, 0.037353516, 0.02998352, -0.037475586, 0.064819336, -0.061645508, -0.012893677, -0.000040769577, 0.030075073, -0.013702393, -0.0034427643, 0.037628174, -0.0023498535, 0.004299164, -0.015464783, 0.04437256, -0.012252808, 0.04598999, -0.039886475, -0.026657104, -0.01651001, 0.021728516, -0.020019531, -0.0027599335, -0.029312134, 0.017440796, 0.015083313, -0.03729248, 0.03338623, 0.026000977, 0.047302246, 0.030654907, 0.009666443, -0.028396606, 0.026779175, -0.049621582, 0.029449463, 0.026138306, 0.012390137, 0.091796875, 0.0032024384, -0.031280518, 0.030059814, 0.0413208, -0.09625244, 0.022201538, 0.05508423, 0.071777344, 0.07348633, 0.0736084, 0.0017766953, 0.024841309, 0.047729492, -0.021347046, 0.03604126, 0.043701172, 0.0076026917, -0.014701843, -0.048034668, -0.01991272, -0.021148682, -0.030807495, -0.00018811226, -0.02633667, 0.003545761, -0.03869629, 0.011306763, -0.033172607, -0.009735107, 0.009757996, -0.033843994, -0.033050537, 0.02696228, 0.05657959, 0.00054979324, -0.009391785, -0.017745972, -0.021987915, -0.021133423, 0.0029468536, 0.03152466, -0.02330017, -0.04119873, 0.039276123, 0.023986816, 0.0690918, -0.025314331, 0.009353638, 0.042297363, 0.02154541, -0.015197754, -0.11981201, -0.030517578, -0.05319214, 0.07116699, -0.035095215, 0.0027275085, 0.014289856, -0.02848816, -0.06958008, -0.006919861, -0.0071754456, -0.034118652, 0.049621582, 0.0118637085, -0.041809082, -0.028533936, 0.020309448, -0.017120361, 0.043151855, -0.017288208, -0.0055236816, 0.045074463, -0.0030174255, -0.0067367554, -0.017501831, 0.006210327, -0.007801056, 0.011268616, -0.036956787, 0.00082826614, -0.011276245, 0.027648926, -0.028335571, -0.03390503, 0.012634277, 0.01828003, 0.030563354, -0.039855957, -0.008384705, -0.030517578, 0.013626099, 0.0096206665, 0.00415802, -0.022521973, 0.03857422, 0.05343628, 0.014205933, 0.0011806488, -0.009521484, 0.005142212, -0.00856781, -0.051696777, -0.025665283, 0.02444458, 0.037231445, -0.0038871765, 0.015945435, 0.031585693, -0.046203613, -0.046813965, -0.018173218, -0.013633728, -0.0090408325, -0.03643799, -0.0022583008, 0.012008667, -0.05960083, -0.02960205, -0.0309906, -0.014335632, 0.023849487, 0.017837524, 0.0035152435, -0.055114746, 0.023269653, 0.01335907, -0.025161743, 0.0035305023, 0.014816284, 0.0023860931, -0.016983032, -0.013801575, 0.007820129, -0.020187378, 0.01071167, -0.078430176, -0.020217896, 0.022262573, -0.021911621, -0.011734009, 0.0067596436, -0.023788452, 0.017196655, -0.008399963, -0.031677246, -0.008224487, 0.0104522705, 0.024215698, -0.03253174, 0.026321411 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09205v1
When Is Multilinguality a Curse? Language Modeling for 250 High- and Low-Resource Languages
Tyler A. Chang, Catherine Arnett, Zhuowen Tu, Benjamin K. Bergen
cs.CL
Multilingual language models are widely used to extend NLP systems to low-resource languages. However, concrete evidence for the effects of multilinguality on language modeling performance in individual languages remains scarce. Here, we pre-train over 10,000 monolingual and multilingual language models for over 250 languages, including multiple language families that are under-studied in NLP. We assess how language modeling performance in each language varies as a function of (1) monolingual dataset size, (2) added multilingual dataset size, (3) linguistic similarity of the added languages, and (4) model size (up to 45M parameters). We find that in moderation, adding multilingual data improves low-resource language modeling performance, similar to increasing low-resource dataset sizes by up to 33%. Improvements depend on the syntactic similarity of the added multilingual data, with marginal additional effects of vocabulary overlap. However, high-resource languages consistently perform worse in multilingual pre-training scenarios. As dataset sizes increase, adding multilingual data begins to hurt performance for both low-resource and high-resource languages, likely due to limited model capacity (the "curse of multilinguality"). These results suggest that massively multilingual pre-training may not be optimal for any languages involved, but that more targeted models can significantly improve performance.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09205v1
2023-11-15T18:47:42
2023-11-15T18:47:42
{ "title": [ -0.034423828, -0.0064697266, -0.058258057, -0.036468506, -0.004310608, -0.02015686, -0.053253174, 0.0011739731, -0.02998352, 0.044555664, -0.017028809, 0.00015354156, 0.02520752, -0.020904541, -0.026672363, -0.0013513565, -0.01576233, 0.054718018, -0.010177612, -0.030380249, -0.004699707, -0.050720215, 0.018493652, -0.0074768066, 0.048339844, -0.059020996, -0.09246826, 0.02406311, -0.03753662, -0.041259766, -0.002784729, 0.04852295, 0.052490234, 0.009338379, -0.021087646, 0.012161255, -0.042114258, 0.010055542, -0.02708435, 0.010551453, 0.020431519, -0.013000488, -0.004989624, 0.005580902, -0.021652222, 0.0009441376, -0.036254883, -0.018341064, -0.008178711, 0.025665283, 0.014297485, 0.017684937, 0.0068092346, 0.010757446, 0.012031555, -0.016403198, -0.009635925, 0.021652222, 0.02999878, 0.052581787, 0.012023926, -0.00699234, 0.0045928955, -0.032714844, -0.023284912, -0.014259338, -0.06137085, 0.030929565, 0.07324219, 0.0024738312, -0.029037476, 0.003435135, 0.0110321045, -0.004814148, -0.072631836, 0.028671265, 0.0039405823, 0.0032100677, 0.07409668, -0.068847656, 0.011802673, -0.012504578, 0.021316528, -0.025604248, 0.030532837, -0.021530151, -0.013908386, -0.0103302, -0.050720215, -0.058929443, -0.01737976, -0.01701355, -0.037597656, 0.0075263977, -0.005832672, -0.032440186, 0.00440979, 0.028717041, -0.019897461, -0.04876709, -0.038726807, 0.039123535, -0.074157715, -0.006816864, 0.025421143, -0.015075684, -0.03543091, -0.0037517548, 0.032196045, 0.050964355, -0.0362854, 0.05831909, 0.01335144, 0.0010652542, -0.011451721, -0.031585693, -0.027069092, 0.03161621, 0.027755737, 0.022369385, -0.0047950745, -0.027496338, -0.0063591003, 0.0064582825, 0.024475098, -0.0020103455, -0.035614014, 0.02406311, -0.0012054443, 0.0519104, 0.019546509, 0.040893555, -0.11804199, -0.09509277, -0.07727051, 0.034332275, -0.0059890747, 0.021209717, -0.025375366, 0.023742676, -0.00089788437, -0.023971558, 0.014411926, -0.0021381378, 0.009559631, -0.015899658, 0.06347656, 0.011650085, -0.04510498, -0.043151855, -0.01838684, 0.020904541, 0.011428833, -0.01953125, -0.047027588, -0.03274536, -0.12841797, -0.023513794, 0.023712158, -0.0049209595, 0.016235352, 0.00035357475, -0.0118637085, 0.011695862, 0.023117065, -0.00006687641, 0.024490356, 0.013137817, 0.009666443, 0.0008559227, -0.021560669, 0.031341553, 0.007255554, -0.0057296753, 0.0017328262, -0.005695343, 0.010223389, -0.010627747, 0.020584106, -0.008132935, 0.0064048767, -0.024520874, -0.0031051636, 0.05621338, -0.06149292, -0.016479492, -0.0057678223, 0.008270264, 0.05908203, -0.0003221035, -0.018875122, 0.013031006, -0.024673462, -0.031921387, -0.023834229, -0.020706177, 0.021896362, 0.021514893, 0.00440979, -0.008369446, -0.01637268, -0.007827759, -0.025863647, -0.000012814999, -0.045196533, -0.03100586, -0.022598267, 0.020706177, -0.015487671, 0.05267334, 0.046905518, 0.011512756, -0.038970947, 0.02507019, -0.01146698, -0.05014038, 0.009773254, -0.008331299, 0.00932312, -0.035888672, 0.024597168, -0.010177612, 0.030303955, 0.044677734, -0.0057640076, -0.0075416565, -0.0020065308, -0.0057754517, 0.022567749, 0.016159058, 0.070373535, -0.03164673, 0.032470703, 0.029190063, -0.0063171387, -0.022613525, 0.015396118, -0.024276733, 0.016983032, 0.0043029785, -0.005104065, -0.059387207, -0.0043411255, 0.03677368, 0.0075950623, -0.02279663, 0.005622864, 0.023590088, 0.02204895, 0.027862549, 0.04611206, 0.008239746, 0.03756714, -0.012054443, 0.02204895, 0.04486084, -0.011306763, -0.039123535, 0.009239197, -0.0096206665, 0.029403687, 0.013412476, -0.031173706, 0.02583313, -0.056274414, 0.0032920837, -0.049621582, -0.017852783, 0.001077652, 0.017929077, 0.03060913, -0.046417236, 0.02178955, -0.008811951, -0.029525757, -0.012962341, -0.009735107, 0.022888184, 0.014778137, -0.045806885, -0.0058517456, 0.052642822, 0.039123535, -0.00422287, -0.010032654, 0.014732361, 0.01902771, -0.025314331, -0.03955078, -0.013320923, 0.049316406, 0.017028809, -0.006401062, 0.0021820068, 0.016906738, -0.0033550262, 0.115478516, 0.074401855, -0.04348755, 0.041107178, -0.033935547, 0.022705078, 0.029464722, -0.043304443, 0.0126953125, 0.017562866, 0.01940918, -0.006504059, -0.045074463, 0.020599365, -0.06188965, 0.009971619, 0.00025367737, -0.026367188, -0.021987915, -0.037475586, 0.0020713806, -0.038330078, -0.024368286, 0.004928589, 0.051605225, -0.0033130646, -0.006717682, 0.015808105, 0.010505676, -0.026290894, -0.005264282, -0.023956299, 0.019454956, 0.011352539, 0.04550171, -0.0069770813, -0.07330322, -0.059417725, 0.00749588, 0.018081665, -0.016357422, 0.011756897, -0.020736694, 0.0014257431, -0.0047950745, 0.003709793, 0.016357422, -0.038146973, 0.022338867, -0.091308594, 0.03753662, 0.0017671585, -0.012016296, 0.0030956268, 0.026138306, 0.007411957, -0.0047912598, 0.017608643, 0.07800293, -0.045532227, -0.04397583, 0.03100586, 0.024856567, -0.0105896, 0.019714355, 0.023742676, 0.0026168823, -0.008285522, -0.012123108, -0.05227661, -0.004146576, -0.00021243095, -0.0115737915, 0.011680603, -0.06555176, -0.026016235, -0.010063171, 0.0019483566, 0.04067993, 0.020492554, -0.00031018257, -0.016616821, -0.0014801025, -0.0044670105, 0.014312744, 0.021850586, -0.0128479, 0.013511658, 0.077941895, 0.00064754486, -0.009788513, 0.0001988411, 0.028671265, 0.006515503, -0.010169983, -0.0385437, -0.047668457, 0.002696991, 0.020721436, 0.020263672, -0.023742676, -0.045684814, -0.08898926, -0.009254456, 0.083496094, -0.021728516, -0.022399902, 0.030395508, -0.070495605, 0.04373169, -0.002532959, 0.007194519, 0.039031982, 0.018447876, 0.009429932, 0.020492554, 0.013748169, -0.024139404, -0.008911133, -0.04510498, -0.11407471, 0.028305054, -0.016021729, -0.026870728, 0.0012464523, -0.027313232, -0.040740967, 0.0067329407, -0.007663727, 0.076416016, 0.024475098, 0.00023436546, 0.030654907, -0.014671326, 0.01625061, -0.013755798, -0.015945435, 0.007587433, -0.0134887695, 0.041931152, -0.0062561035, 0.04196167, 0.02658081, -0.014892578, -0.010955811, -0.0039863586, -0.011985779, 0.022994995, 0.01083374, -0.051330566, 0.0015583038, -0.010498047, 0.0006656647, -0.006793976, 0.00032186508, 0.01259613, -0.04748535, -0.0071868896, -0.032196045, -0.023376465, 0.023956299, 0.011871338, -0.032958984, -0.002067566, 0.012832642, -0.028137207, -0.0076828003, -0.0044670105, 0.020980835, 0.018341064, -0.009689331, 0.0014772415, -0.045196533, 0.022140503, 0.009506226, -0.015823364, 0.0066108704, 0.0018157959, -0.011001587, 0.004432678, 0.003540039, 0.008857727, -0.042816162, -0.017181396, -0.011482239, 0.023635864, -0.0013837814, -0.06756592, -0.00995636, 0.012252808, -0.09649658, -0.054107666, 0.011726379, -0.02798462, -0.017822266, -0.025405884, 0.033172607, -0.035461426, -0.028244019, 0.0031719208, -0.02331543, -0.004711151, -0.0079422, -0.082458496, -0.0026378632, 0.08514404, -0.0077590942, 0.021148682, 0.015129089, -0.029083252, -0.0006046295, -0.030426025, 0.040985107, 0.03277588, 0.028381348, 0.010421753, -0.0119018555, 0.027420044, -0.028030396, 0.014175415, 0.039520264, -0.012741089, 0.009643555, 0.011505127, -0.00024354458, 0.008224487, -0.0015153885, 0.04449463, 0.00077724457, -0.0033473969, -0.027328491, 0.011512756, -0.011291504, -0.013580322, 0.005519867, 0.0029449463, 0.018447876, 0.018127441, 0.007297516, 0.043670654, -0.0055503845, 0.010681152, 0.03378296, -0.028396606, -0.019332886, -0.011924744, 0.008354187, 0.0055236816, 0.004219055, 0.024536133, -0.0035190582, 0.039794922, -0.02508545, -0.013206482, -0.005279541, 0.014144897, -0.050567627, -0.014419556, -0.052947998, -0.06304932, -0.014930725, 0.019302368, -0.0069732666, 0.028671265, 0.034942627, -0.012771606, -0.019515991, 0.0058898926, 0.034820557, 0.012336731, -0.023666382, -0.08288574, 0.014579773, -0.013801575, -0.0637207, -0.05923462, -0.01461792, -0.014404297, 0.019805908, -0.00053977966, -0.015792847, 0.016540527, 0.019348145, 0.036895752, 0.023956299, -0.017852783, -0.033203125, 0.01626587, -0.032440186, -0.027420044, 0.022262573, -0.013572693, -0.008369446, -0.014663696, 0.027877808, -0.020645142, -0.010177612, -0.008605957, 0.042541504, -0.019836426, 0.0579834, -0.045196533, 0.032440186, 0.020324707, 0.013908386, -0.0009407997, 0.0060920715, -0.038482666, 0.0061073303, -0.012435913, 0.038391113, -0.015235901, -0.00036787987, 0.05230713, 0.013725281, 0.023162842, 0.0017852783, -0.023529053, 0.0155181885, 0.023361206, 0.032287598, -0.009170532, -0.0736084, -0.040130615, -0.008399963, -0.020721436, 0.041656494, -0.05847168, 0.023910522, -0.016937256, 0.006450653, -0.0005707741, -0.027328491, 0.031982422, -0.019470215, 0.033569336, -0.04043579, -0.011253357, 0.019943237, -0.004058838, -0.036468506, 0.010978699, -0.016448975, -0.0259552, 0.014205933, 0.025558472, 0.0017766953, 0.018600464, -0.0023269653, -0.018615723, -0.00472641, -0.024536133, -0.04449463, 0.0017004013, -0.011444092, 0.01876831, -0.014183044, 0.023162842, -0.066589355, 0.01751709, -0.03074646, -0.04360962, 0.036956787, -0.091674805, 0.0052719116, 0.07104492, -0.0035972595, 0.046295166, -0.014518738, 0.020614624, 0.03024292, 0.06652832, -0.009674072, 0.028152466, 0.03994751, -0.022537231, 0.014968872, 0.0042381287, 0.019195557, 0.0046844482, 0.027664185, 0.011054993, 0.0054626465, -0.05606079, 0.028717041, 0.037506104, -0.0030384064, 0.03564453, -0.062561035, 0.024337769, 0.010673523, -0.027328491, 0.021636963, -0.04763794, -0.037109375, -0.018875122, -0.021881104, -0.05657959, 0.010696411, -0.025177002, -0.046569824, -0.047058105, 0.026306152, -0.014984131, 0.008491516, 0.00422287, -0.0011415482, -0.04711914, 0.032684326, 0.021591187, -0.038879395, 0.0009498596, -0.016555786, 0.0037708282, 0.039520264, 0.042297363, -0.059509277, -0.008842468, 0.00667572, -0.034820557, -0.041137695, 0.020202637, 0.0060691833, -0.022918701, 0.0019512177, -0.023544312, -0.019515991, -0.0015602112, 0.030471802, -0.023025513, -0.025344849, 0.022064209, -0.008590698, -0.006538391, 0.002368927, 0.02519226, -0.01348114, 0.01637268, 0.019607544, -0.02960205, 0.031402588, -0.010276794, 0.01739502, -0.026184082, -0.02067566, -0.0058059692, 0.028961182, -0.002111435, -0.0029144287, 0.03970337, 0.048065186, -0.0016260147, -0.0041885376, 0.012138367, 0.057128906, -0.053344727, -0.027938843, -0.0014247894, -0.011177063, -0.01826477, 0.048461914, 0.027893066, -0.007369995, -0.04083252, -0.064453125, -0.029510498, 0.010475159, 0.025238037, 0.024719238, 0.03515625, -0.01725769, 0.035736084, -0.03540039, -0.010055542, -0.06707764, 0.036071777, -0.03225708, -0.04837036, 0.011741638, -0.0052337646, -0.017044067, -0.0211792, 0.047943115, 0.059539795, -0.026275635, 0.041503906, -0.07513428, -0.013450623, -0.005455017, -0.042175293, 0.040100098, -0.020004272, -0.0039596558, 0.035614014, -0.049102783, 0.038909912, 0.010971069, 0.04724121, 0.059692383, 0.010879517, -0.0029239655, 0.0009174347, 0.011054993, -0.044311523, 0.016433716, -0.05053711, 0.0014190674, -0.068481445, -0.017990112, -0.09283447, 0.004501343, -0.0018930435, 0.046020508, 0.0048599243, 0.015838623, 0.0007824898, 0.011528015, 0.031921387, 0.020568848, 0.048858643, -0.013793945, -0.0016622543, 0.0056648254, -0.049865723, 0.030685425, 0.04748535, -0.008903503, -0.020950317, -0.0070762634, -0.009315491, 0.0068588257, -0.009902954, 0.007987976, -0.00705719, 0.0024089813, -0.020309448, 0.0146484375, -0.019104004, 0.03878784, 0.05178833, 0.012260437, 0.009613037, -0.0048179626, -0.018371582, -0.027770996, -0.030029297, 0.0056915283, 0.04156494, -0.08581543, 0.049468994, -0.0058288574, -0.046661377, -0.020584106, 0.04269409, 0.007865906, -0.04586792, -0.03515625, 0.012649536, 0.037109375, 0.039398193, 0.024734497, -0.034088135, -0.019958496, 0.0013389587, 0.046142578, -0.00079774857, 0.03161621, -0.009819031, 0.04046631, -0.011856079, -0.04751587, 0.0071258545, -0.016525269, -0.0063285828, 0.03137207, 0.004917145, 0.0262146, -0.0032615662, -0.029083252, -0.010955811, 0.015068054, -0.0423584, -0.025756836, 0.021133423, 0.025421143, 0.029937744, 0.060150146, 0.0075645447, -0.005634308, 0.0061950684, -0.02607727, 0.031799316, 0.03665161, -0.02104187, 0.030044556, -0.05050659, -0.057006836, 0.03756714, -0.06549072, 0.06677246, -0.040283203, -0.002981186, -0.03942871, 0.054260254, 0.00039839745, -0.052093506, -0.029342651, -0.0143966675, -0.052703857, -0.0039978027, 0.004470825, -0.024429321, -0.010429382, -0.02848816, 0.00035738945, -0.012451172, 0.01625061, 0.021636963, -0.025054932, -0.082092285, 0.03262329, -0.014190674, 0.057617188, -0.044006348, -0.00088071823, -0.009002686, -0.004447937, -0.011428833, -0.03149414, -0.009353638, -0.042816162, -0.02973938, -0.06347656, 0.010772705, -0.011413574, -0.022888184, -0.026412964, 0.01651001, -0.013694763, -0.015945435, 0.013435364, 0.032318115, -0.034576416, -0.041625977, 0.004787445, -0.043701172, 0.028076172, 0.0065841675, -0.0058250427, -0.007347107, 0.014289856, -0.031799316, -0.029464722, 0.03302002, 0.052978516, 0.0055885315, -0.050567627, 0.00957489, 0.019256592, 0.050354004, -0.05340576, -0.031051636, 0.009429932, 0.024993896, -0.0053520203, 0.02078247, 0.0031261444, -0.01751709, -0.0036888123, 0.019195557, 0.0019817352, -0.025558472, 0.00005567074, -0.012458801, 0.02810669, 0.049987793, -0.005519867, 0.02029419, 0.039031982, -0.01260376, 0.014404297, 0.015449524, 0.0035095215, 0.0368042, -0.004283905, 0.051818848, -0.019226074, -0.029937744, -0.045959473, 0.01576233, -0.0037498474, 0.02949524, -0.017166138, 0.020004272, 0.003894806, 0.07281494, -0.046844482, -0.06488037, 0.07904053, 0.04815674, 0.007095337, 0.029800415, 0.009895325, -0.0062942505, -0.011985779, 0.001871109, 0.01763916, 0.032989502, 0.0047035217, -0.042510986, 0.017822266, -0.06976318, -0.05987549, -0.0067825317, -0.04208374, 0.042419434, -0.042633057, 0.030593872, -0.021713257, -0.005077362, 0.0024490356, 0.030700684, 0.018295288, -0.020568848, -0.04748535, -0.02116394, 0.04345703, -0.016174316 ], "summary": [ 0.009155273, -0.033050537, -0.028640747, -0.021820068, -0.06185913, -0.010726929, -0.09173584, -0.0024356842, -0.020263672, 0.04840088, -0.01272583, 0.0062789917, 0.032196045, -0.022827148, 0.011993408, -0.0051498413, -0.0039749146, 0.042663574, 0.03111267, -0.010292053, 0.0057525635, -0.027374268, 0.009208679, -0.014572144, 0.0287323, -0.08666992, -0.0637207, 0.030975342, -0.03274536, 0.001698494, 0.010643005, 0.068847656, 0.013572693, 0.01108551, -0.0022029877, 0.0070152283, -0.023986816, -0.0045166016, -0.0019798279, 0.012275696, 0.031234741, -0.014755249, 0.1015625, 0.008178711, 0.02532959, 0.017715454, 0.026855469, -0.05770874, 0.008293152, -0.035125732, 0.008850098, 0.0031967163, 0.025360107, -0.039978027, -0.0056533813, 0.017730713, -0.032684326, 0.04788208, 0.011726379, 0.044830322, 0.0028457642, 0.01171875, -0.0036411285, -0.04232788, -0.00071907043, 0.004081726, -0.019821167, -0.01864624, 0.03781128, 0.014968872, 0.027709961, -0.0104599, 0.021728516, -0.03262329, -0.013153076, 0.033813477, -0.026367188, 0.02368164, 0.0597229, -0.04284668, 0.009757996, -0.018707275, -0.017120361, -0.031280518, -0.0051193237, -0.034973145, -0.0024585724, -0.00089263916, -0.043060303, -0.05569458, -0.028381348, -0.05984497, -0.09851074, 0.06384277, 0.028015137, -0.027908325, -0.015068054, -0.022964478, -0.010940552, -0.05230713, 0.010009766, 0.006969452, -0.04095459, 0.016403198, 0.017028809, -0.033050537, -0.03768921, 0.0020713806, 0.07489014, 0.04714966, -0.018554688, 0.06188965, 0.020111084, -0.01689148, -0.018920898, -0.017990112, -0.015792847, 0.038116455, 0.0070381165, 0.003370285, -0.004047394, 0.038330078, -0.06768799, -0.016433716, 0.023025513, 0.004432678, 0.015914917, 0.047790527, -0.02798462, 0.052215576, 0.00881958, 0.004825592, -0.084228516, -0.017150879, -0.062316895, -0.014213562, 0.0069465637, -0.0027332306, -0.014961243, 0.0062179565, 0.011047363, -0.018295288, 0.028823853, 0.0064964294, -0.005012512, -0.0036678314, 0.019241333, 0.013908386, 0.004135132, -0.029006958, 0.0024852753, -0.023986816, 0.038269043, -0.046417236, -0.014076233, -0.07550049, -0.03704834, -0.015388489, 0.018493652, -0.026687622, -0.028213501, -0.020584106, 0.01713562, 0.0010356903, -0.021026611, 0.020324707, 0.012840271, 0.0038928986, 0.008712769, -0.070007324, 0.0055274963, 0.011695862, 0.01449585, -0.022354126, 0.01096344, 0.009895325, -0.017959595, 0.04168701, 0.029876709, -0.047546387, -0.0023326874, -0.031463623, 0.06939697, 0.016952515, -0.03781128, -0.002363205, 0.008087158, 0.05126953, 0.049835205, 0.009109497, -0.0006227493, -0.049346924, 0.00037765503, -0.010665894, 0.02418518, 0.011871338, -0.046417236, 0.001241684, 0.01448822, -0.03955078, 0.049713135, -0.015159607, 0.0067710876, -0.047332764, -0.082458496, -0.013786316, -0.031219482, 0.03375244, -0.027938843, 0.010940552, 0.031921387, 0.0015010834, -0.043060303, 0.036132812, 0.010757446, 0.020370483, 0.015472412, 0.01386261, 0.05734253, -0.01524353, 0.09100342, 0.0012683868, 0.04989624, 0.03338623, -0.0670166, 0.007572174, -0.01651001, 0.038482666, -0.022781372, 0.0064849854, 0.05065918, -0.007171631, 0.026229858, 0.059753418, 0.002067566, -0.0038051605, 0.027420044, -0.04937744, 0.02810669, 0.0067710876, 0.0036716461, -0.007423401, -0.008041382, 0.045135498, -0.04220581, 0.0009326935, 0.036376953, -0.0018415451, 0.0035171509, 0.011375427, -0.035217285, -0.025665283, 0.030380249, -0.06210327, 0.010955811, 0.037231445, 0.0040397644, -0.067993164, 0.0287323, -0.02154541, 0.035888672, -0.004722595, -0.05267334, 0.030792236, -0.043395996, -0.01826477, -0.039978027, -0.04486084, -0.008026123, -0.0052108765, 0.040374756, -0.049957275, -0.0012969971, -0.026870728, -0.061157227, 0.0031642914, -0.040496826, 0.04107666, 0.010894775, -0.017105103, 0.01222229, 0.07836914, -0.016906738, -0.023086548, -0.010284424, 0.008758545, 0.00020802021, 0.016357422, 0.007083893, 0.02796936, 0.03491211, -0.017211914, -0.008735657, 0.010932922, 0.012413025, -0.020217896, 0.08679199, -0.005218506, 0.0062065125, -0.016143799, 0.03729248, 0.038391113, -0.013702393, -0.0048065186, 0.018966675, 0.010276794, -0.003370285, -0.00007420778, -0.0035934448, 0.0368042, -0.07897949, 0.03866577, 0.030838013, 0.051971436, -0.037322998, -0.01889038, -0.008720398, 0.022994995, 0.0013999939, 0.020599365, 0.07513428, 0.021408081, 0.044708252, 0.016036987, 0.032806396, -0.06628418, 0.03463745, -0.016082764, 0.037719727, -0.020431519, -0.015350342, -0.027709961, -0.045928955, -0.051635742, 0.0107421875, -0.01361084, 0.0025501251, 0.03378296, -0.024871826, -0.0178833, -0.0037460327, 0.010116577, 0.0023345947, -0.0127334595, -0.013366699, -0.039215088, 0.045532227, -0.017440796, 0.0052223206, 0.046569824, 0.002614975, 0.015594482, 0.007331848, 0.049743652, 0.054870605, -0.05407715, -0.049102783, 0.029708862, -0.00088071823, -0.019012451, 0.027511597, -0.006336212, -0.0007081032, -0.024520874, -0.012519836, -0.005004883, -0.018035889, 0.0057144165, 0.013473511, 0.0077934265, -0.03466797, 0.008514404, -0.01322937, 0.004989624, 0.030517578, 0.021133423, 0.09625244, 0.017456055, -0.00737381, 0.057617188, 0.029006958, 0.041259766, -0.011077881, 0.0041160583, 0.08270264, -0.005622864, -0.01109314, 0.033203125, 0.016555786, 0.006916046, -0.030670166, -0.034088135, -0.0041885376, -0.03050232, -0.0029640198, 0.027755737, -0.030578613, -0.08129883, 0.015396118, -0.024215698, 0.097595215, 0.028381348, 0.03225708, 0.03363037, -0.050445557, 0.07519531, 0.016540527, 0.03427124, 0.03274536, -0.016815186, 0.022277832, -0.03656006, 0.020370483, -0.052520752, -0.016098022, -0.031341553, -0.019577026, 0.0040397644, 0.007396698, -0.016296387, -0.040008545, 0.031799316, -0.02229309, 0.0146102905, 0.035308838, 0.07318115, -0.012016296, -0.017349243, 0.011940002, 0.012809753, 0.01008606, 0.005405426, -0.012817383, 0.03302002, -0.010971069, 0.08068848, 0.0033073425, -0.030685425, 0.032226562, -0.060272217, 0.0073013306, 0.008102417, -0.031021118, -0.0074806213, -0.011299133, -0.042541504, 0.0044784546, -0.02178955, 0.024749756, 0.023864746, -0.011444092, 0.001124382, 0.0045204163, 0.0065612793, -0.044647217, -0.020141602, -0.0037899017, 0.012184143, 0.013946533, 0.0049438477, 0.010322571, -0.016479492, 0.018920898, -0.012298584, 0.011161804, 0.07165527, -0.05117798, 0.04208374, -0.02279663, -0.0021400452, 0.05831909, -0.06762695, -0.0006327629, -0.004322052, -0.032348633, -0.035064697, 0.04421997, 0.01890564, 0.010276794, -0.050598145, -0.07336426, 0.039367676, -0.01864624, -0.0748291, -0.03643799, 0.01966858, -0.040008545, -0.03756714, 0.0099487305, 0.051086426, 0.0063171387, 0.017501831, 0.036834717, 0.018157959, 0.005130768, 0.022338867, -0.017715454, 0.06323242, -0.013397217, -0.050231934, 0.00894928, -0.016281128, 0.019012451, 0.020736694, -0.0362854, -0.0020370483, 0.023284912, -0.006641388, 0.022033691, -0.009643555, 0.024215698, -0.02003479, -0.04663086, 0.0055999756, -0.019760132, 0.006175995, 0.009025574, -0.027633667, 0.010635376, 0.008140564, 0.01651001, 0.036010742, 0.020828247, 0.0021152496, 0.009094238, 0.02532959, -0.007003784, 0.025482178, 0.026382446, 0.012626648, -0.016647339, 0.006679535, -0.032196045, 0.0138549805, 0.03149414, -0.02053833, -0.005836487, 0.016571045, 0.026123047, -0.014816284, -0.019638062, -0.012435913, -0.008140564, 0.0031337738, -0.0035171509, 0.025054932, -0.0073661804, 0.027938843, 0.022277832, -0.012069702, -0.009674072, 0.0024776459, -0.0206604, -0.04937744, -0.020385742, -0.019485474, 0.0075912476, 0.013366699, 0.009178162, -0.0073509216, 0.0051116943, -0.026641846, 0.0030784607, 0.041809082, 0.024124146, 0.04623413, -0.087890625, -0.11456299, 0.02557373, -0.013427734, -0.048858643, -0.037078857, -0.03793335, -0.015838623, -0.01335144, 0.0034370422, -0.010475159, -0.014961243, 0.013031006, 0.035186768, -0.014640808, 0.031158447, 0.002166748, -0.031311035, -0.047607422, 0.018356323, -0.013137817, 0.003408432, -0.032196045, 0.01939392, 0.068603516, -0.016616821, -0.027053833, -0.024383545, 0.00573349, 0.04119873, -0.014541626, -0.038604736, 0.0070152283, 0.021606445, 0.016052246, -0.002325058, -0.002981186, -0.013053894, 0.039398193, -0.004261017, 0.009178162, 0.033691406, 0.013679504, 0.03878784, -0.033843994, -0.00044941902, 0.019729614, -0.011169434, 0.03378296, -0.00045228004, 0.054870605, -0.021118164, -0.0345459, -0.05218506, 0.0020999908, -0.014961243, -0.00015103817, 0.012809753, -0.019882202, 0.008979797, 0.034057617, 0.023422241, -0.032073975, 0.006160736, 0.0041007996, 0.010536194, -0.011550903, -0.008903503, 0.009963989, -0.008178711, -0.030029297, -0.03338623, -0.048614502, -0.03744507, -0.0079422, -0.011604309, -0.059265137, 0.03338623, 0.01776123, -0.022613525, -0.0014305115, -0.015670776, -0.01473999, -0.021148682, -0.02897644, 0.013519287, 0.027496338, 0.010810852, -0.012397766, 0.019515991, -0.038330078, -0.037506104, 0.040649414, -0.06512451, -0.07965088, -0.010528564, -0.029571533, 0.01197052, 0.016357422, -0.017333984, 0.0034694672, 0.06021118, -0.03466797, 0.017578125, 0.021865845, -0.004837036, 0.007160187, 0.01576233, 0.028930664, 0.03074646, -0.0076675415, 0.0034446716, -0.014335632, 0.008308411, 0.0026550293, -0.00983429, 0.005908966, 0.008331299, -0.010414124, 0.042388916, 0.014976501, -0.032318115, -0.0051956177, -0.020233154, -0.014251709, -0.007007599, -0.014160156, -0.05114746, -0.0020313263, -0.016830444, -0.04135132, 0.016098022, 0.029327393, -0.00806427, -0.011077881, 0.028030396, 0.00097227097, -0.005344391, -0.008354187, -0.04071045, -0.021408081, 0.005256653, 0.022064209, 0.017654419, -0.012680054, -0.0029964447, -0.041015625, -0.009841919, 0.020126343, -0.013656616, -0.05142212, -0.0077056885, -0.027328491, 0.0036144257, 0.002790451, 0.0023765564, -0.008552551, -0.034423828, 0.005554199, -0.0025405884, -0.021484375, 0.032043457, -0.03326416, -0.040405273, 0.008331299, 0.008300781, -0.032409668, 0.010536194, 0.022201538, -0.03378296, 0.012145996, 0.008842468, 0.013221741, -0.026245117, -0.010353088, 0.0020198822, 0.024551392, 0.0042762756, -0.0046806335, 0.04711914, 0.017837524, 0.022491455, 0.029968262, 0.0071372986, 0.046936035, -0.011650085, 0.013450623, 0.017791748, 0.018585205, 0.008224487, 0.0132751465, 0.011291504, 0.027572632, -0.030090332, -0.057617188, -0.003704071, 0.0061836243, 0.015342712, 0.034820557, 0.023376465, 0.050720215, 0.078125, 0.009185791, -0.031311035, -0.058685303, 0.03427124, -0.039978027, -0.09234619, 0.064819336, -0.009475708, -0.0473938, 0.02645874, 0.012420654, 0.046539307, -0.019577026, 0.08416748, -0.025680542, -0.017852783, 0.0071258545, 0.015930176, 0.007610321, -0.0037612915, 0.0063323975, -0.01600647, -0.022521973, 0.023025513, 0.03765869, -0.01146698, 0.014289856, -0.020126343, -0.014160156, 0.012580872, -0.012687683, -0.01763916, 0.025756836, -0.020080566, -0.014785767, -0.058258057, -0.04534912, -0.037750244, 0.045562744, -0.03414917, -0.009399414, 0.009971619, 0.010551453, -0.013267517, 0.027618408, -0.025527954, 0.029266357, -0.0063171387, -0.020462036, 0.0056381226, -0.013626099, -0.06750488, 0.03805542, 0.060028076, -0.003698349, -0.021087646, -0.005580902, 0.0042495728, 0.015357971, -0.017715454, -0.032714844, -0.057525635, 0.033325195, -0.037597656, -0.0012083054, 0.0118637085, 0.03564453, 0.0053520203, -0.03253174, 0.04650879, -0.010108948, -0.0029640198, -0.0009841919, -0.012672424, 0.02973938, 0.016525269, -0.02571106, 0.028381348, 0.013397217, -0.041229248, 0.009414673, 0.0061683655, 0.039794922, -0.045654297, -0.009155273, 0.004714966, 0.0028800964, -0.0058288574, -0.012290955, -0.037872314, -0.011817932, -0.016967773, 0.0015592575, 0.021972656, 0.0042800903, -0.042236328, 0.03488159, 0.008300781, -0.009841919, 0.020812988, -0.02746582, 0.019104004, 0.03213501, 0.033416748, 0.0027770996, -0.020233154, -0.015411377, -0.023849487, 0.021987915, -0.022598267, 0.0046844482, 0.013427734, 0.046844482, 0.0748291, 0.03942871, -0.030136108, 0.024887085, 0.07373047, -0.041656494, 0.028030396, 0.01474762, 0.0006737709, 0.0026550293, -0.029571533, -0.00033068657, 0.0020484924, -0.03010559, 0.0146484375, -0.059143066, 0.011474609, -0.040374756, 0.02166748, -0.060943604, -0.0132369995, -0.0026283264, -0.032928467, -0.08251953, 0.029953003, 0.05831909, -0.017700195, -0.009994507, -0.020401001, -0.040740967, -0.013122559, 0.008216858, 0.037231445, -0.013504028, -0.048919678, 0.040283203, 0.010322571, 0.08203125, -0.0016822815, -0.016113281, 0.022445679, -0.0082473755, 0.0014410019, -0.062072754, -0.0051116943, -0.03970337, 0.01423645, -0.101257324, 0.05606079, 0.017333984, -0.020858765, -0.068725586, 0.026794434, -0.057037354, -0.024307251, -0.0041046143, 0.048187256, -0.029388428, -0.012527466, 0.002357483, -0.025650024, 0.038146973, 0.0041923523, 0.029449463, -0.0345459, 0.02432251, 0.017074585, -0.010314941, 0.058166504, 0.053649902, -0.014122009, -0.05029297, 0.017364502, -0.01838684, 0.015144348, -0.020523071, -0.014175415, 0.031311035, 0.007949829, -0.012191772, -0.02671814, -0.010398865, -0.028625488, 0.026855469, 0.019729614, 0.00472641, -0.0074539185, 0.034851074, 0.02619934, 0.04748535, 0.0118255615, -0.036346436, 0.052886963, 0.012321472, -0.06439209, -0.020126343, 0.029312134, 0.02519226, -0.007873535, 0.0065689087, 0.021224976, -0.037475586, -0.05987549, -0.030715942, -0.015930176, 0.0036334991, 0.008399963, -0.0055885315, 0.02029419, -0.009155273, 0.04638672, -0.06793213, -0.021011353, 0.045715332, 0.015129089, -0.0129776, -0.032043457, 0.048461914, 0.04324341, -0.019134521, -0.0096206665, 0.013824463, 0.033813477, 0.026397705, -0.055480957, 0.011405945, -0.0859375, -0.018814087, -0.027572632, -0.032958984, 0.022766113, -0.041107178, 0.022109985, -0.0132369995, -0.0006184578, 0.021728516, -0.008117676, 0.012527466, 0.012588501, 0.008216858, 0.003194809, -0.014755249, 0.019241333 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09204v1
Fusion-Eval: Integrating Evaluators with LLMs
Lei Shu, Nevan Wichers, Liangchen Luo, Yun Zhu, Yinxiao Liu, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng
cs.CL, cs.AI
"Evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) is a complex task, especially\nconsidering the intricacies (...TRUNCATED)
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09204v1
2023-11-15T18:46:56
2023-11-15T18:46:56
{"title":[-0.040222168,0.008514404,-0.05178833,-0.05859375,-0.002565384,0.012031555,-0.05065918,-0.0(...TRUNCATED)
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09198v1
"Never Lost in the Middle: Improving Large Language Models via Attention Strengthening Question Ans(...TRUNCATED)
"He Junqing, Pan Kunhao, Dong Xiaoqun, Song Zhuoyang, Liu Yibo, Liang Yuxin, Wang Hao, Sun Qianguo, (...TRUNCATED)
cs.CL, cs.AI
"While large language models (LLMs) are equipped with longer text input\ncapabilities than before, t(...TRUNCATED)
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09198v1
2023-11-15T18:42:44
2023-11-15T18:42:44
{"title":[0.0018405914,0.00018084049,-0.029464722,-0.07305908,0.00042939186,0.0020771027,-0.05209350(...TRUNCATED)
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09194v1
"Structural Priming Demonstrates Abstract Grammatical Representations in Multilingual Language Mode(...TRUNCATED)
James A. Michaelov, Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, Benjamin K. Bergen
cs.CL
"Abstract grammatical knowledge - of parts of speech and grammatical patterns\n- is key to the capac(...TRUNCATED)
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09194v1
2023-11-15T18:39:56
2023-11-15T18:39:56
{"title":[0.012367249,0.008659363,0.0051574707,-0.05166626,-0.030059814,0.0005221367,-0.066589355,-0(...TRUNCATED)

This dataset comprises a collection of the most recent (up to 17 November 2023) 50K arXiv papers' metadata in the computer science category: 'cs.CL' (Computation and Language). Each metadata entry includes the embeddings for the 'title' and 'summary' (abstract) of the paper, generated using Cohere's Embed-v3.

Downloads last month
47
Edit dataset card